AdventAI

A NEW AND SIGNIFICANT DEFINITION.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 41., October 18, 1892

Chief-Justice Paxson of Pennsylvania, has delivered to the grand jury of that State, at the session of the court of Oyer and Terminer at Pittsburgh, a definition of treason against the State, in what promises to be one of the most interesting trials conducted anywhere in recent times. The occasion is an outgrowth of the Homestead riot, thirty-one persons who acted a leading part on the side of the strikers at that time having been indicted on a charge of the above-named crime. In his charge to the jury, Justice Paxson said:—

“Treason is the organization of a large number of men in a common purpose to defy the law, resist its officers, and to deprive any portion of their fellow-citizens of their rights under the Constitution and laws. It is a state of war when a business plant has to be surrounded by the army of the State to protect it from unlawful violence at the hands of former employees. Every member of such asserted government, whether it be an advisory committee, or by whatever name it is called, who has participated in such usurpation, who has joined in a common purpose of resistance to the law and a denial of the rights of other citizens, has committed treason against the State. With the definition of this offense is the designing or overturning of the government of the State. Such intention need not extend to every portion of its territory. It is sufficient if it be an overturning of it in a particular locality, and such intent may be inferred from the acts committed. If you find from the evidence that the defendants have, or any of them has, committed, participated, and aided in any of the acts which I have defined to you as constituting the offense of treason, it will be your sworn duty to find a true bill against the party or parties so offending. We have reached the point in the history of the State where there are but two roads for us to pursue; the one leads to order and good government, the other leads to anarchy. The one great question which concerns the people of this country, is the enforcement of the law and the preservation of order.”

This, with the exception of the trial of Jefferson Davis for the part he acted in the great Rebellion, is the first case of a trial for treason in this country since the historic John Brown, in this same month of the year 1859, was tried for treason and murder at Charlestown; but if the definition laid down by Justice Paxson is upheld, and the indicted persons found guilty, it will be likely to be very soon followed by others. We fail to see how the charge of treason in this case can be sustained. The Homestead affair seems to us to have been clearly a case of riot, like other riots that have marked this age of strife between capital and labor, and no more partaking of the nature of treason than were others that preceded it. Riot and treason are two essentially different crimes. Treason is the highest crime known to the law, and involves a criminal renunciation of allegiance to the sovereign power. Under the United States Constitution treason is defined as levying war against the United States, or adhering to their enemies, giving them aid and counsel. By levying war is meant resistance to the sovereign State through force of arms, by a body of men assembled for the purpose of executing a treasonable design. The distinction between a treasonable and a riotous assemblage of men is in the intent. If the object to be accomplished is of a public nature and looks to the overthrow of the government, there is treason. But an armed resistance to the law by any number of persons for purely private ends, is not treason. We could cite legal authority for these statements, but it is not necessary.

It is the closing words of the quotation from Justice Paxson, however, to which we particularly call attention. “We have reached,” he says, “the point in the history of the State where there are but two roads for us to pursue; the one leads to order and good government, the other leads to anarchy. The one great question which concerns the people of this country is the enforcement of the law and the preservation of order.” Such words, uttered on such an occasion, were almost, if not quite, equivalent to saying that resistance to law was to be regarded as treason. It is very easy to see where this will place seventh-day observers who refuse to comply with the law for the observance of Sunday.

Already the organs of the Sunday-law party are making just such an application of the Justice’s words. The Christian Statesman of Oct. 15 contains a long editorial utterance on the subject, in which it says that the definition laid down by Pennsylvania’s Chief Justice “has a bearing upon the municipal government of all the large cities of this country,” “is a timely document anent the attitude of the Columbian Fair directors on the Sabbath and saloon questions,” and “bears directly on the publishers of the Sunday newspapers of this State.”

And thus out of the utterances of the Judicial branch of our government, and the enactments of its legislative branch, the tide is setting ever more strongly toward the realization of that which is pointed out in the prophecy of Revelation 13.

L. A. S.