The nature and existence of the soul has been the subject of endless discussion by those expert in metaphysics, psychology, and the often more abstruse science of theology, so-called. But human reasonings or imaginations are vain when it is desired to obtain a practical knowledge of a question, the essential part of which exists only in man's relation to his God.
And among those who profess to take the Bible as their text-book there is a wide diversity of opinions and conclusions. Some from the Scriptures confidently affirm the existence of the soul as a distinct constituent of the human individual; others deny the proposition, claiming that the term “soul” applies to the man as a whole only.
There are two great rocks (besides other smaller ones) upon which the ordinary drift of controversy dashes. Confusion and the division of the current of opinion is the consequence. These are, first, the hypothetical position that the term “soul,” as applied to a distinct element of man's nature, implies the principle of inherent immortality. Upon this taken-for-granted ground two false syllogisms are formed: First, The soul is immortal; man has a soul; therefore man has an inherent immortal nature. Second, The soul is immortal; man is mortal; therefore, man has no soul. This logic will not bear criticism for more than one reason; but faulty as it is, it is the basis upon which the vast majority of professed Christians form their conclusions.
The second rock upon which opinions divide is found in the use of the word “soul” in the English Bible. The difficulty is not so much with the Bible or with the original languages as it is with those who undertake to form a specific definition for the term, and then make the various instances of its use in the Scriptures conform to that definition. Some affirm that “soul” exclusively means the immortal conscious element; some that it means the animal life; others that it means the individual; etc., etc. It is vain. The word is used promiscuously as applied to various objects, and interchangeably with various other words. Let us avoid both these obstacles, and the channel is comparatively clear.
In the first place we learn positively, from the Bible, that man is not in possession of immortality in any sense or degree. It pertains to the “King of kings and Lord of lords; who only hath immortality.” 1 Tim. 6:15, 16. It is placed before us as an object to be sought for (Rom. 2:7); and will be bestowed upon the righteous in the resurrection at the second coming of Christ. 1 Cor. 15:51–54. There is not an intimation in the Bible that the soul is immortal, nor an instance in which the term is associated with the attribute, although the soul is repeatedly threatened with death and destruction, and its final salvation is said to be the “end of your faith.” 1 Peter 1:9.
The attribute of continuous conscious existence, or immortality, was attached to the conception of the soul early in the history of the race. The origin of this association was the statement of the deceiver in the Garden, made in direct contradiction to the express declaration of God. “In the day thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die,” said the Lord to our first parents. “Ye shall not surely die,” said Satan, “for God doth know that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened, and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil.” Heathen philosophy and apostate religion took up the proposition laid down by the enemy, and so successfully has it been maintained, that the vast majority of men have received it. The dogma of the immortality of the soul has been placed as the corner-stone of nearly every false system of religion that the world has seen, and alas! it is interwoven into the fabric of the Christian system by those to whom it has been handed down from pagan times.
Turn the search-light of God's word upon the various creeds of Catholicism and Protestantism, and the false and treacherous work of the enemy quickly appears. But so firmly has the error become imbedded in the faith, so intimately has it entwined itself in the affections, that to many people it seems like the rending of heart-strings to separate the hoary fable of the conscious state of the dead and the natural immortality of the soul from the truths with which it has been so long associated. But at last it brings joy and peace to substitute glorious truth for dark, cold-blooded error.
When we break forever the bands of falsehood which unite our conception of the soul with inherent immortality, our first and greatest difficulty is in the past. So doing, we do not dismiss the thought of the existence of the soul as a distinct feature of man's nature; let that stand; it is truth. We do not deny the glorious fact of immortality; we will continue to seek and hope for it at the revelation of Jesus Christ.
The nature of man is threefold. “I pray God your whole spirit and soul and body be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.” 1 Thess. 5:23. The Syriac reads, “Your whole spirit, and your soul, and your body.” Having accepted this fact, the question as to the definition of these terms at once arises, and here we must aim to avoid rock number two. It will be futile, we believe, to try to formulate any definition to which the words “spirit” or “soul” in their Biblical use will universally apply. Let it be borne in mind during this study of the question that such is not the object before us. We take the Scriptural and rational ground that man has a threefold nature, and it will be our endeavor to ascertain and clearly define what those principles are, without insisting upon the name which either shall be called. But for clearness we shall adopt the terms given us in the text last quoted, with the understanding that the terms are not exclusively specific in their application, and that the objects are not exclusively designated by those terms. O. C. T.