AdventAI

NEW YORK CONSTITUTIONAL REVISION.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 39., September 25, 1894

THE subject of constitutional revision has lately occupied the attention of the people and law-makers of the State of New York. The fact that the constitutional inhibition of the United States Constitution regarding the establishment of religion does not extend to the several States of the Union, is becoming very apparent in that State. The numerical preponderancep. 615 and wealth of the Catholic Church in New York have made it comparatively easy for her so to manipulate the affairs of the State that she has already nearly gained the control of all its wealth for her own purposes. Church property being exempt from taxation, that church has engaged in a most lucrative speculation in land near all the growing cities, and church institutions without number have drawn their annual support from the treasury of the State.

Seeing that the whole State would soon be tied hand and foot, and be delivered over bodily to the Catholic hierarchy, and that there was nothing in the United States Constitution or the State constitution of New York to prevent such a catastrophe, it was determined to make an effort, before it should be too late, to retrieve, if possible, the impending disaster. To this end a convention for constitutional revision, composed of delegates duly elected, has just assembled in Albany, the object of those who brought this about being, if possible, to prevent the further encroachments of the Catholic Church upon the treasury of the State.

The struggle which has taken place at Albany has shown to all, what was becoming patent to the more observing before, that the Catholic Church was intrenched in the State of New York, and, what was more, had no intention of yielding an inch of the ground that she had gained. The battle which was fought in the committee was over the question of appropriation of public money for sectarian purposes, and the following statement, which comprises Section 4 of the proposed amendment to the New York constitution, was submitted to the convention:—

“Neither the State nor any subdivision thereof shall use its property or credit or any public money, or authorize or permit either to be used, directly or indirectly, in aid or maintenance, other than for examination or inspection, of any school or institution of learning, wholly or in part, under the control or direction of any religious denomination, or in which any denominational tenet or doctrine is taught. This section shall not apply to schools in institutions subject to the inspection of the State Board of Charities.”

It will be noticed that the exception at the close of the article made a loop-hole large enough to put all the preceding part of the amendment through it; since all that would have to be done to avoid the provisions of the amendment would be to open all Catholic institutions which are supported by the public money to the inspection of the State. Those who were devoted to the non-sectarian idea, amazed at this stultifying exception, went to work and finally defeated it. With this exception removed, the amendment passed by a vote of 71 to 68. Thus the object sought, to prevent the appropriation of public money to sectarian purposes, has scored an apparent victory.

We say apparent victory, for the vote was not final, and there were about fifteen absentees, who will vote another time. And even though this provision shall become a part of the Constitution, when Catholics shall have become more numerous, they will declare that the Catholic Church is not and never was a denomination or sect, but the church, to whom all power is given; and so they will not have to repeal this amendment, but while taking the State funds themselves, they will hold up the constitutional revision as the basis to prevent the Protestant denominations from having any of the public money! The whole Catholic system was developed by just such means, and the end is not yet.

M. E. K.