JUSTIFICATION BY FAITH AND WORKS.
By Thaddeus L. Waters
BY THADDEUS L. WATERS. (Fremont, Mich.) THE following extracts from two of perhaps as noble-minded, large-hearted Christian thinkers as the present age has produced, are so excellent, so to the point, and so brief, that I copied them for the REVIEW. There are many Christian people who are unable to harmonize the expressions of Paul and James; but as both spoke and wrote as the Spirit moved them, they must, like the soprano and bass of a tune, harmonize perfectly together. These explanations, it seems to me, make the subject of justification very clear. Are these expressions of the apostles,—Paul, the apostle to the Gentiles, and James, the bishop of Jerusalem,—as Martin Luther says, irreconcilable? On this question, the following words by Canon Farrar are to the point:— By “faith,” St. Paul never means dead faith (fides informis) at all. He means, (1) in the lowest sense of the word, general trust in God (assensus fiducia); then, (2) self-surrender to God’s will; (3) in its highest and most Pauline sense—the sense in which he uses it when he speaks of “justification by faith”—it is self-surrender which has deepened into sanctification; it is a living power of good in every phase of life; it is unio mystica, a mystical incorporation with Christ in unity of love and life. But this application of the word was peculiar to St. Paul, and St. James does not adopt it. He meant by “faith,” a mere theoretical belief—belief which may exist without any germinant life—belief which may stop short at a verbal profession of Jewish orthodoxy—belief which does not even go so far as that of demons—belief which, taken alone, is so inappreciable in value that he compares it to a charity which speaks words of idle comfort and does not give. Again, by “works” the two writers meant very different things. St. Paul was thinking mainly of those works which stood high in the estimation of his Jewish opponents; he meant the works and observances of the Levitical and ceremonial law—new moons, sabbaths, sacrifices, ablutions, meats, drinks, phylacteries, etc.; or, at the very highest, works of ordinary duty, “deeds of the law,” untouched by emotion, not springing from love to God. He did not mean, as St. James did, works of love and goodness done in obedience to the royal law, those works which spring from a true and lively faith; which must spring from it; which it is as impossible to sever from it as it is to sever from fire its light and heat. And, finally, the sense of the word “justification,” in St. Paul moves in a higher plane than that in which it is used by St. James; St. Paul uses the word in a special, technical, theological sense, to express the righteousness of God, which, by a judgment of acquittal, pronounced once for all in the expiatory death of Christ,419 he imputes to guilty man. St. James uses the word in the simpler sense of our being declared and shown to be righteous, not, indeed, as many have said, before men only, but righteous before God, as those whose life is in accordance with their belief. St. Paul speaks of the justification which begins for the sinner by the trustful acceptance of his reconciliation to God in Christ, and which attains its perfect stage when the believer is indeed “in Christ;” when Christ has become to him a new nature and a quickening Spirit. St. James speaks of the justification of the believer by his producing such works as are the sole possible demonstration of the vitality of his indwelling faith. Briefly, then, it may be said that the works which St. Paul thinks of are the works of the law; those of St. James, the works of godliness. That St. Paul speaks of deep and mystic faith, St. James of theoretic belief; that St. Paul has in view the initial justification of a sinner, St. James the complete justification of a believer.—Early Days of Christianity, bk. 1, chap. 23, pp. 409, 410. Alexander Campbell, the founder of that body of Christians known as Disciples, in his quaint way expresses the same thought. He says:— Faith and works must be apprehended in the apostolic sense before justification by either can be understood in that sense. Sinners are justified by faith, and Christians by works. But this is too laconic for the mass of mankind. It is one thing, however, to introduce a person into a state of acceptance, and another to live acceptably in that state. It is one thing to enter into the married state, and another to make a good wife. Now, faith in God’s promises through Jesus Christ, is argued by the apostles as that which brings men into a state of intimacy, friendship, and familiarity; or, in other words, into a state of acceptance with God. Thus, faith is accounted to a man for righteousness, by the mere favor of God. But the continued enjoyment of such a state is, by the same favor, made to depend upon our behavior. On this principle is founded all the apostolic exhortations.—Christian Baptist, vol. 4, p. 337.