Last August our publishing house at Basel was fined for the eighth time for Sunday work. This fine was three weeks’ imprisonment and 200 francs ($38.45), for the director, or in default, forty days’ imprisonment. From this decision we appealed to the court of appeals of Basel City. The decision of the lower court being sustained here, we carried the case to the Supreme Court.
The appeals to the Supreme Court cannot be presented in person, but only in writing. Our written appeal, with an introduction addressed to the public, was printed, and 50,000 copies circulated in all parts of Switzerland. At the same time most of the editors and a number of legislators and members of the cabinet and the President were visited. The public sentiment was quite favorable, and many articles appeared in the journals, mostly in favor of religious liberty. Some spoke very decidedly in condemnation of the decision of the Basel courts. The appeal was well received by the public, especially French Switzerland.
Scarcely had we finished circulating the appeal, when our case was set for Oct. 10 by the Supreme Court. We were not informed of the date, but learned it from a clerk of the court, a friend of one of our brethren. After reading our appeal, this clerk said that we had a better idea of freedom of conscience than the judges that would have to decide our case.
The Supreme Court of Switzerland consists of fourteen judges, in two divisions of seven judges each. Nine of the judges are Catholics. The second division, before which our case came, is composed of three Protestants and four Catholics. The cases to come before the court are first referred to one of the judges, who is expected to study it, and present it to the court with his opinion. Our case was referred to Judge Blaesi, Old Catholic (the sect of Catholics who reject the dogma of infallibility). Brother Curdy, editor of our French paper, brother Gold, of Lausanne, and I were present at the hearing. Some judges spoke in German, others in French.
Judge Blaesi did not present our appeal in full, but gave a summary of it, and read some portions, especially those that spoke of its being antichristian and papal to use force in matters of religion. His presentation of the case was fair, considering the position which he occupies. His opinion of the case was that the appeal must be rejected, on the ground that our rights of conscience were not violated. The law did not punish us for being Adventists, but for violating the Sunday law, which is civil. The articles of the Constitution which we invoke in favor of liberty of conscience, declare also that religious convictions do not free one from the performance of civil duties. This is in substance his opinion; he did not recognize our argument thatp. 678 it is not a civil duty to rest one day in seven.
The president then called on each of the judges for his opinion. First, Judge Cornaz, Protestant, spoke, stating that although generally denied, it is nevertheless a fact that Sunday laws rest on a religious basis. It is also a fact that the State works on Sunday by exercising its soldiers, and it allows others to work in restaurants, railways, bowling-alleys, hunting, etc. It should, therefore, allow the Adventists to work, who, unlike the Salvation Army, are a quiet, orderly people. The Adventists are right in their appeal, and were it in our capacity, I would move that we sustain their rights. But it is not in our power to do so; this is a question which the Federal Assembly only can deal with; the Adventists must apply to this body for relief.
Judge Bezzola was then called on, and replied in substance that he must differ with the last speaker on the point of Sunday’s resting on a religious basis; it is his opinion that it rests on a politico-social basis, its special object being to secure a rest day for the laborer. Experience has demonstrated that one can better rest on Sunday than any other day because it is the common rest day; the hum and din of business has ceased, while the public places of resort and amusement are open. It would not be inappropriate to rest after having worked by choosing Saturday as the rest day, instead of beginning the week with rest. But we now have Sunday fixed upon as the common rest day, and the Sabbatarians must accommodate themselves to the European social condition. It was his opinion that such public amusements as hunting would also yet be regulated by a federal law, as is already done by some cantonal laws.
Judge Clausen (Catholic) next spoke, stating that Judge Cornaz chooses the Sunday clause of the factory law because it rests on a religious basis; to this I oppose the fact that when the factory law was enacted, both the religious and the politico-social factors were united. It was then found that these two factors could be well united in the Sunday-rest question; and they may continue to be so united. Viewing the general state of things in the Confederacy, we must admit that the church still has something to say. We do not reason here as they do in some parts of France; but even there, they must bow to the demands of Sunday.
Judge Stamm followed, confining himself to legal obstacles in the way, and advised that the case be dismissed on these grounds.
Judge Morel being called on stated that this question must be decided on existing laws. In our constitution we find no principle showing that there should be no work at all on Sunday. After church service, stores are open, commerce does not rest, confectioners for large and small children, and saloons, are open, and have a larger patronage on Sunday than any other day. It has not yet occurred to any one to introduce a Sunday according to the English system, where hacks are not allowed to run, and hotels, except for strangers, are closed. The Swiss people have repeatedly rejected by vote such a Sunday; they do not wish to have custom-house bars erected between the laboring part of the week and Sunday. There is, therefore, neither law nor custom which says that there should be no work at all on Sunday.
But there is the desire to have as far as possible a common rest day. We already have cantonal laws requiring Sunday rest. But what is most important for us is Article XIV. of the factory law; this the appellant has violated, and thereby also the Basel Sunday-law, which requires quite strict Sunday observance. Therefore the decision of the Basel court is not unconstitutional.
Judge Blaesi, the one who presented the case, spoke again, replying to the point of Judge Stamm, that our case should be dismissed because it was not in the province of the supreme court to decide on the unconstitutionality of a law. He said that he would have treated the case from this standpoint; but he thought a more thorough consideration of the case necessary, inasmuch as it concerned an important question of freedom of conscience, which has been printed in a pamphlet and recently widely circulated.
A vote being now taken, it was unanimously decided to reject the appeal. The costs will be borne by the State.
The fact that the costs are laid upon the State is a favorable feature, showing the good-will of the court. We attended the hearing of other cases, and in each case the appeal was rejected, and the costs laid upon the appellant. We had scarcely any ground to hope for a favorable decision; our chief object in appealing was to spread the truth. In this we were not disappointed, for the question was discussed everywhere, and in some places elicited considerable warmth in our favor. It remains to be seen what turn sentiment will take now that the court has spoken. With many this will be final; but there are others who will grow more zealous in our favor. One gentleman remarked that if the Supreme Court decided against us, he would be the first to take up the matter of petitioning the Federal Assembly in our favor.
Our appeal has had a good effect on our own people as well as the general public. During my stay of nearly seven years in this field, I have seen nothing that has so stirred things as what has taken place during the past few months. Our people are manifesting a courage unknown to them before. We go forward rejoicing, knowing that He who is at the helm will direct all things to his praise. H. P. HOLSER.