I SEND herewith for the REVIEW a few “Sparks from a German Anvil,” which we might call a “Sunday Anvil,” if it were not for the fact that the extracts are from a long series of articles entitled, “The Evangelical Church and the Social Question.” In this series the writer—probably Mr. Stöcker, the court-preacher, as the articles are published without name in the Deutsche Evangelische Kirchenzeitung, his organ—says many good things on what he calls the negative side of the question, under which he discusses liberalism, socialism, materialism, and kindred topics, and then comes to his “positive side,” under which he treats of the plan of salvation, Christ, the Christian’s stewardship, the family in its various phases, etc., and finally brings Sunday to the front, about which topic he lets the sparks fly right and left; a few of these I have gathered for the benefit of our American readers, to show how the Sunday movement progresses over in the Old World, in the eyes of its friends. For the sake of brevity I will forbear making any further remarks, but give you the cream of the things said:—
We propose, That the Sunday rest be enforced by a legal enactment, prohibiting professional labor, as far as this is possible to carry out, excepting only such cases where from the nature of things it will be impossible to enforce it, or where necessity compels work.
The numbers who fight for the observance of Sunday in Germany, are constantly and rapidly growing. Parties who are otherwise separated by radical differences, are united on the Sunday question. The ecclesiastically minded Evangelicals, the Catholic center, the Social Democrats, have all the same watch-word: We want the Sunday; the movement for Sunday is economical and at the same time religious. It will gain the victory finally, even though but gradually. . . .
It is evident from all that could be and has been said, how warmly and vigorously we must stand up for our Sunday. In what way is this to be done? Many would do it on this platform: Sunday is the commandment of God, and must therefore be kept! But this position has not been able to find any theological bottom, and must, therefore, be discarded, for the sake of being truthful, however mighty a lever it would be for an agitation.
Only three scriptures speak of the Sunday in the first church—Rev. 1:10; 1 Cor. 16:2; Acts 20:7; but none of these says one single word about Sunday rest. . . . The Sabbath commandment, as such, is for us at an end; if it were still in force, we would have to join the American sect of Saturday Adventists, who are trying to introduce Saturday again, instead of Sunday, into christendom.
But our view is confirmed by the practice of the oldest church, which kept the Sabbath along with the new Sunday, as something separate from it, but above all by the position of Dr. Luther, who, as is well known, does not say one word in his little catechism about Sunday rest, but says in the large catechism:—
“Therefore this commandment—the Sabbath law—does not concern us at all any more, according to our rude understanding as Christians, for it is a wholly external matter, like other ordinances of the Old Testament, that were dependent on peculiar customs, persons, times, and places of those ages, which are now all, through Christ, left free.”
“Hence we can say that we stand in no other relation to the Sunday than to any other wholesome institution not commanded in the Holy Scriptures; but with this, one would not do full justice to the Sunday, for, in the first place, the choice of one day in seven is, on biblical grounds, much older than the Mosaic law,—Gen. 2:2, 3,—and there is another leading motive for its observance, which existed already at the time of Moses, too, and this is the necessity for rest, every one day in seven, which we must consider a gift of the Creator. Deut. 5:15. Perhaps we could express it in this way: Sunday rests upon a natural necessity, which the Christian recognizes as made by God, namely, the necessity for nature to have one day in seven for rest.”
“And whilst Monday, or Tuesday, or any other day might furnish this rest, the facts in sacred history and in the Sunday traditions would for all christendom let any other day, to be kept, appear as a strange freak. It must be this very Sunday.”
“On this ground, as much as we can see, the Evangelical Church must stand up for its Sunday most energetically. . . .”
“To secure a more general Sunday rest will, on the one hand, be the task of a private endeavor, on the other, a matter of government regulation. . . . Without the backing of a popular current in favor of Sunday observance, the very best of laws would be only half executed. But to be sure, on the other hand, without a state law, all private endeavor would be mere patch-work. We need a law, not like our Sunday laws hitherto, which aim at external rest on the streets, but which enforces the real rest of hands, and feet, and heads. Such a law will be a Christian mercy on all the people. . . .”
“The family and the Sunday: these are two words about which a Christian movement of the people can be brought about, and around which they will rally as soon as they are pronounced with force and soberness. We do not seek after vague and misty ideals, but for clear points on which to proceed; we have before us a moral and a legislative task. . . . Let us have a far-reaching Sunday law, and the condition of even the lowest spheres of the people will be essentially ameliorated. To be sure, this will cost sacrifices, but there can be no real Christian progress without sacrifice.”
I have been very busy trying to finish “Vol. IV.,” so that I have not had the time I could wish to write; but I hope next year to find more time to send you sparks from European Sunday forges, and chips from the Sunday workshops.
AUGUST KUNZ.