Aids for Bible Readers

14%

Review and Herald Publishing Association · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Feb 13, 1908

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 85, No. 7.

Read the full edition

Aids for Bible Readers

Historical quotations and extracts from various writers which may assist the thoughtful student of the Scriptures.

The Catholic Reformation and the Authority of the Vatican

MORE important than the views which the Vatican may espouse or denounce is the motive principle of this new crusade against heresy,—the assumption that the Vatican has authority to declare, through the “Holy Inquisition,” what shall or shall not be held true, whether in criticism, history, or science,—the claim of the Vatican to exercise, by divine right, a despotic power over men’s intellects, forbidding to the faithful all true liberty of thought. Are we, or are we not, prepared to grant this claim? The whole question turns on that.
The Vatican is wise in forbidding genuine research into the meaning of the Scriptures, and in laying down an “orthodox” view of the early history of Christendom. For nothing is more certain than that a candid study of the Scriptures, a sincere examination of early history, will cut at the root of the Vatican’s assumptions. The claim of intellectual despotism is wholly unwarranted by the words of Jesus himself, and by the whole spirit of his teachings; it is wholly unwarranted by the words and conduct of the apostles; it is unwarranted by the early practise of the church. This claim grew up, I am entirely convinced, as a part of that process by which the Bishop of Rome assumed the title of Sovereign Pontiff, till then worn by the Roman Cæsars, and with that title assumed much of the Cæsars’ power. And this claim of intellectual despotism has always gone hand in hand with civil persecution, and with the assertion of political suzerainty over Christendom.
Let us begin with the heart of the matter. Where do we find Jesus claiming despotic authority over men’s intellects, and demanding that they shall renounce their convictions? Where do we find Jesus countenancing civil persecution? Can we imagine Jesus, in the black robe of the inquisitor, dragging forth “heretics” by the hundred, and burning them at the stake? Can we think of Jesus organizing a bloody crusade against the Waldenses, and hurling “mother with infant down the rocks”? If Jesus would have authorized these things, why did he not do them himself? Why did he not summon the twelve legions of angels and drive Herod from Jerusalem, setting up the “temporal power” in the City of David?
Has he not given the answer himself: “My kingdom is not of this world.” Jesus does not say: “Whoever dares to think otherwise than I, let him be anathema;” he does say: “Come unto me, all ye that labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me; for I am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls.” Jesus does say: “He that hath my commandments and keepeth them, he it is that loveth me: and he that loveth me shall be loved of my Father, . . . and we will come unto him, and make our abode with him.” And does not Jesus specifically command his disciples to be subject to the political power of the state, even though that power was pagan and idolatrous: Reddite ergo quæ sunt Cæsaris Cæsari: et quæ sunt Dei, Deo?”},{