THE “CATHOLIC MIRROR” ON THE SUNDAY-CLOSING

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 23, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 34.

Read the full edition

THE “CATHOLIC MIRROR” ON THE SUNDAY-CLOSING.

We have had occasion at different times to make extracts from the Catholic Mirror, generally for the purpose of adverse criticism. But the Mirror is not entirely devoid of common sense, and upon the question of the Sunday-closing of the World’s Fair, it has all the time maintained a thoroughly American and consistent position; and simple justice to the Mirror demands of us that we should recognize this fact. As an illustration of the general teaching of the Mirror upon this much-contested subject, we give the following extract from an editorial of July 30:—
“To close the art and non-mechanical departments on Sunday, which is the only day on which so many thousands will have an opportunity to visit them, would be an injustice and shame.”
“Sabbatarian bigotry, however, is as blind as bigotry in its other forms. Surprising is it that those who are thus acting with the idea of keeping the Sabbath holy, do not see that the course they insist upon will be the very one to embitter thousands against Christianity and religion. Deprived of their rights in this way, they will see in the system which forces this wrong upon them, something odious and intolerable.”
“Sunday-closing, as we have already pointed out, will do infinite moral harm to many visitors to Chicago; for, not being permitted to go to the Fair, they will visit worse places. The saloons and evil resorts will be crowded with persons in search of amusement, and in the low dives of the city a saturnalia of wickedness will reign.”
“The blunder on the part of Congress is to be regretted, and all the more, since it was not made from the impulse of principle. The members simply had not the courage to resist the pressure of the fanatical element which urged the Sunday-closing, and in yielding must have done so with a secret feeling of shame for their own want of moral fortitude.”
We give the above all the more readily, because if any one knows the authority for keeping Sunday, and how it should be observed, it is the Catholic Church. The observance of Sunday is simply an old pagan practice which the Catholic Church, by some church locus pocus, turned into a Christian holiday. They never thought of turning it into a Sabbath, and never have tried to do so, but have contented themselves with observing it something after the manner of the heathen from whom it was borrowed. Hence, Sunday in countries where Catholicism prevails, is more of a holiday than a strict day of religious worship, which accounts for the difference between what is called the “European Sabbath” and the “American Sabbath.” The thought of the first day of the week becoming the Sabbath never occurred to the apostate (not apostolic) fathers of the church who manipulated the change. Upon this point Chambers’s Encyclopedia remarks:—
“By none of the fathers before the fourth century is it [Sunday] identified with the Sabbath, nor is the duty of observing it grounded by them either on the fourth commandment or on the precept or example of Christ or his apostles.”—Art. Sabbath.
The observance of Sunday in its original conception as a holiday among Christians had no reference to the fourth commandment, and no one knows this better than the Catholic Church. But the Protestants, especially of this country, have not been perfectly satisfied with the Sunday as it came from the hands of those who made it and established it upon a holiday basis. They feel the need of a real Sabbath such as God established, and not having the courage to take up the rejected Sabbath of the Lord, they try to put a sanctity hitherto unknown, upon the Catholic holiday, and call it the Sabbath, enforcing it by the authority of the fourth commandment,—something the Catholic Church never thought of doing. Not only do they try to make Sunday the Sabbath, but they desire to enforce it with pharisaical and puritanical strictness upon all people indiscriminately, without respect to race or religion. Thus they go to greater lengths in enforcing a Sabbath, which they have made themselves out of the Catholic holiday, than even the Catholics themselves can go. What can we say when Protestants carry the spirit of intolerance to such lengths in the enforcing of doctrines peculiarly Catholic that even Catholics are ashamed of them? This is like out-heroding Herod, and being more Catholic than the pope!
M. E. K.