AdventAI

THE SHADOW AND THE SUBSTANCE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 34., August 23, 1892

In the 2nd chapter of Colossians, the apostle Paul speaks of certain things, “which,” he says (verse 17), “are a shadow of things to come; but the body is of Christ.” Here the present tense is used for the past; for the apostle is speaking of a state of things which existed previous to the crucifixion of Christ; and all shadows have now ceased. The sense is, “which were [before Christ] a shadow of things to come.”

Some of the things which composed this shadow are enumerated in the preceding verse: they were sabbath days, new moons, holydays (or feast days, distinct from the sabbaths), drinks and meats. Verse 16. These had all disappeared in Christ, as a shadow ceases when the substance which cast it is reached. For this reason he told the Colossians that they were not to let any man judge them with respect to these things; that is, they were not to be suffered to lay any obligation upon them in regard to them, nor to condemn them if they did not observe them.

To the Hebrews Paul stated further what constituted that shadow of things to come. In Heb. 10:1, he says: “For the law having a shadow of good things to come, and not the very image of the things, can never with those sacrifices, which they offered year by year continually, make the comers thereunto perfect.” Here again the present tense is used for the past; for that had all passed away, when this was written to the Hebrews, and the sense is that the law spoken of could not, while it was in force, with only such sacrifices as they had, make any one perfect, however strictly he might follow it.

In Heb. 9:9, 10, the same thing is again referred to: “Which [the Mosaic tabernacle] was as a figure for the time then present, in which were offered both gifts and sacrifices, that could not make him that did the service perfect, as pertaining to the conscience; which [service] stood only in meats and drinks, and divers washings, and carnal ordinances, imposed on them until the time of reformation.” Again, chapter 7:18, 19: “For there is verily a disannulling of the commandment going before for the weakness and unprofitableness thereof. For the law made nothing perfect.”

“The law” spoken of in these passages certainly cannot be the moral law; for there was not about that the least element of anything that was typical or shadowy. All its principles were in existence, and its Sabbath was specially instituted, before it was possible for a type or shadow to exist; that is, before the fall of man. And it was never necessary to disannul the moral law for something better to follow.

But there was another system called “the law,” which consisted of regulations concerning meats, drinks, holydays, new moons, sabbaths (yearly), gifts, sacrifices, divers washings, and carnal ordinances, which could make nothing perfect, the weakness and unprofitableness of which existed in itself, and which was disannulled to make way for something better.

In other passages the apostle tells us how this law, in respect to which we are not now to be judged in any particular, was disannulled. Thus, in Eph. 2:15, we read: “Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances.” In Col. 2:14, he states the same fact: “Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross.”

That it is the typical and ceremonial law that is referred to by the expressions “law of commandments contained in ordinances,” and “the handwriting of ordinances,” and that that is what was nailed by Christ to his cross, we know, because it is for the reason that Christ has blotted out and nailed something to his cross, that no man is to judge us in reference to meats, drinks, and all that constituted a shadow, of which Christ’s work is the body; and the book of Hebrews shows that it was that law which had sacrifices and offerings that was a shadow of good things to come. This, then, is what is spoken of in these passages, as being blotted out and nailed to the cross; not the moral law, nor the Sabbath of that law.

But it may be said that Col. 2:13 speaks of the forgiveness of sin, which is the transgression of the moral law; and why does not verse 14, and onward, therefore have reference to the same thing? Why is there such a sudden transition to the ceremonial law?—A moment’s consideration of the situation will show why the apostle frames his argument in this way.

It appears from verse 8 that the church in Colosse, like that in Galatia, was troubled with Judaising teachers who taught that unless they were circumcised after the manner of Moses, they could not be saved. Acts 15:1. The Jews had fallen into the error of supposing that their system of worship, of which circumcision was the test and token, would really take away sin; and they made it of immense importance, teaching that unless one was circumcised, he could not be saved; and, conversely, that if he was circumcised, and kept the law of Moses, he would be saved. When the gospel as presented by Christ was introduced, of course so important a matter as that on which salvation depended, could not be discarded, and so some imagined and taught that the two systems could be amalgamated, the chief features of each being retained; for it was certain of the Pharisees who professed to have embraced the gospel, who were causing all the trouble with regard to the law of Moses. Acts 15:5. With them every convert from the Gentiles must adopt circumcision and other features of the Jewish system.

But all this had then become obsolete, and was of no more account than the superstitious observances of the Gentiles, which were always apostasy. So the apostle labors to show the Colossians that it is not necessary to go through the Jewish system to reach Christ and salvation. He calls this “the rudiments of the world,” in verse 8, just as in Gal. 4:3, and bids them beware lest any man spoil them through it. He tells them that the fullness of the Godhead dwelt in Christ bodily, and that in him they are complete. He informs them that in Christ they have the true circumcision made without hands, and consequently don’t need the Mosaic rite. He shows them that by baptism they have shown their faith in Christ, and that he has quickened them with the new life of the gospel, and forgiven their sins. Then he shows that Christ has blotted out, by nailing to his cross, that very system to which these Judaising teachers were trying to turn them. Now we can see why he introduces it as he does. Christ is the only source of life and forgiveness; it is not to be attained as these teachers claimed, through circumcision and the law of Moses, where the Jews were seeking it. From the darkness of heathenism they could come directly to Christ, as well as from the then obsolete system of Judaism; and they might as well stay in the former as to adopt the latter.

The terms of verse 15 doubtless refer to the great exaltation and importance attributed by those Jewish teachers to that system which had passed away. Satan, working with the wisdom of over four thousand years’ experience, and with the energy of despair, would of course try to make that a rival and obstacle to the work of Christ. But the successful accomplishment of the sacrifice upon the cross was a complete despoiling and nullification of all the false systems which the powers of darkness would try to build up in that line. On the cross Christ openly triumphed over them.

But if verse 14 refers to the ceremonial law, the Jewish system, it may be asked in what sense that was “against us,” and “contrary to us.” These expressions are applicable to it when contemplated with reference to the finished work. That system was only a temporary arrangement. In itself it made nothing perfect (Heb. 7:19; 9:9; 10:1), hence to make that perpetual and eternal, would be only a farce. It was weak and unprofitable. Heb. 7:18. It was a yoke which they were not able to bear. Acts 15:10. It was “imposed on them until the time of reformation” (Heb. 9:10), or until the seed should come. It was contrary to, and against, us, just as the staging and scaffolding is against a building, after the structure is completed;

It is then, after having served its purpose, an impediment and an offense, and must be removed. It was the enmity between Jews and Gentiles, the middle wall of partition, which Christ broke down and abolished. Eph. 2:14-16.

A careful study of these scriptures, and a clear understanding of the relation of the two dispensations as therein set forth, would save many from the error they have fallen into with reference to the perpetuity of the moral law. It was the ceremonial law, not the moral, that was nailed to the cross.