CHURCH AND STATE SOPHISTRY

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 1, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 43.

Read the full edition

CHURCH AND STATE SOPHISTRY.

The Christian Statesman, an organ devoted to principles, which if carried out will result in the practical union of the government of this country with the church, in a late number lays down some propositions of what it considers to be the proper relation of the State and the Church toward each other. We will give them, as a fair specimen of that religio-politico sophistry which is so assiduously at work to undermine the religious freedom that has always been the boast of this country:—
“It is the State’s duty to suppress open idolatry, as Asa did in Judah; it is the Church’s privilege to enforce the worship of the true God within her pale. It belongs to the State to punish blasphemy, to the Church to sanctify God’s holy name. It belongs to the State to prohibit all public Sabbath desecration; it is upon the Church to consecrate the day to God.”
Let us analyze these statements, and see to what their acceptance would inevitably lead if adopted and carried out to their logical conclusion. We will first notice the statement about King Asa: “It is the State’s duty to suppress open idolatry; it is the Church’s privilege to enforce the worship of the true God within her pale.”
It is a common thing for these zealous National Reformers (?) to refer to the kings of Judah for examples of what the authorities of this country ought to do. But what reason have we for believing that the kings of Judah, good or bad, are to be our examples of government? The Bible certainly does not say so, and the United States Constitution recognizes no authority higher than the people. The Constitution of the American Republic rests no more upon the laws or customs of the Jewish theocracy than it does upon the Justinian code. But suppose the United States should undertake to imitate King Asa and suppress “open idolatry,” what would be the result?
The Statesman is a great friend of the Chinese in this country. Every step which has been taken by Congress to regulate or prevent their immigration to our shores has been opposed by that paper as being a great wrong. Now it is a well-known fact that the Chinese are veritable worshipers of idols. Their Joss houses are a common sight in San Francisco and other cities where they congregate. Should this government begin, like Asa, to “suppress open idolatry,” it would at once interfere with the religious practices of the Chinese in a way actually to drive them out of the country. This would not be treating them as we want them to treat our countrymen who are in China, and certainly would be a departure from the Golden Rule. The spirit manifested in such a law would be anything but Christian. Moreover, if we have a right to force the Chinese to give up their peculiar manner of worship while in our country, and to expel them if they will not do so, because their acts of worship are not in harmony with the generally received religious impulses of the people of this country, how could we blame the Chinese government if it should retaliate by expelling from China our countrymen there who worship Christ,—a worship of a divinity new to their country and not having the sanction of the authorized traditions of their race? If such an aggressive policy in regard to religious matters should be inaugurated by this government, the Chinese here would surely have “to go,” and China, acting in the same spirit, and with more show of reason, since she would be the aggrieved party, would have ample justification for a decree of banishment of all American worshipers of Christ within her domain. We suspect that in such a case Christian (?) people here would ask that the United States navy be at once sent to China to protect American citizens in their rights to worship God in that heathenish land!
But why stop at the worshiping of images? Indeed, the Statesman did not particularly mention image-worship. An inspired apostle has declared that covetousness is “idolatry.” The same writer also refers to persons “whose God is their belly.” This being the case, the man who is openly and notoriously covetous and gluttonous, is just as much an idolater in the sight of God as is the person who actually bows before an image and worships it. Then, according to the governmental policy outlined in the Statesman, if we only had a man at the head of this government like King Asa, the covetous and the gluttonous would be promptly arraigned before the courts; and if the covetous man would not agree to forego his covetousness, and the glutton to accept some simple diet recommended to him by the court, condign punishment, either of fine, imprisonment, or banishment, would at once be inflicted upon him.
Again: if “open idolatry” is a crime against the State, why is not secret idolatry also a crime? And as it is the State’s manifest duty to ferret out and punish crime, whether it be public or private, such a policy would result in a veritable Inquisition, and every attempt to make it appear less than this, is an attempt to conceal the final results of such a policy. All this, and much that we have not space to mention, is implied in the statement that “it is the State’s duty to suppress open idolatry.”
Returning to the first principle again, as bowing to an image is an act of worship of what is believed by the worshiper to be the Deity, government has no more right to “suppress” such worship than it has to suppress any other worship, and any attempt to do so would be an infringement upon natural rights. Not that it is right to worship an image, but every man has a right to worship one if he wants to; for as far as worship is concerned, he is not amenable to civil law; for he breaks no law of civility by so doing. In matters of worship we are free moral agents, and to our own Master we stand or fall.
We will now notice the next quotation: “It belongs to the State to punish blasphemy, to the Church to sanctify God’s holy name.” Now while the Church has an undoubted right to discipline a member for profaning the name of God, it does not necessarily follow that the civil authorities are bound to take cognizance of the case, and have the man arrested, and fined, or otherwise punished for so doing. If that should be the rule, the State would be nothing but the tool of the Church to punish her refractory members, and the civil law would be bound to inflict the punishment she should demand. Such an understanding of the relations of the Church and State has caused the death of thousands of noble men. The persecutions of the Baptists and Quakers in the early days of New England was the result of this mistaken idea, which was a relic of the State-and-Church theory of the Old World. While it cannot be the rule that whatever is condemned by the Church should be punished by the civil law, there are many things which the Church condemns that civil law should condemn and punish. The Church condemns murder. The State also condemns it, but not because it is condemned by the Church, but because it is a breach of civility, and an infringement of the rights of man,—of the right of a man to live. So of theft, so of the commission of any act which distinctly trenches upon another individual’s civil rights.
But there is a distinction between the duties of civility—duties which we owe to our fellow-men—and duties of worship which we owe to God alone. We are to “render therefore unto Cæsar [civil government] the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.” To reverence God’s name is an act rendered to God, and civil law should not enforce it; for with it, by right, it has nothing to do. Its place in our laws is a relic of the Church-and-State union of past ages. Public opinion does not enforce it, and if it should be repealed, there would be no more profanity than there is now.
In some portions of our country it is unlawful to deny the doctrine of the Trinity. The District of Columbia has such a law. This law goes so far as to prescribe penalties for those who worship the same God whom the law-makers worshiped, because their conceptions as to his unity and divisibility did not harmonize with theirs! This shows that such laws are contrary to human rights, and should be repealed.
In the light of the principles above enunciated, let us look at the Statesman’s third proposition: “It belongs to the State to prohibit all public Sabbath desecration; it is upon the Church to consecrate the day to God.” We cannot indorse either of the above statements. If we believe the Bible, we must believe that God himself consecrated the day, and while it is possible for man to profane it, it is impossible for him to consecrate it, or make it more holy than it is already. This is a sufficient reason why no man or set of men can make a Sabbath. The Church cannot consecrate a day; it can only accept with gratitude the Sabbath God has appointed.
Now we will look at the other point in question: Does it “belong to the State to prohibit all public Sabbath desecration?” In this case the State would first have to decide what day is the Sabbath,—a purely religious question upon which there is as much dispute as there is as to what is baptism. Government has no right to decide such a question. When it does so, it is transcending the powers granted it in the Constitution. To understand properly this question, it is only necessary to ask, Is the observance of the Sabbath an act of worship to God or an act of civility to our fellow-men? The fourth commandment, which is the indisputable basis upon which all Sabbath-keeping rests, places its observance upon the basis of fealty to God. “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” The reason is based upon God’s work of creation, “for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth.”
That Sabbaths are observed as acts of worship to God, and not out of respect to man’s rights, is amply proved by the words of Paul, “He that regardeth the day, regardeth it unto the Lord.” Although we do not understand that Paul was especially speaking of the weekly Sabbath, the rule of worship here laid down covers all Sabbaths,—they are to be rendered to the Lord and not to men. Then what has civil law to do with the enforcement of Sabbath-keeping? Properly, it can do nothing; for it is not within the province of civil law thus to do. And it is easy to be seen that it encroaches upon human rights to enforce such laws. Keeping the Sabbath is of itself an act of worship. Enforced Sabbath-keeping, then, is an act of enforced worship, and enforced worship is as abominable in the sight of God as is any other constrained and heartless service. Such a law, if enforced, robs the conscientious observer of any other day than the one prescribed by law, either of his money or his time; for if he disobeys the law, he is compelled to pay a fine or go to jail, and if he obeys the law, and at the same time carries out his own religious convictions, which he must do to be an honest man, he pays a fine to the constituted authorities of fifty-two days of his time every year,—days of enforced idleness, which is a positive damage both to himself and to the State. It therefore follows that a Sabbath enforced by the law is religious tyranny, as has already been amply proved in this country, and while this remnant of church legislation is still upon nearly all the statute books of the States of the American Union, the exemption clauses in many of the States show that there was a doubt in the minds of the law-makers whether they had a right to enforce such a law upon the people, especially upon those whose religious faith led them to observe another day.
Such laws are not in accordance with the genius of American civilization, and the supreme court of California has very properly declared such laws unconstitutional. The action of President Harrison in signing the bill to close the Columbian Exposition on Sunday at the demands of the religious press, who have acknowledged that the press of the country as a whole was against such closing, is a surrender of the civil power at the demands of the church, and will in all probability be the means of his losing many thousands of votes of laboring men, whose rights are thus cruelly ignored.
Thus does clericalism labor hard to enforce its religious dogmas upon the people, but liberty should be awake to the dangers of such a movement, that the principles of civil and religious liberty guaranteed to us in the Constitution may be preserved.
M. E. K.