AdventAI

[So many are calling at the present time for evidence that this passage is genuine, that we reprint the following from the Review of Jan. 28, 1890. It is denied only by certain Age-to-come believers, in the way of whose theories it directly stands:—]

When a text of Scripture stands directly in the way of a person’s cherished theory, his first desire is, naturally, to get it out of the way by some means; and if he can find a doubt expressed by some one in regard to its genuineness, or it chances to be omitted in some manuscript, that is enough; he henceforth throws it out as an interpolation.

Rev. 20:5 is one of the troublesome texts to certain Age-to-come theories, and an effort is made to dispose of it in the manner above suggested. The text reads: “But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.”

In this passage and its context the doctrine of two resurrections is plainly taught; first, that of the people of God, and, secondly, that of the wicked a thousand years later. For though only the martyrs and such as gain the victory over the beast and his image are here distinctively mentioned, the first resurrection will include all the saved; for Paul says that all who sleep in Christ are the ones first raised. 1 Thess. 4:16. And again he says, “Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ’s at his coming.” 1 Cor. 15:23.

But Age-to-come theories, which have Christ reigning on this earth, and subduing his enemies during the thousand years (a theory which we showed in No. 1, present volume, to be a whole dispensation one side of the mark), cannot brook the idea that at the end of that period a vast multitude of the wicked are raised from their graves to undo all the good work which their thousand years have accomplished. Hence the desperate efforts made to get this text, by some hook or crook, out of the way.

The author of the “Millennial Dawn” insists that the text in question is an interpolation; and the only ground he presents for the assertion is that it is not found in the Sinaitic manuscript, which, as reported to us, he claims was discovered in 1869-70.

There is some mistake about this; for as early as 1844 Tischendorf visited the convent of St. Catharine, at Mount Sinai, when he discovered a portion of the Sinaitic manuscript. He made subsequent visits, and by 1859 had secured the whole codex for the royal library at St. Petersburg. (See Tischendorf’s Sinaitic MS., published by the American Tract Society, 1866, Cassel’s Bible Dictionary, McClintock and Strong, etc.)

In regard to the omission of the text, the Emphatic Diaglott says nothing about its being omitted in the Sinaitic, though it does notice its omission in the Vatican MS., but says:—

“These words were probably omitted by oversight in Vat. MS., as they are found in A. B. C.—though not in the Syriac.”

Alford, in his New Testament, gives the text in full, but says nothing about its being omitted in the Sinaitic MS., though he consulted that manuscript, for he notes its variations in other places. In his New Testament for English Readers (Lee and Shepard, Boston, 1872), in notes on Rev. 20:5, after quoting the text, he says:—

“I cannot consent to distort its words from their plain sense and chronological place in the prophecy on account of any considerations of difficulty, or any risk of abuses which the doctrine of the millennium may bring with it. Those who lived next to the apostles, and the whole church for 300 years, understood them in the plain literal sense; and it is a strange sight in these days, to see expositors who are among the first in reverence of antiquity, complacently casting aside the most cogent instance of unanimity which primitive antiquity presents.”

If the Dean talks thus of those who simply misinterpret the text, what would he say of those who presumptuously attempt to throw it out altogether?

But there is other evidence on the genuineness of this passage, besides the early manuscripts; and that is the writings of what are called the Ante-Nicene Fathers. These antedate any manuscript whatever. They quote and comment upon many of the passages of the New Testament; and whatever passage is thus taken up by them, is shown to be one which was accepted as genuine by them. One of these was Tertullian, who wrote about the close of the second century, having been born A. D. 160. In Vol. III, p. 431, of his writings, the text is quoted as it stands in the English version, and recognized as a genuine portion of the book of Revelation.

It is, doubtless, such considerations as these which have led all modern critics, like Meyer, the great German commentator, and the authors of the Revised Version, to retain the passage as genuine. And for one in the face of such evidence to insist that the passage is an interpolation, and try to get rid of it that way, because it interferes with a cherished theory, is not a mark of either candor or scholarship.

But even if it be granted, for the sake of the argument, that the passage should be left out, is the matter made any better even then for the Age-to-come theory?—We cannot see that it is; for it must still be conceded that there are two resurrections, with a space of time between them which cannot be inferred to be any other than the thousand years. It is not claimed that the last clause of Rev. 20:5 (which reads: “This is the first resurrection”) should be omitted. Then we have this testimony (verse 4, last clause): “And they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years. [Verse 5.] This is the first resurrection. [Verse 6.] Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection, on such the second death hath no power, but they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years. [Verse 7.] And when the thousand years are expired, Satan shall be loosed out of his prison, [Verse 8.] And shall go out to deceive the nations which are in the four quarters of the earth,” etc.

When it is said: “This is the first resurrection,” it is just as clearly said that there is to be a second resurrection at some subsequent period. When it is said that those who have part in the first resurrection are blessed and holy, it is just as clearly said that they who have part in the second resurrection are unblessed and unholy, that is, the wicked. When it is said that on such; that is, those who have part in the first resurrection, the second death hath no power, it is just as clearly said that on the other class, the wicked, who have their part in the second resurrection, the second death will have power, or destroy them.

Paul also makes the same distinction between the two classes, the righteous and the wicked, in the resurrection, stating that only those who are Christ’s are raised at his coming, consequently leaving the wicked to be raised at some subsequent time; for all, both righteous and wicked, are to be raised. Acts 24:15. Thus in 1 Cor. 15:22, 23, he testifies: “For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive. But every man in his own order; Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ’s at his coming.” In verse 52 of the same chapter, he says: “The trumpet shall sound, and the dead shall be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.” It is only the righteous dead who are to be raised incorruptible; therefore the resurrection at the last trump, when Christ appears, is to be confined to this class.

Again: in 1 Thess. 4:16, he says: “For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God; and the dead in Christ shall rise first: then we which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air.” Here the only ones who are spoken of as being raised when the Lord appears are “the dead in Christ;” and all of that class are, of course, included.

Here, then, we have the facts: 1. The righteous dead are raised at the beginning of the thousand years; the wicked dead are left to be raised at some subsequent period; 2. The righteous live and reign with Christ during the thousand years; but nothing is said about any other class living till the thousand years end; 3. The wicked then again appear as the nations whom Satan goes out to deceive (Rev. 20:8); for we cannot suppose that these are the righteous who have lived and reigned with Christ during the thousand years; they are not to be deceived by Satan at the end of that period; 4. The wicked are to be destroyed in the second death (Rev. 20:14, 15); but, 5. The second death does not come till the close of the thousand years; 6. Will, now, some one tell us what conceivable reason there could be for raising the wicked dead before the time comes for their judgment and destruction? The idea that they will be raised previous to that time is unnatural and impossible. Therefore even if we leave out all but the last clause of Rev. 20:5, calling it an interpolation, the proof still remains that all the righteous are made alive at the beginning of the thousand years, and that the rest of the dead (the wicked) live not again till the thousand years are finished.

The conclusion, then, is this: 1. That Rev. 20:5 is not an interpolation, but is genuine; but, 2. That no one need try to throw it out on account of the doctrine it teaches; for the same facts are elsewhere clearly taught without it.