WHY IT IS TO BE PREFERRED.
By Wolcott H. Littlejohn
BY ELDER WOLCOTT H. LITTLEJOHN. The readers of the REVIEW are familiar with the exposition of the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, ordinarily presented by those of our faith. In the articles upon that subject just printed in the REVIEW, the writer discusses the question from a somewhat different standpoint. While admitting that the account is a parable, he undertakes to explain how the parable happened to take the form that it did. To the average reader the fact that Christ speaks of Abraham’s bosom and hell, and places the beggar in one and the rich man in the other, furnishes a strong presumptive argument for the existence of such places. To say that the account is a parable and therefore proves nothing here or there, does not at all times satisfy those who have been taught to accept the account of the rich man and Lazarus as a record of historic events. Something more is needed. Before their grip upon that passage can be broken, it is required that some satisfactory reason should be given why Christ put the parable in its present form; that is, why he should have placed the rich man and Lazarus in localities that never had an existence. If this can be done satisfactorily, a long stride will be taken in the direction of capturing the very citadel of the conscious state of the dead.291 The writer of the articles referred to thinks that this can be accomplished to the satisfaction of every candid mind. He takes the position usually adopted by our writers; i. e., that the account is a parable, and then assumes that the parable took the shape of an argumentum ad hominem. An argumentum ad hominem is an argument made from the standpoint of those addressed, and does not necessarily reflect the views of the speaker. In the articles the writer proves that the Pharisees believed in the conscious state of the dead and in the existence of Abraham’s bosom, hell, the gulf, etc. He then proceeds to show that such views are both absurd and unscriptural, and that Christ did not intend to indorse them, but simply employed them for the time being for the purpose of confounding the Pharisees out of their own mouths in the matter of the estimation placed by them upon riches. The writer will be obliged to any one who has read the articles, for any suggestions or criticisms which he may see fit to offer.