THE FIRST-DAY ADVENTIST CONVENTION AT WORCESTER, MASS.
By John Vuilleumier
For quite awhile I had been cherishing the hope of becoming more intimately acquainted with our sister denomination, commonly called “Second Adventists,” or, by us, “First-day Adventists.” I was therefore very glad to improve the opportunity which offered itself to me, of attending their midwinter convention, which was held in this city, Worcester, Mass., beginning Feb. 15, 1892 and closing the 18th. The convention was held in the large meeting hall of the Worcester church. I have no official figures about the number of attendants from the outside. I should judge that some days there were between two and three hundred. The total attendance at some meetings was about five or six hundred. A carefully prepared program announced some thirty written essays on as many theological, pastoral, and practical topics, and three general discussions. Among the subjects indicated were the following: “Foreign Missions, Ministerial Qualifications, Revival Methods, Signs of the Times, The Two Covenants, The Devil’s Lie, Prof. Totten’s Views, The Advent Movement, Conditional Immortality, Present Status of Prophecy, Is the Animal Kingdom in the Redemptive Economy? Modern Infidelity, Educational Interests, Church Organization, Atonement, Adventual Doctrines, Relative Importance of Practical and Doctrinal Preaching.”292 The themes marked out for the general discussions were: The Jew Question, Futurism, and The Sabbath. Among other noteworthy members of the convention were Rev. E. A. Stockman of Boston, chairman of the convention and editor of the official organ of the body (World’s Crisis), of which he is one of the ablest representatives; Mr. I. C. Wellcome, one of the survivors of the 1844 movement; Mrs. McKinstry, the leading lady preacher, and author of an important work on history and prophecy; last but not least, I was pleased to meet Elder D. T. Taylor, one of the leading theological writers of the denomination, an intimate friend of the late Elder J. N. Andrews. He delivered a remarkable address on the “Present Status of Prophecy,” and made a powerful argument against the return of the Jews. Many were the excellent words spoken on the various subjects either of Biblical research or of practical life and missionary activity. Particularly noticeable was a distant echo of the extraordinary days of 1844,—echo which I have heard so many times in our own general gatherings. In a social meeting, a brother said:— I will take off my hat to a man who calls me Christian; I will shake a man’s hand, who calls me a Second Adventist; but I will shake both hands of the man who calls me “an old Millerite.” Miller was sent of God. The waiting for the coming of the Lord in the clouds of heaven is still the key-note of Second Adventism, to judge of it by the convention. But, as in 1844 and since, it is the expectation of an event which is liable to come without any further sign or warning, to-day, to-morrow, as well as in three months or in ten years. Since the day of the disappointment, forty-eight years ago, Second Adventism has had no more landmark on its time-table; and, as it was repeatedly declared at the convention, it knows of no great event predicted to take place between this and the coming of the Lord. Thus, its prophetic compass having ceased, in 1844, to mark the way to follow, to point to the north pole as still in the distance, the denomination is left to seek anxiously in open sea, amid the threatening billows, for an invisible goal! It is obvious from this, that this body of Adventists is to-day exactly where it stood half a century ago, on the morrow after the great disappointment,—amid the distressing search for a solution to that mystery and to the successive disappointments which have followed it. The convention had no solution to offer, no explanation of the past, no date for the future. And yet, logically, the solution of this mystery is a question d’être; for it would seem that the body has no right before the religious world to maintain a separate existence without explaining why the Lord did not come in 1844, if, as they believe, he caused them to proclaim that he would. Nor does the body seem to be entirely unconscious of this critical situation of affairs; it seemed to me that I could catch at the convention many signs of that painful feeling of uncertainty. I will mention one or two. In an able and very warmly applauded address, Mrs. McKinstry undertook to answer some ten or twelve very significant questions, of which here are a few: “Is it important that adventual doctrines should still be preached? Can these doctrines be ignored by us as a body? Have we preached this doctrine until we have lost our spirituality? Is it true that our doctrines are worn out, and that the Salvation Army and the Christian Alliance are the favorites of God?” And again: I said that Second Adventism is still waiting for the Lord to come; but this waiting has an expression of sadness; it is no more the calm, solemn but triumphant, expectation of the former days. This is shown by these words of the chairman of the convention, which are melancholy, their intent to the contrary notwithstanding:— We believed that Jesus would come. He has not come. But he has not recalled his promise. His coming is near. . . . We are not melancholy. We are happy, on the whole. Our King cometh. I was never more anxious to see him than now. I am getting old, they tell me. . . . Yet I hope to live to see him. . . . I believe that some men and women who heard the first cry of the message will see the coming of the Lord. I could subscribe heartily to these last words, as I listened to them. Only I could but think of how much more vivid and hopeful my expectation must be for not being harassed by a fifty years’ long nightmare, and for my having in hand a prophetic guide, perfectly clear and intelligible, without any obscurities or interrogation points on it, marking all the stations of the past, even that of 1844, those that followed until 1892, and also the very few, solemn ones, which still separate us from the great consummation. This unavoidable dilemma of either revising some positions about the 1844 movement or of giving it all up, seems to keep our Second Advent friends thinking, even leading some of them toward what we consider as the solution of the problem. A speaker said:— For many years I have believed that the prophetic periods of the Bible do not tell us the definite time, the year when the Lord shall come. And I think we have made mistakes here. You will think that this is a queer statement for an Adventist to make. But Christ says that even the angels do not know the exact time. And all that Daniel got was through the angel. (True.) The same speaker, it seems, could not help noticing a significant prophecy, closely connected with those relative to the Advent message, but which is still enshrouded in darkness to that denomination. He said:— I will speak this afternoon about Revelation 13. The Crisis does not have much to say about it; the Seventh-day Adventists do. We have many theories about it. But what does this prophecy mean? His new interpretation, however, did not seem to convince many minds of its soundness. He continued:— The two-horned beast is not the United States, by any means. (Laughter.) It is a lineal descendant of Persia, and means Turko-Persia, as sure as the world. (Laughter.) As will have been noticed, the subjects given for the general discussion—“Futurism” and “The Sabbath”—bear directly on the present situation of the denomination. They might very profitably have given rise to the questions: 1. Were there not in 1844, and may there not be now some future events mentioned in prophecy? And if so, are not Seventh-day Adventists correct in believing that the end of the 2300 days in 1844 was not to mark the end of the world? 2. Is the Sabbath of the decalogue, which is the seventh day of the week, the only divinely appointed Sabbath? And if so, are not Seventh-day Adventists correct again in observing it? Alas! these two questions so well chosen, and so boldly placed on the program, were not discussed. Some way or other, the discussion did not come off. I hope it may yet.