THE ARGUMENTATIVE CHILD

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 3, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THE ARGUMENTATIVE CHILD.

MRS. S. M. I. HENRY.
(Sanitarium.)
“WHAT would you do with a boy who will argue about everything that comes up? If I give him a piece of work to do, he wants to do it in his own way, and will stand and argue longer about every point than it would take to do it, if it is of no more importance than the best way to pile the wood in the wood-box.”
Arguing is reasoning aloud with an antagonist, who also reasons aloud; lacking the antagonist, it will soon die out. It is sometimes a sign of ideas, sometimes of self-will, sometimes of a desire to hear one’s self talk.
The argumentative, or reasoning, trait is one of the most necessary, and yet is capable of becoming the most troublesome, of all the mental faculties. It is that by which evidence is weighed, and conclusions are reached; and a conclusion must always be more or less aggressive. Its legitimate place is at home, in the seclusion of one’s own breast. Its processes should never be compelled to be made public; for the method by which one arrives at a conclusion must be anything but quieting; it is like the leavening of the lump. It means disturbance, such as had better be behind the closed door of one’s own consciousness. Argument is almost always best met by silence. Silence is the “soft answer” that turns away, or discourages, this wrathful spirit.
The habit of arguing, once formed, cannot be corrected by counter-argument. No one can argue alone; so the first step in the process of cure is to let the child find out, as soon as he begins to argue, that he is ignored.
If he is given a piece of work to do, he must be allowed to do it in his own way, unless time is taken to teach him your way so that he will comprehend it. You cannot teach him by words until he has come to years of understanding, and perhaps not then by words alone. Your words will very often not mean to him just what they mean to you, so that even if you give him the most minute instructions, in so simple a thing as piling wood in a box, he will find ample opportunity for misunderstanding. Even our most common English words have many shades of meaning to the child who is learning their use.
Let him learn how to do things first by helping you. If he wants to try new, strange, and utterly childlike ways of doing, do not arbitrarily interfere by word or act, such as will bring replies and retorts, unless you are prepared to take time and the necessary patience to make him fully understand you and your methods. But let him experiment; accept his original efforts; and by easy, natural stages lead him on to the more perfect way, even of laying sticks of wood. Do not despise his log-house plan, even if it cumbers the floor for a little while, nor object if he prefers to stand the sticks on end in the box, instead of laying them cordwood fashion. Until you can lead him to see, by actual demonstration, that your way is best, you had better leave him to discover that fact by observation.
But any child who is on confidential terms with his father and mother can soon be aroused to the spirit of emulation which will make him anxious to acquire the best possible manner of doing whatever comes to his hand.
As to the habit of arguing, refuse to answer him in the same spirit; refuse to answer him at all, if necessary. Leave him to talk it out alone to the wood-pile, teaching him by both precept and example, as opportunity affords, how to think it out alone, keeping the reasoning process to himself, and publishing only the conclusions to which he comes by his reasoning; and how to publish them by true and generous acts, and kindly, courteous statements, instead of by brute force, and loud, angry dispute.
The better nature must be nourished and strengthened for conquest in this matter as truly as any other. The lust of notoriety, which is the basis of much public argument, must be as truly crucified as any other appetite, and in the same way, and for the same reason.
But I believe most earnestly in the work of the Holy Spirit on the childish nature, for its renewal and sanctification, so that in all tempers of the mind, as well as all appetites of the body, the young may be kept from ever falling to the low level of wordy contention.
In a family of children where the habit of arguing has developed until all have become involved in a constant war of words, which not infrequently breaks down into actual quarreling, the only hope is in the direct work of the word and Spirit of God, together with proper instruction in politeness and good manners. Children are easily taught in those things that constitute “good form” if they have half a chance to learn. “Be kindly affectioned one to another with brotherly love,” is the Scriptural method; “in honor preferring one another.” Rom. 12:10. “Let all bitterness, and wrath, and anger, and clamor, and evil-speaking, be put away from you, with all malice: and be ye kind one to another; tender-hearted, forgiving one another, even as God for Christ’s sake hath forgiven you.” Eph. 4:31, 32.
Children are copyists always; and of all things, words, tones, and manners of speech are the most readily imitated; and, taking advantage of this fact, any purely external evils can be remedied, even if they have already begun to crystallize into habits, especially if the moral nature has been at all aroused to aid in the work.
The argumentative disposition can be harnessed into parliamentary usages, and so be held by the bit and bridle of the “motion,” the “second,” the discussion “according to rule,” and the final determining power of the vote. The more aggressive the children are in their disputings, the more probable will it be that they can be easily brought under this restraining power; for the whole system of “rules of order” grew out of the necessity, which just such belligerent spirits realized, of making for themselves some sort of harness in which to “work off their steam.”
Some special time, once or twice a month, might be set apart, to which all questions in dispute could be referred for proper discussion; while father or mother might take the chair as “moderator of the meeting” until the children grow up to such dignity.
Discussion among the children need never become offensively aggressive as long as father and mother remain quiet, patient, and just. The children should have such training in these points, while still at home, that as they go out into the world, they will both respect the rights of others to express their beliefs and firmly but kindly speak whatever truth requires of them.