AdventAI

AN IMPORTANT QUESTION, AGAIN.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 17., April 26, 1898

Under this heading, last week, a partial answer was given to an attempt by a Mr. Cope, Methodist pastor in Ingham county, Mich., to show that the seventh day is not the right day to keep for the Sabbath, with an intimation that further notice might be taken of the matter this week, by presenting some of his specific arguments. We do this on the principle brought out by Pope, in reference to vice:—

“Vice is a monster of so frightful mien, As to be hated needs but to be seen,” etc.

So, sometimes the best exposure of error is simply to hold it up to the light of day, that people may get a fair view of it, and thus perceive its folly. He begins by saying:—

“I intend to show that the Mosaic law has no claims on us under the gospel dispensation.”

He may just as well spare his time and labor in this direction; for no one, that we are aware of, claims that that law is now binding. Of course he attempts to hide behind the sophistry that the ten commandments were the law of Moses; but everybody knows better than that. His second proposition is:—

“And I claim that there was no law from Adam to Moses.”

No law from Adam to Moses! Then there was no sin in the world from Adam to Moses! For the apostle is careful to state very explicitly, as if to condemn especially such blind and reckless assertions of those who would pervert the truth, that “where no law is, there is no transgression,” and that “sin is not imputed when there is no law.” Rom. 4:15; 5:13. And another apostle gives us the reason: “For sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3:4. Think of the world being considered without sin from Adam to Moses! What a glorious period of human history that must have been! And yet the very first transgression violated, specifically, eight of the ten commandments, and “brought death into our world, and all our woe.” No law! and yet Cain terribly punished for the murder of his brother! No law! and yet a whole race of men swept off the face of the earth because of their unrighteousness! and remember that “all unrighteousness is sin;” and “sin is the transgression of the law.” No law! and yet the inhabitants of Sodom destroyed by fire and brimstone because of their lust! No law! and yet Laban found cause for accusation against Jacob because he had stolen his goods! We are glad the management of the world from Adam to Moses was not left in the hands of Mr. Cope, if he cannot tell the difference between a state of holiness and such a condition of sin as called down destruction in one case upon the whole world, and in others, upon cities and individuals innumerable. He reminds us of a man who proposed a conundrum to his friend: “What is the difference between an egg and a mule?” His friend gave it up. “Well,” said the man, “all I have to say is, that if you cannot tell the difference between an egg and a mule, you would be a very unsafe hand to send to buy eggs”!

How men who have ever read the Bible, or who have the least conception of the position of God as the moral governor of the world, can make such assertions as that there was no law, and consequently no sin, from Adam to Moses, is utterly past comprehension. Of the folly of calling the ten commandments the old covenant, we spoke last week.

Our author further says: “I intend to show that the decalogue had no penalty attached, only that contained in the ceremonial law.”

But the ceremonial law is not the decalogue; and the penalty of the ceremonial law, when removed with that law itself, does not affect the ten commandments at all. Strange that men cannot, or will not, see that as the moral constitution by which God governs the world, the ten commandments occupy a position as high above every local, national, or ceremonial regulation as the heavens are high above the earth. By that law, as such, the world will be judged in righteousness at the last day. And it will then be found that the law has penalty enough to satisfy the most skeptical. The next minister, in all probability, who attempts to argue against the law will claim that it is abolished because it did have a penalty, and the violation of the Sabbath was punished with death. We are glad Mr. Cope has sufficient discrimination to see that the penalty, as far as it was to be inflicted by man, belonged to a law on a plane different from that of the moral law.

The next plunge is into geology. There could have been no seventh-day Sabbath, it is claimed, because the days of Genesis 1 were immense periods of time, and not simply days of twenty-four hours. The apostle speaks of some “who change the truth of God into a lie.” This geological claim does this very thing. We here enter into no discussion of the speculations of geology. We speak to believers in the Bible; and no one who truly believes and reverences that word will yield up its testimony to the inferences of men on geology.

No one can deny the parallel between Gen. 2:2, 3 and Ex. 20:8–11. Both passages refer to the same time, describe the same event, and use the same terms, which, by every rule of language and all the laws of honest interpretation, must be taken in the same sense. But the day of Ex. 20:8–11 is such a day as Israel had at Sinai,—the twenty-four hour day, common to all history. Therefore the day of Gen. 2:2, 3, must be of the same nature. There is no possibility of avoiding this conclusion. While the word “day” is sometimes, of course, used in a figurative sense, meaning a period of time of a greater or less length, as in Ps. 118:24, referring to the whole gospel dispensation, and in 2 Peter 3:7, referring to the thousand years of the judgment of the wicked, in its ordinary sense, in which it should always be taken, unless for good reasons to the contrary, it means a period of twenty-four hours; and Ex. 20:8–11 is an absolute demonstration that such is its meaning in Gen. 2:2, 3.

There was no sun, we are told, till the fourth day; hence there could have been no days tillp. 270 then. But light was created as soon as the Spirit of God began to move upon the face of the waters; and it then performed the same function that it has performed since God placed it upon the sun on the fourth day, and made that great orb the light-bearer.

He argues that as fish and birds were created on the fifth day, and beasts on the sixth, they must have had time to multiply before Adam named them; hence those days must have been long periods of time. Not at all. Animals were brought forth “abundantly” in the very act of creation. See the record in Gen. 1:20–24.

It is further urged that “no reason could be assigned why God should give man a Sabbath to keep in the garden of paradise.” This betrays the grossness of the writer’s views of the nature of the Sabbath. He would confine it to the mere idea of physical rest; but that is not the leading idea at all. We must not overlook the higher object of the spiritual union and fellowship of man with his Maker, which it is a cardinal idea of the Sabbath to promote. With such low-grade views of the nature of the Sabbath, it is no wonder such arguments as are here under review are urged against it.

The use of the term “Jewish Sabbath,” to describe the weekly rest day, further shows his misapprehension of the nature of the Sabbath; for there is no such institution brought to view in the Bible. It is always the Sabbath of the Lord, not the Sabbath of Jews or Christians, or any other class of national or denominational people. “The first Sabbath that was given to man,” it is further asserted, “was given to the Jews as a memorial of God’s delivering them from Egyptian bondage; and consequently the Sabbath law was binding on the Jews only.” But Genesis, which records the giving of the first Sabbath, does not say any such thing; while the fourth commandment, spoken from Sinai, and graven on the tables of stone, does not give the deliverance from Egypt as a reason for the Sabbath, but makes the Sabbath exclusively a memorial of God’s creative act in the beginning.

Well schooled in the labyrinth of antinomian sophistries and assertions, Mr. Cope dilates on the statements of Hebrews 4 and the experience of Israel at the falling of the manna; but it is needless to follow him further here. The covenant made with Israel at Horeb, and not made with the fathers, was not the ten commandments, because the fathers did have the ten commandments, as shown by abundance of testimony reaching back from that time, even to the creation itself.

Candid reader, what excuse will you give if you refuse to treat the Bible as you would any other book? if you refuse to take its testimony in its plain and obvious sense, except where the construction or context shows it to be figurative? if you persist in joining things together which it makes distinct? if you confound together the moral and ceremonial laws? if you try to confuse the law of the priesthood (Heb. 7:12) with the law of ten commandments, and so pervert the word which God has given us?

Moral law, from the opening to the close of the reign of sin on this earth,—law through which God exercises uniform and impartial jurisdiction among men,—law which is the representative of his will and the standard of his government among his creatures,—law by which, as an undeviating standard of right, men of every age and nation will be judged at last (Eccl. 12:13, 14; James 2:8–12),—is the only consistent, reasonable, and Scriptural view of this subject. And any and all attempts to mar or misrepresent the uniform Bible view of God’s relation to the government of his intelligent creatures will be found to be only quibbles and perversions; and those who use them will have a serious account to give when God shall make inquisition for his truth, by challenging an answer to the question, Who hath required this at your hand?

U. S.