A LATE action of Justice Pryor, of the supreme court of New York, in regard to the right of a corporation to do business on Sunday, is attracting much attention and comment. The case may be briefly described: A Jewish society for some purpose seeks incorporation under the laws of the State of New York. The articles of incorporation specify that the annual meeting of the society will be held on Sunday. Justice Pryor rejects the petition for the incorporation of this society, because of this proposed Sunday desecration. He says:—
The question is not whether such meetings on Sunday are illegal, but whether they should be allowed by a justice of the supreme court. A thing may be lawful and yet not laudable. . . . The Christian sabbath is one of the civil institutions of the State; and the legislature, for the purpose of promoting the moral and physical well-being of the people, and the peace, quiet, and good order of society, has authority to regulate its observance and prevent its desecration. This sanctity of the Christian sabbath is sanctioned and secured by repeated acts of legislation, extending from the colonial period to the present year, as well as by the impressive deliverances of the court of appeals. As justice of the supreme court, I may not approve that which the immemorial and united policy of the State condemns. . . . The legislation of the State against profanation of the Christian sabbath is operative and imperative upon all classes of the community. Because the holding of corporate meetings on Sunday is contrary to the State, if not to the letter of its law, I decline to approve this certificate.
It will be noticed that Justice Pryor does not cite any specific law as a reason for his refusal to grant the petition; but he cites the general feeling throughout the State, beginning from colonial times, which is, in different ways, embodied in the laws of the State. He does not act as a judge; for a judge can only decide what is lawful. He acts in this case as a man, with his own ideas of what is laudable! Very naturally, this action arouses much discussion. Catholic, Presbyterian, and Methodist papers hasten to commend his refusal to allow this Jewish society to incorporate. Jewish papers, of course, are united in their outspoken opposition to Justice Pryor’s action. One of them, the American Hebrew, says:—
We have no wish at the present moment to discuss the legal aspect of the matter, but surely this is enough of the principle that sets down the private meeting of an organization for religious purposes as an aggression upon the Christian sabbath. There are many organizations in this city, such as the labor unions, lodges, and societies established under the authority of the State, which hold their meetings on Sunday without a voice being raised in opposition. Is it simply because the new society is composed of Jews, who do not recognize Sunday as holy time, that their peaceful assembly becomes a menace to, and a profanation of, the Christian sabbath? There is a vast amount of work on Sunday, such as issuing of newspapers, sale of tobacco, etc., much of which does not come under the head of work of necessity; yet these are accorded the protection of the State, while a justice of the supreme court styles a meeting to regulate religious observances among the Jews an aggression upon the Christian sabbath! We really feel inclined to rub our eyes, and pinch ourselves, to see if we are awake; and to take down our geography, and see if New York State has been incorporated into Russia, or if we have been moved back two centuries to the days of the Salem witchcraft.
We are pleased to find that the Watchman, the Eastern organ of the Baptists, takes the following sound position on this subject:—
That may be good law, but for a number of reasons it is not good policy. The Hebrew association should have its rights to incorporate determined by fairly defined conditions, and not by the personal opinions of a judge. Justice Pryor’s labored argument to show that to hold this special business meeting on Sunday is a desecration of the day, will commend itself to many people; but Baptists, who believe in the separation of church and state, will repudiate the justice’s sophistry. This Hebrew association does not interrupt or disturb other persons in their observance of Sunday, which is the ground upon which the application could be rightly denied. The decision is contrary to the spirit of our institutions, and is an instance of petty persecution. We hope that the Hebrew association will carry the case, if that is possible, to the court of appeals. They will find that Baptists all over the country will sustain them.
The whole affair is suggestive of the spirit of our times to exalt Sunday. The fact that it is a Jewish organization which, by this action of Justice Pryor, is not allowed to do on Sunday the very things which professed Christians are allowed to do, seems to be especially gratifying to those who so volubly declare that this is a Christian nation. Thus here and now, as in other countries and in former days, in the name of Christ the Jews are deprived of the most sacred natural rights. It is difficult to tell which is the greater shame,—the false attitude in which Christ and his merciful teachings are placed by these self-styled Christians; or the evil and hardship which this decision causes certain citizens who, under the Constitution, are assured that they are possessed of inalienable rights, which, in defiance of this Constitution, are here threatened by Justice Pryor and others of his class. M. E. K.