AdventAI

A METHODIST ON THE LAW.

By M. E. Kellogg

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 5., February 2, 1897

BY ELDER M. E. KELLOGG.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

The position taken by the Methodist Episcopal Church in its discipline, and the doctrinal works of its representative men, and also by its preachers generally,—that the moral law of ten commandments is still binding,—is so well known that it only needs to be alluded to to be remembered. Some of the finest and clearest statements of the relation of the law and the gospel may be found in the pages of the standard Methodist commentators. To the proposition that the ten commandments are a distinct and separate law from the civil and ceremonial laws of the Jews, both Methodists and Seventh-day Adventists give an affirmative answer. And, further, they also agree that the moral law of ten commandments is binding upon all, but that the civil and ceremonial laws are no longer of force, the civil law ceasing when the Jewish nation ceased to be a nation, and the ceremonial ending at the cross.

So upon the general principles of the obligation of mankind to obey the law of God, we are in substantial and happy accord. The difference between us appears only in the application of the principles. In fact, the line of separation between us and the Methodists in regard to the law of God, comes in regard to the application of one of the ten commandments. We insist in allowing that the fourth commandment, which our Methodist brethren concede to be binding, and which they hold up in the aggregate with the other precepts of the law of ten commandments, should be obeyed just as literally as the rest of the specific law with which it is associated. We no more dare to assert that “the seventh day,” which that commandment declares is the Sabbath, can be any other day than the seventh, than we would that the parents we are required to honor are some other person’s parents instead of our own.

And this is to say again that Seventh-day Adventists apply the same rule to each one of the commandments severally that they do to them collectively. But our Methodist friends apply one rule to the law as a whole, and then in the application of this rule to the precepts of the law severally, they discriminate in regard to one,—the fourth commandment,—and make of it a law so ceremonial and equivocal that it may undergo a radical change; in fact, a complete transfer of the obligation to observe the seventh day to another day, observed for another purpose! We are very sorry that they are so inconsiderate upon this one point, and shall continue to call their attention to it in a kind manner, with the hope, which to some extent is continually being realized, that while the whole Methodist Church will not be more consistent upon this point, there will be found among its members those who will be so. At the same time we are glad that they still advocate the general principle that the ten commandments are binding; for it is better to hold to correct principles, even though they are not always carried out, than to ignore them altogether.

As an illustration of Methodist teaching upon the law as a whole, we here give an extract from a sermon delivered at the late Methodist Episcopal General Conference at Indianapolis, Ind., by Rev. R. Crawford Johnson, superintendent of the Methodist Central Mission, Belfast, Ireland. The text was, “There is no fear in love; but perfect love casteth out fear: because fear hath torment. He that feareth is not made perfect in love.” 1 John 4:18.

The text will guard us also against antinomianism. If we sometimes make a Christ of holiness, others ignore its value and importance. Some time ago, Mr. Watkinson, the fraternal delegate from England, was looking around one of our cathedrals, when the verger drew his attention to a wall which needed some artistic decoration, adding the sapient remark, “You know the ten commandments might be painted up, and the ten commandments, sir, are better than nothing.” Some go further than this esthetic official, and declare plainly that the ten commandments have been abolished; for it lies at the very root of antinomianism. The word “law” in the Bible refers to three different things: 1. Civil law. This was the law belonging to the Jews as a nation. Some of the laws concerning the Sabbath were simply civil laws. Take, for instance, the law forbidding the Jews to travel more than ten thousand cubits on the Sabbath. 2. The ceremonial law. This was the law pertaining to the Jews as the disciples of Moses, and consisted of regulations about priest, and sacrifice, and altar. 3. The moral law. This was the law given to them as men, and it contained rules for character, conduct, life. We have an epitome of this law in the ten commandments. The civil law has passed away with the existence of the Jewish commonwealth. The ceremonial law has passed away with the sacrifice of Calvary, as the star is lost to view amid the glories of the rising sun. The moral law, however, which was given to the Jews neither as the descendants of Abraham nor as the disciples of Moses, but simply as men, is binding still. We see this clearly taught in the sermon on the mount. Please turn to Matt. 5:17-20: “Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.” Christ is here speaking of the moral law, as you will plainly see by the context; and with reference to this he distinctly says, “Think not that I am come to destroy.” The word translated “destroy” means primarily to loose, to dissolve, and when applied to a law, means to abrogate, set aside, or annul.

“I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.” The word “fulfil” appears in its original signification in the Church of England liturgy,—“Fulfil us with thy heavenly grace and benediction,”—and means to fill full, to perfect, or complete. Theophylact explained it by a twofold illustration. He applied it to a picture in outline; when coloring was added, it was fulfilled. He also applied it to a vessel like this tumbler, which I hold in my hand, when partially filled. Pour in more water, and fill it to the brim,—it is then fulfilled or filled full. Christ fulfilled the law in two respects—first in his life, then in his teaching. But in the sermon on the mount, he refers to the latter; and we see that, instead of repealing the ten commandments, he fulfils them by making them more searching and authoritative still, so that anger becomes murder, and lust, adultery. Verses 21-28.

Now a great many fail to see the radical difference in these three kinds of law, and because the civil and ceremonial laws have passed away, they think that the moral has ceased, and they celebrate its abolition in such wretched ditties as— “Free from the law! O, happy condition!”

To such preaching, Seventh-day Adventists can join in a hearty “Amen.”