A correspondent writes requesting that more evidence be presented to show that the dates assigned in Seventh-day Adventist publications for the birth and crucifixion of Christ are correct, as these dates are earnestly repudiated in a work called “The Millennial Dawn,” Vol. II, pages 54–62. This work maintains that Christ was born, not between three and four years before A. D. 1, as we teach, but only one year and three months before A. D. 1; that he began his ministry in A. D. 29, being then thirty years of age, instead of A. D. 27; and that he was crucified in A. D. 33 instead of A. D. 31.
This the reader will see disarranges the whole application of the prophetic period of the seventy weeks, from its beginning, through its intermediate dates, to the end. The Dawn claims that the seventy weeks should be dated from the commission given to Nehemiah by Artaxerxes Longimanus, in the twentieth year of his reign. Then it claims that the date usually given to this commission, B. C. 445, is nine years short, and that it should be 454, from which it figures out the beginning of Christ’s ministry in A. D. 29. In support of this view it refers to Dr. Hales’s Chronology, pages 449, 531. We cannot understand this reference; for Dr. Hales’s Chronology is a work of four volumes, and the volume is not given. But Dr. Hales does not sustain the view claimed. On one of the pages named, 531 of Volume II of his Chronology, we do find this: “Nehemiah lived to a very advanced age; for from the date of his commission, B. C. 444, to the succession of Jaddua,” etc. Thus 444, not 445, is the usual date of Nehemiah’s commission. Dr. Hales (Vol. II, page 448) places the seventh year of Artaxerxes, when Ezra received his decree, in B. C. 457, as we have it; and of course his twentieth year, when he commissioned Nehemiahp. 57 miah, would be 444 B. C. But the grant to Nehemiah was no decree, and cannot mark the date of the seventy weeks of Dan. 9:24, 25. (See works on Daniel and the Sanctuary published at this Office.)
Now as to the date of the Christian era, we have these facts. The era was invented by Dionysius Exiguus, A. D. 532. He placed the birth of Christ in the year of Rome 753, and of course marked that year A. D. 1; but it was ascertained later that Herod died in the year of Rome 750, and Christ was born, according to Matthew, before Herod died; so the date of Christ’s birth must be carried back between three and four years before the year known as A. D. 1. Our correspondent asks for the proof that the death of Herod was in the year of Rome 750; and on this point we present the following from Dr. Hales, Vol. I, pages 84, 85:—
Dionysius was led to date the year of the nativity, U. C. 753, from the evangelist Luke’s account that John the Baptist began his ministry “in the fifteenth year of the reign of Tiberius Cæsar,” and that Jesus at his baptism, “was beginning to be about thirty years of age.” Luke 3:1–23. For Tiberius succeeded Augustus at his death, Aug. 19, U. C. 767; and therefore his fifteenth year was U. C. 782; from which, subtracting the assumed year of the nativity, U. C. 753, the remainder was twenty-nine years complete, or thirty years current.
But this date of the nativity is at variance with Matthew’s account, that Christ was born before Herod’s death; which followed shortly after his massacre of the infants at Bethlehem. Matt. 2:1–19. And Herod’s death was also shortly after the lunar eclipse of March 13, U. C. 750, between that and the Passover, which fell that year on the 12th of April, as may be collected from Josephus, “Antiquities,” 17, cap. 6–8; Bell. Jud. 1, cap. 13, 4–8.
And that Herod’s death is rightly assigned to the year U. C. 750 is confirmed from the duration of his reign; for Josephus states that by the interest of Antony, Herod was appointed king by the Roman Senate “in the one hundred and eighty-fourth Olympiad, when Caius Domitius Calvinus, the second time, and Caius Asinius Pollio, were consuls,” U. C. 714. “Antiquities,” 14, 14, 5. And that he was established in the kingdom by the death of his rival, Antigonus, who had been set up by the Parthians; “when Marcus Agrippa and Caninius Gallus were consuls,” U. C. 717. “Antiquities,” 14, 16, 4. And he adds that Herod reigned thirty-seven years from his first appointment by the senate, and thirty-four years from the death of Antigonus. “Antiquities,” 17, 8, 1; and Bell. Jud. 1, 33, 8. Now if we take these as current years, according to the usage of Josephus, the death of Herod was U. C. 714+36=U. C. 750; U. C. 717+33=U. C. 750, as before. Such a critical conformity of astronomical and historical evidence, both furnished by an author the most competent to procure genuine information, establishes both; and decides the question that Herod could not have died later than the year U. C. 750.
As a specimen of the Dawn’s inaccuracy of statement, read the following, which occurs as a note on page 54 of its volume II: “The year A. D. was fixed upon as early as the fourth century by Dionysius Exiguus, and other scholars of that period, though it did not come into general use until the sixth century.” The facts are that all authorities give 532 as the date of the invention of this era by Exiguus, which was the sixth century instead of the fourth; and it did not begin to be used generally till 730, which was in the eighth century instead of the sixth, and was not established till the time of Pope Eugenius IV, A. D. 1431, which was the fifteenth century, as stated by Dr. Hales, Vol. I, page 84.
The Dawn makes an especial attempt to set aside the testimony of Josephus as worthless; for if his testimony stands, all its contention falls to the ground. Only assertion is brought against him, except in one instance, where an attempt is made to show an inconsistency in regard to the age of Herod and the length of his reign. But the foregoing testimony from Dr. Hales, showing the accurate agreement of Josephus’s testimony with both historical and astronomical contemporary events, is sufficient to establish his reliability in this matter.
On another point the reasoning of the Dawn is at fault. Naturally some attention must be paid to the date of the reign of Tiberius, in view of the testimony of Luke 3:1, 2. Fortunately all are agreed that the death of Augustus occurred in the year of Rome 767, A. D. 14. From this point, the Dawn contends that the reign of Tiberius must be dated, as sole emperor, which would bring his fifteenth year in A. D. 29, just where this author wants it. And he claims this, because, he says, there is no point from which a joint reign with Augustus could be dated, unless we go back ten years to A. D. 4, when Tiberius was adopted by Augustus, but not given any legal authority. In support of this he quotes from Merivale’s “History of the Romans,” Vol. IV, pages 220, 221.
Now if the author of the Dawn had studied Merivale carefully, he would have found that what was done in the year of Rome 757, or A. D. 4, was simply the adoption of Tiberius into the Julian family, without any reference to the throne. And if he had read on in Merivale, same volume, to pages 278, 279, he would have found that when Tiberius returned from his German campaign, he was allowed the celebration of a triumph in Rome, and was then clothed by Augustus with proconsular power, which was understood by all the people as co-sovereignty with Augustus himself. And the date which Merivale himself gives to this transaction is the year of Rome 765, or A. D. 12, two years before Augustus’s death.
Now it is an object with every ruler to make his reign as long as possible; and from what point, then, would Tiberius date his reign?—From this association with Augustus, of course. Smith’s Bible Dictionary (art., Jesus Christ) says: “It was in the fifteenth year of Tiberius, the emperor, reckoning from his joint rule with Augustus (January, U. C. 765), and not from his sole rule (August, U. C. 767), that John the Baptist began to teach.” Reckoned from this point, A. D. 12, his fifteenth year would be A. D. 27, where we have it. With such inaccuracies, the Dawn stumbles along through an argument to prove an error.
There are some things the reader may safely rest down upon as established facts: 1. The seventh of Artaxerxes, when Ezra received his decree to restore and build Jerusalem (Ezra 7:8), was B. C. 457. 2. This date is fixed by the canon of Ptolemy; and the reliability of this canon is shown in this way: in connection with its historical events, it names eclipses which occurred at the same times, giving the dates of the same. There are more than twenty of these, and they have been repeatedly calculated, and always found to fall on the dates to which Ptolemy assigned them, proving his statements accurate; so that Prideaux says that Ptolemy’s canon is not to be receded from for any human authority whatsoever. 3. Reckoned from B. C. 457, the sixty-nine weeks, or four hundred and eighty-three years, which were to reach to the Messiah the prince, ended in A. D. 27. This was the fifteenth year of Tiberius Cæsar, reckoned from his association on the throne with his stepfather Augustus, in A. D. 12; and in this year John began his ministry in the spring, and Christ, six months younger, six months later, in the fall, both being, according to the law, thirty years of age when they entered upon their work. 4. Christ’s ministry lasted three years and a half, to the Passover in A. D. 31, when he was crucified in the middle of the seventieth week. 5. Three and a half years more, the last half of the week, reached to the autumn of A. D. 34, when the time allotted to the Jews expired, and they made their formal rejection of the gospel, as a nation, in the martyrdom of Stephen. 6. These seventy weeks being the first 490 days of the 2300, the remaining 1810 reached to the autumn of 1844, when the cleansing of the sanctuary began.
These dates and eras are absolutely unassailable, and can never be overthrown. U. S.