AdventAI

SUNDRY NO-SABBATH SOPHISTRIES.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 3., January 19, 1897

X. “No man can show the least indication of Christ’s recognition of the seventh-day Sabbath after his resurrection.”

Such is another of the assertions put forth by those who oppose the present binding obligation of the seventh day as the Sabbath. And they seem to consider this an argument in favor of their proposition: “Christ did not keep the Sabbath after his resurrection; therefore it is not binding on us.” Let us see how it will work on a parallel proposition: “No man can show the least indication of Christ’s recognition, after his resurrection, of the commandment, ‘Honor thy father and thy mother.’” Shall we therefore conclude that that obligation is not binding upon us? And so we might go through with all the rest of the ten commandments; for if the Sabbath was abolished at the cross, all the law of which the Sabbath was a part was abolished also; it all stands or falls together; and on the principle of the foregoing proposition, we should be bound to affirm that none of the commandments are binding, because Christ did not reassert them after his resurrection. But nearly all denominations have justly set their brand of condemnation upon such an idea, by incorporating into their creeds and confessions of faith the ten commandments as the moral law,—the immutable and eternal transcript of the principles of the government of Jehovah.

The sophistry of the argument is apparent when one considers that Christ’s work of teaching was all accomplished before the crucifixion, and the new covenant, embracing all the principles of the gospel, was ratified upon the cross. And when, as Christ was about to leave his disciples and ascend into heaven, they asked him about the establishment of the kingdom on which their hopes were so earnestly centered, he declined to answer them then, but said that they should receive power in time to come. Christ’s omission to enjoin moral duties during this time did not abolish those obligations.

XI. “Christ kept the Christian sabbath, or first day of the week, after his resurrection, but did not once keep the old Jewish Sabbath. John 20 : 9–23, 26–29.”

It is only a desperate determination to have it so, that leads to so reckless an assertion. In the four brief Gospels we have all the known facts concerning that occasion; and these can be easily traced:—

1. After the crucifixion, the holy women, refraining from the loving service of preparing the means for embalming their Lord, “rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” Luke 23 : 55, 56. This shows that Christ had taught them nothing concerning any change of the Sabbath during all his life and ministry. He had given them no intimation of any first-day institution; but of course he had instructed them in reference to everything going into the new covenant, which he ratified on the cross. It shows that the Sabbath commandment was not abolished on the cross; and it shows Sabbath-keeping by Christians in this dispensation, according to a still binding commandment.

2. After Christ had risen, on the first day of the week, he gave no intimation by word or deed that it was a sabbath, which is proof positive that it was not; and he gave equal proof that it was not a sabbath, by doing what would not be appropriate to a sabbath; namely, making a fifteen-mile journey from Jerusalem to Emmaus and back. Two of the disciples also took this journey, which shows that they did not regard it as the Sabbath, but as a secular working day. Luke 24 : 1, 13, 33.

3. Christ did not show himself to the disciples collectively, but only individually, on the first day of the week; for the first interview he had with the eleven was after the return of the two disciples from Emmaus. Mark 16 : 9–14. Now, inasmuch as the day was almost ended when Jesus made himself known to them at Emmaus (Luke 24 : 28, 29), it was utterly impossible for them to get back to Jerusalem before the close of that day; hence, when they met the eleven, as recorded in Mark 16 : 13, the first day had passed, and it was then the second day of the week; and Jesus had not yet appeared to them.

4. The reason the two disciples were so late in their visit to Emmaus, was because they intended to tarry there all night, and invited Jesus, as a stranger (before they knew him), to tarry with them. Luke 24 : 29. Thus they must have been very careless or stupid disciples to be at that distance from Jerusalem at that hour, if they knew that it was the Sabbath by the appointment of Jesus, and that they ought to join the other disciples in meeting together to celebrate the institution.

5. The meeting recorded in Mark 16 : 14 is the same as that recorded in John 20 : 19. This latter record describes the state of mind the disciples were in. They were, as Christ had told them, as sheep among wolves; and like a little, frightened flock, they were in their common place of abode (Acts 1 : 13), and had fast bolted the doors for fear of the Jews. Only the third day before this, they had witnessed the cruel tragedy of the crucifixion of Christ. They did not know that Christ had risen. They had kept the Sabbath according to the commandment; but that was past, and the first day of the week had come, when the Jews would be at liberty to go forward with the persecution of the followers of Christ; and in their disappointment and terror, they supposed they would be the next victims, and perhaps suffer the fate of their Master.

But does it not say that this was the first day of the week?—Yes; the record begins while it was yet the first day of the week, but near its close; for it was evening; but it does not follow that all that took place on that occasion was accomplished before that day ended, and the second day of the week had commenced (sunset being the dividing line between the days). The eleven were at their common abode. The doorsp. 41 being shut for fear of the Jews, shows that the absorbing theme that occupied their thoughts and attention was the fear that the Jews would seek them out as the objects of their further vengeance. As they continued thus communing together, the hour of sunset was reached, and that day ended. The time came for their evening meal, and they sat down to meat. The two disciples from Emmaus then arrived, and told them how they had met the Lord, and he was known to them by the breaking of bread; and ere they had finished their repast, the Saviour himself stood in their midst, as stated in Mark 16 : 14, thus bringing his interview and first meeting with them collectively, on the second day of the week, not the first.

6. When he thus met with them, on the second day of the week, did he commend them for their fidelity in meeting together to keep the new sabbath in honor of his resurrection?—No; but he upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, not simply because they themselves did not believe that he had risen, but because they would not believe even those who had seen him and testified to them that he was risen. Yet, forsooth, we are told that they were met together to celebrate the resurrection of Christ, and to keep the sabbath which had been established in honor of that event.

7. As the first meeting of Jesus with the apostles together has now been found to have been on the second day of the week (Mark 16 : 14; John 20 : 19), it follows that the second meeting, “after eight days” (John 20 : 26), granting that this expression means, as we are told, just one week, was not sooner than on the second day of the next week. So there is no Sunday here. But granting that these first two meetings were on Sunday, and designed to establish the disciples in the new sabbath, what shall we do with the third meeting, which is expressly mentioned as such in John 21? Was this on the first day of the week? If so, the disciples had so far forgotten the new sabbath and its proprieties that they were out on a grand fishing excursion. Verse 3. And Christ approved of their so using that day; for he gave them a miraculous draft of fishes. Verse 6. But if this was not the first day of the week, then it follows that Christ was so indifferent in regard to the days on which he met with his disciples, that the very third time he met with them was on some other day besides the new sabbath, which it is affirmed he was trying to establish, and on which it is claimed he met with them.

And this is all the evidence that can be found to sustain the proposition, put on parade with such a flourish of trumpets, that Christ kept the first day of the week as the Christian sabbath, from his resurrection to his ascension, and that his disciples kept it by his command. If the question were merely a political or a scientific one, false logic, misstatements of fact, or erroneous conclusions would not be fraught with such far-reaching and tremendous consequences. But when it is considered that this question involves no less an issue than obedience or disobedience to God, the keeping or the violating of his commandments,—a practise which has such a decisive bearing on our standing in the future world (Matt. 5 : 19),—how dare men risk their eternal interests on anything less than the most earnest and careful and prayerful treatment of the testimony of God’s word, that has been given to guide them in their duty toward him? U. S.