The “Raines law,” regulating the sale of intoxicating liquors in New York City, is professedly a temperance law; but its main provision is that on Sunday it shuts up saloons, which are allowed to be open other days; so that really, instead of being a temperance measure, it is a Sunday law, devised for honoring the first day of the week. It seems to be a settled fact that under the operations of this law, more liquor is sold and drank on Sunday than on other days, or than was drunk on Sundays before this law was enacted. Under the Raines law, a hotel-keeper can furnish liquor to his guests every day of the week; and hence every saloon-keeper who can do so has turned his saloon into a hotel. A half dozen guest-rooms are all that is required to meet the demands of the law, and these rooms every Sunday are filled with drunken and immoral guests of both sexes. The Evangelist of New York City, has this to say of the “Raines hotels,” as they are now called:—
Moreover, competent observers declare that Sunday drinking has increased under the law, that the mock “hotels” are not only worse dens of drunkenness on Sunday than the old, wide-open saloon, but serve as a resort for the vicious of both sexes. Disguised as hotels, saloons which formerly were closed at night and on Sunday, are now never shut, and in many cases are mere breeding-places of vice and crime.
One would think that such being the case, this law would be repealed. But no; it has shut up the saloons on Sunday, and hence it must stand! Since liquor is now sold on Sunday more than ever before, and other vices are joined with it, it becomes apparent that the suppression of intemperance was not the real object of those behind the law; but that the protection of Sunday and its exaltation above other days, in obedience to so-called Christian sentiment, was the real object. What matters it to the Sunday reformer that the thousand “Raines hotels” sell liquor all day Sunday to drunken, immoral guests? Sunday is vindicated by the suppression of the saloon upon that day, and the Christian character of the law is maintained! When a Sunday victory thus becomes a temperance defeat, who but a religious devotee of Sunday exaltation can find any satisfaction in the result? M. E. K.