WHEN IT DOES NOT APPLY

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 5, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 1.

Read the full edition

WHEN IT DOES NOT APPLY.

The principle of religious liberty is of universal application; that is, that every man has the right to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience, without interference or molestation from his fellow men in any capacity whatever, either civil or ecclesiastical. And this applies to those who follow a false religion, or who profess no religion, as well as to those who profess the true religion.
But there are limitations,—not to the principle, but to men’s perversion of it. The line must be drawn in such a way as to prevent any encroachment upon the rights of others. When the plea of religious liberty is pressed to that extent that it tramples upon the rights of any portion of the community, it is carried beyond its legitimate bounds. Hence the Mormon cannot come in with this plea to defend his enslaving doctrine of polygamy; nor can the idolater, under the plea of religion, claim the right to offer human sacrifices. The state, as the defender of the rights of its citizens, has a right to restrain all such attempts.
On the same ground the state has a right to impose some restraint upon Romanism,—not as a religion, but as a political conspiracy, under the garb of religion, against the state and the civil and religious liberties of the people. The reason will appear more clearly from a little episode in the history of the Prince of Orange. When the Dutch were struggling for their liberties in the sixteenth century, the States of Holland, at an assembly at Leyden, resolved to prohibit the public exercise of the Romish religion. The Prince of Orange, in his “Apology,” published in 1580, gives, among other reasons for that step, the following:—
They who at first judged it for the interest and advantage of the country that one religion should be tolerated as well as the other, were afterward convinced by the bold attempts, cunning devices, and treacheries of the enemies who had insinuated themselves among the people, that the state was in danger of inevitable destruction unless the exercises of the Romish religion were suspended, since those who professed it (at least the priests) had sworn allegiance to the pope, and laid greater stress on their oaths to him than to any others which they took to the civil magistrate.
How can any government consistently place in public office, or elevate to positions of public trust and influence, those who are not citizens of the government; that is, those whose first oath of allegiance is given to a potentate of a foreign country, and whose obligations to their home government are considered only secondary? The Prince of Orange tried at first to follow this course; but of him the historian further speaks:—
The prince, in fact, had come even then to hold what is now the generally received maxim, that no one ought to suffer the smallest deprivation of his civil rights on account of his religious belief; but at the same time he felt, what all have felt who have anxiously studied to harmonize the rights of conscience with the safety of society, that there are elements in Romanism that make it impossible, without endangering the state, to apply this maxim in all its extent to the papal religion. The maxim, so just in itself, is applicable to all religions, and to Romanism among the rest, so far as it is a religion; but William found that it is more than a religion,—that it is a government besides; and while there may be scores of religions in a country, there can be but one government in it. The first duty of every government is to maintain its own unity and supremacy. . . . The force with which this consideration pressed itself upon the mind of William of Orange, tolerant even to the measure of the present day, is seen in what he says a little further on in his “Apology:” “It was not just,” he adds, “that such people should enjoy a privilege by the means of which they endeavored to bring the land under the power of the enemy; they sought to betray the lives and fortunes of the subjects, by depriving them not of one, two, or three privileges, but of all the rights and liberties which for immemorial ages had been preserved and defended by their predecessors from generation to generation.”—Wylie’s “History of Protestantism,” pages 101, 102.
This sets forth the situation exactly. If Romanists would confine themselves to what could legitimately be called religion, they would be entitled to all that is implied in the principle of religious liberty. But Romanism is, as stated above, more than a religion. It is a political conspiracy. What would Romanists do with this country if they had the power?—Deprive every true American of all his rights and liberties, and turn the country bodily over to a foreign potentate. And this they even dream of doing. The pope has enjoined them to enter everywhere into politics. And their methods of working are the same now as in the last century; for Rome never changes. “Cunning devices,” “treacheries,” “bold attempts,” traitorous insinuations, are still current weapons. This is why the Jesuits have been expelled, in turn, from every civilized country under heaven, except the long-suffering and spiritually-blinded United States of America. And this country will by and by suffer bitterly for its tolerance or stupidity.
U. S.