CLASHING VOICES

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 12, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 2.

Read the full edition

CLASHING VOICES.

BY ELDER F. D. STARR.
(Nashville, Tenn.)
It was recently my privilege to be present one afternoon at an annual conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, held at Nashville, Tenn. The topic under consideration was one upon which there was much difference of opinion,—whether they should continue to endorse and acknowledge the Tennessee Methodist as the official organ of this conference. The editor, B. F. Haines, read a lengthy defense of his paper, to vindicate it from the attack that was made upon it. The opposing party expressed itself in a resolution stating that it was the sense of that body that the Tennessee Methodist no longer reflected the true doctrines of Methodism, and that they could no longer recognize it as the official organ of that conference. The opinion of the other party was expressed in a resolution stating that the journal had done a good work, and that they would continue to support it.
The trouble seemed to be that the paper devoted too much of its space to the doctrine of “sanctification,” or perhaps, rather, to the editor’s view of that doctrine. One speaker said they did not want the same thing continually for breakfast, dinner, and supper, and they did not want an organ unless they could have something to do in regard to the organist; they did not want an organ if they could not be allowed to say anything about the tune that should be played. The editor strongly maintained that his understanding and treatment of the subject of sanctification and the “second blessing” were strictly in harmony with the teachings of primitive Methodism, and it would be a most inconsistent thing indeed for a Methodist conference to reject a paper just because it taught the genuine doctrines of Methodism. He stated that he had been exceedingly alarmed by the increasing worldliness that was coming into the church and seemed about to engulf it. (Who will say his observations on this matter were not about correct?) He had looked about to see what remedy might be found, and had become convinced that the doctrine of sanctification was the only thing that would prevent the ruin; hence the reason for devoting so much space to it.
The editor had the advantage in that he held a controlling share of the stock, as far as the financial phase of the matter was concerned, so the most the party displeased with his management could do was to protest in the way they did. It was quite an exciting time. Quiet was secured, and it was announced that the matter of determining whether they would endorse said journal as their official organ would be determined by vote of the delegates. The roll was then called, and the responses began,—a vigorous “No,” then an emphatic “Yes,” and so on. As nearly as could be estimated by an observer, there were about three “no’s” to one “yes.”
As I left, I thought, Surely we are living in a time when great bodies are being divided in sentiment. In political parties this tendency has been very marked this season; old lines are obliterated, and new combinations are formed. But this is not confined to politics. In some respects this may be an advantage; individuals may be left more free to think for themselves. But the writer, and perhaps the reader, is sometimes a delegate to similar conventions or assemblies. Observations from the position of a spectator impress one with the necessity of proper Christian decorum when acting as participant, and avoiding, as much as possible, unnecessary clashing of voices.