July 4th : July 14th.
BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek College.)
I HAVE thought many times, while writing these articles for the REVIEW, that they must be more than instructive and admonitory. The woes that are coming upon the earth are real—most terribly real—woes. The distress, the perplexity, the anguish of mind and the suffering of body, which men and even frail women and tender children will inevitably undergo, unless their hearts have been given to the Almighty, make me shudder as I think of them. Again and again I ask myself: Is there that power and spirit in what you write that will save a soul from death? Is there that in the words which your mind is yielding and your pen tracing that will awaken an earnest longing in the reader’s mind to become wholly God’s? Unless this is accomplished, I can only regard my work as not being wrought in Him. Results belong with God; and happy is the man who, although seeing no fruit of his labors, can say with that ancient seer: “I have labored in vain, I have spent my strength for naught, and in vain: yet surely my judgment is with the Lord, and my work with my God.”1
As the terrors of the Reign of Terror in France are related, it will be necessary to reproduce some of the most striking scenes of that dire time in vivid colors. This is not for the purpose of dwelling upon events of blood. It is not from a desire to sicken any one. But those times will be again. This is a fact which the world, and even those who profess to be waiting for the coming and kingdom of our Lord Jesus Christ, do not sense. Moreover, it is a fact that if these things are not sensed, the soul will be without a shelter in that day of wrath.
On account of the embarrassed state of the treasury of France, the States General was opened at Versailles, May 5, 1789. The States General was nothing more nor less than a congress, consisting of three hundred and eight representatives from the clergy, two hundred and eighty-five from the nobles; and six hundred and sixty-one from the “third estate,” as the people outside the two above-named orders were called. Versailles is a small town a few miles distant from Paris, and was at that time the home of King Louis XVI and his court. This States General, which soon constituted itself the “National Assembly,” resolved to make a constitution for France, and to inaugurate certain sweeping reforms. The clergy and the nobles were inclined to yield many of their past privileges and prerogatives. A majority of the representatives of the people were disposed to be fair; in fact, nearly all in the National Assemblyp. 20 impress me as having had honest intentions of doing those things which would be best for the nation. But things everywhere in France were in such a fearful condition that a peaceable solution of the problem was absolutely impossible. In order that this may be correctly understood, another class of people, heretofore unmentioned, claims attention.
In the city of Paris, and in all the other large cities of France, there existed thousands of unemployed men and women. Many of them had formerly lived in the country; but on account of the low prices of produce, and the oppression which the rich exercised upon the small farmers, they had come to the cities, hoping to secure work. There was, however, in the cities, little that they could do. Some might and did find work as common day laborers. For such work the men were paid twenty-six cents a day, and the women, fifteen cents, while bread cost more than it does now.2 There were hundreds of thousands of this class in Paris in the year 1789.3 They lived in the slums, in vice and squalor. Their children were brought forth in vice, nourished and raised in infamy, and bred to crime. Such a life inevitably must engender the vilest and fiercest passions of which the human mind is capable. In the nature of things it must awaken, and awaken to intense activity, “the original beast slumbering in the human breast.” These people are the very lees of society, and only in times of social agitation do they come to the surface. They hate not only the rich, but everybody who has anything. Says Von Holst:—
They are embittered against the government; there is, when they begin to think about it, in the existing condition of things, nothing that is dear to them; the very fact of their being a vast mass renders them excitable; when the blood of a few is stirred, that of all instantly begins to course faster in their veins, and the heightened temperature of every one reacts upon that of the whole mass. A single burning straw can easily be put out by a child, but if it be one of a huge pile, the burning candle cannot with impunity be held to it. They do not reason, but they feel all the more intently; they will follow every voice striking the tone which, at the moment, awakens a responsive echo in their breasts; and they have not been taught in vain not to scruple to take the law into their own hands; and, finally, in an upheaval, which would turn everything topsyturvy, they have nothing to lose, but everything to gain. In a revolution resorting to force, every demagogue would find in them the flying columns ever ready to his hands, and in a revolution coming to believe revolution in itself the magic panacea for all political and social evils and dangers, it would be the easiest thing in the world to work them into a mental and moral delirium stopping short at absolutely nothing.4
The very existence of such a class, the very fact that there were such things in France as wild city mobs, seems to have been forgotten by the men who started in to reform the country. They were “the nobodies,” and nobody thought of them.
They were not slow, however, in making their weight felt. On the 5th of May, 1789, the States General had been opened, and the country had passed from beneath the rule of a despotic monarchy to that of a National Assembly, consisting of twelve hundred and fifty-four representatives. On the 14th of July of that same year, the mob of Paris rose, stormed the Bastile, and began their work of murder and rapine. The Assembly was powerless, and on that day, France changed masters again. On that day “the nobodies” learned their power, and France passed from the rule of the Assembly to the rule of a howling, yelling, wild, and unmanageable mob. From that day forward there was no real government in France. Anarchy reigned supreme. From the 14th of July, 1789, the mob of Paris controlled the country until the end of the Revolution, when everything passed under the iron heel of Napoleon Bonaparte. “To every impartial man,” says Malouet, “the Terror dates from the 14th of July.”7 And this fact can never be too much appreciated, for from this date a despotism, blacker, thicker, and infinitely more terrible than that of the Bourbon kings, settled down over unhappy France. The absolute and irresponsible rule of the king was exchanged for the still more absolute and still more irresponsible rule of “those terrible bands which always make their appearance in civil commotions, and are never seen but on such occasions—these now everywhere showed themselves as if they had sprung from the earth.”8
This element took possession of the French Revolution in the start, and never relinquished it till the end. “From this moment,” says a deputy,9 “liberty did not exist, even in the National Assembly. . . . France stood dumb before thirty factious persons. The Assembly became in their hands a passive instrument, which they forced to serve them in the execution of their projects.”
The ancient fortress of the Bastile was taken by a howling mob, the leaders of which demanded and obtained from the Assembly, rewards for their atrocious services. Liberty had indeed been misshapen, democracy had gone wild. Liberty had now degenerated into license, and democracy had abandoned the field to slumocracy; and through all the Revolution these hideous abortions reveled in riot and gambolled in gore.
It is often said that the 14th of July marked an era of independence for the French nation. In a certain sense this is true; but in its more immediate results, it was not so. On the contrary it marked an era of the greatest anarchy the world has ever seen. There was as much liberty for France in the events of July 14, 1789, as there is effulgence in darkness. There was not in those events as much as a shade of a shadow of liberty. The storming of the Bastile was the fitting inaugural of the mob. The wild scenes of the wildest elements of society were appropriately ushered in by the unseemly and unnecessary brutalities of that dire day. When the awful scourge of the Revolution was over, there was, as a result, a good degree of liberty secured to the French people. But terrible was the price which was paid for it.