MAGNITUDE OF THE TURKISH QUESTION

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 12, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 2.

Read the full edition

MAGNITUDE OF THE TURKISH QUESTION.

THE clergy of our country who are crying for some European power, or for the United States, to conquer Turkey and free the suffering Christians there, who are, as they believe, oppressed by Turkey, seem to have but a feeble idea of the magnitude of such a task. The fact is that the defeat of Turkey would only pave the way for another most Herculean task. The arbitrary rule of the Turk is all that prevents desperate fighting between the different factions of the so-called Christian population of Turkey. The type of Christianity which prevails in Turkey is the same as that which Europe possessed in the middle ages. The Moslem scimitar, bloody as it is, keeps order among those who, but for it, would be devouring one another. The following candid statement upon this point, made by Henry P. Smith, in the Evangelist, is worthy of attention:—
We take it as a matter of course that Jews, Moslems, and Christians hate one another and are hated by one another. We do not always remember that the same may be said of the Christian sects among themselves. Greeks, Jacobites, Armenians, Bulgarians, Catholics, Maronites, and Nestorians are all represented in Turkey; and each sect, if it had the power, would persecute the others. The fearful anathemas uttered by orthodox fathers against Nestorians were only the expression of a feeling which has lasted to the present day. Under the Byzantine emperors, dogma was established by enactment, and those who refused to conform to the state type of doctrine were exposed to suffering or death at the hands of the mob. It was only a continuation of Greek conditions that was seen when the various parties of Christians moved their Arab masters against other Christians. In the time of the califate of Bagdad, the Greeks informed the calif that the Nestorians could not be considered Christians. What the state of the Turkish Empire would be, were freedom introduced, is seen in the church of the Holy Sepulcher at Jerusalem when pilgrims of different names meet there—the utmost efforts of the Turkish guard are needed to prevent violence and bloodshed. A Greek patriarch and an Armenian patriarch reside at Constantinople. When the Greek revolution broke out, the Armenian patriarch offered to keep the Christian populace of the city in order, if he were allowed to destroy all the churches of the Greeks!
This is the discouraging feature of the situation. The Christians—except so far as they are under Protestant influence—do not want reform, but revenge. Repression has not produced the feeling of toleration; it never does produce it. The Christians do not want to live at peace with the Turks, and they are as far from understanding what equality before the law means as are the Moslems. And so far as the proposal or promise of reform raises any inspiration in their minds, it raises an inspiration for revolution. Their ideals are in the past. The Greeks dream of re-establishing the empire of Constantine; the Armenians, of restoring the old kingdom of Armenia. If these dreams cannot be realized, they prefer to be let alone. Progress is abhorrent to them. The modern European ideas of liberty arouse antipathy rather than sympathy in their conservative breasts. When young Turkey was making some stir and promise of advance in Constantinople, a pasha was asked whether there was not an old Turkish party. “Certainly,” he replied, “it is made up of the Greek clergy!” There was reason in the jest. Conservatism is the very substance of Eastern society.
From this statement it may be seen that when the Turkish government is torn down, it must be immediately superseded by some power which will be able to police the whole country, or internal strife worse than Turkish massacres will burst out among the warring factions of Christians. Probably Russia is the best fitted of any of the nations for this task. But when Russia does get possession of Turkey, the Armenians, Nestorians, Jacobites, Maronites, and all other sects will be under the control of the Russian-Greek Church; and the Protestant American missionaries who have so bitterly complained of the Turks will have the opportunity to return to their own country; for Russia tolerates nothing. But since Russia is a Christian (2) nation, perhaps her intolerance can be borne with greater patience and equanimity than the reign of the Mohammedan sultan.
M. E. K.