AdventAI

A BREAKING OUT.

By George C. Tenney

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 2., January 12, 1897

The intense pressure to which those who undertake the support of Sunday sacredness are subjected is shown by the rush, roar, and hiss which every newly discovered loophole of escape develops. We have no word of criticism for those who conscientiously adhere to what they believe to be the truth, even though their views may seem very erroneous. But when people bind themselves about with error, and wrap themselves up in tradition so as to exclude the possible entrance of light, they are in a condition that excites pity. The word of God would gladly penetrate this dense covering if it could, but the crust of prejudice prevents the entrance of truth, which presses in on every side with sacred power. It also hinders the escape of error, which, however, occasionally finds small vent with a disproportionate roar.

Dropping the figure, and picking up the fact at hand, we call attention to a four-column article in the Chicago Tribune of Monday, December 28, headed, “He Fixes the Sabbath; S. W. Gamble Elucidates the Fourth Commandment for the Jews. Saturday Idea is Excluded, and the Movable Nature of the Day is Expounded.” Then follows, in newspaper style, the announcement that:—

S. W. Gamble, of the South Kansas Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church, has announced the theological discovery that the Jewish Sabbath was not Saturday, but was a changeable day, and that “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy,” never referred to Saturday. It is difficult to estimate the importance of the discovery which is detailed below. When first presented to the great theologians, they say, “It is impossible;” but when they give it careful attention, they gladly and cheerfully endorse it.

The Christian Endeavor of Chicago, which has for one of its aims the “rescue of the Sabbath,” through its editor, Edward F. Cragin, who gives special attention to this department, learned of the discovery some months ago. After careful investigation, Mr. Cragin was satisfied that it was correct, but “to make assurance doubly sure,” Mr. Gamble, the father of this discovery, was sent for to come to Chicago, and present this new theory to the leading Biblical scholars and theologians of this city. Mr. Gamble’s experiences here were interesting, as he went from one theological seminary and from one Hebrew scholar to another.

This is not the first time we have heard of this modern gentleman from Gath. His boastings over the truth and his defiance of its advocatesp. 25 have disturbed the gentle atmosphere of the Southwest for some months. Nor is his theory peculiar to himself; for many others have suggested similar hypotheses as an evasion of the plain command of God. The Tribune gives the following “condensed statement” of the supposed discovery:—

The Sabbath of the Jews, from the Exodus until at least after the crucifixion, occurred on fixed dates,—that is, on the fifteenth day of Abib, or Nisan, each year, because it commemorated their freedom from Egyptian slavery on that date. It occurred the same day of the week with the fifteenth day of Abib until the day of Pentecost. The week, including Pentecost, contained six work days and two Sabbaths. The six work days followed the day of Pentecost Sabbath, which would bring the next Sabbath after Pentecost on the next day of the week to what it had been preceding that time in the year, making a change of the Sabbath day at Pentecost to the next day in the week each year. The same law holds good in the count of the sabbath years and the year of jubilee. Each jubilee period was a perfect cycle in itself. The last week of years in each jubilee period contained six work years and two sabbath years.

Following this is the endorsement of Mr. Gamble’s theory by two eminent theologians of Chicago, and a partial endorsement by Rabbi Hirsch, after which the Tribune adds:—

It is needless to say that the publication of this matter, which the Tribune obtains from the advance sheets of the January issue of the Christian Endeavorer, will lead to new study. As the discovery of America changed all geographical studies, so this discovery will revolutionize the whole study of the Sabbath question.

And then follow three columns of illustrations, speculations, figures, etc., supposed to substantiate the projected theory; but we searched in vain for one scintilla of positive evidence in favor of the basic proposition that the weekly Sabbath was reckoned each year from the fifteenth of Abib. There are plenty of assertions, as usual, but a paucity of evidence that is in exact contrast to the abundant assumption.

The following day the same paper published other comments from other authorities, in which the position taken the previous day was disavowed and disproved. Rabbi Felsenthal, a distinguished Jewish authority, referring to a supposed dialogue published by Mr. Gamble, said:—

Practically the whole argument is contained in this dialogue:—

“Upon what date did the Bible require the passover lamb to be slain?”

“On Abib 14 every year.”

“Upon what day was it eaten?”

“On Abib 15 every year.”

“Upon what date was the wave sheaf offered and the harvest commenced?”

“On Abib 16 every year.”

“Was Abib 15 always a sabbath day?”

“Certainly it was.”

“Was Abib 16 on the first day of the week each year?”

“Yes. Upon that date they began to count the seven weeks toward Pentecost.”

“Very well. Will you furnish me an accepted solar or lunar calendar that will locate Abib 15 on Saturday every year, and Abib 16 on Sunday every year?”

“O, I see! I see! It cannot be done. I had never thought of it before.”

The answer, “Certainly it was,” was a hasty concession. In the twenty-third chapter of Leviticus, where directions are given for finding the festival days, we find the following: “And ye shall count unto you from the morrow after the sabbath, from the day that ye brought the sheaf of the wave-offering; seven sabbaths shall be complete; even unto the morrow after the seventh sabbath shall ye number fifty days; and ye shall offer a new meat-offering unto the Lord.” The word translated “sabbath,” where it occurs the first time, should be translated “feast,” in my opinion. In the Hebrew the word simply means a cessation from labor, and it was used for feasts as well as for the Sabbath. The Sadducees and Pharisees at the time of Christ differed upon this question, the Sadducees maintaining that the count had to be from the regular Sabbath, the Pharisees that the feast-day was meant. The Pharisaic view prevailed.

I, for one, never heard before that there were two sabbaths, and consequently eight days in the week of Pentecost. I do not think there is any authority for this in the Bible. The command to labor six days and rest one was not taken strictly, and feasts frequently interrupted work days. Nor is it true that the Jewish year consisted of exactly three hundred and fifty days, or fifty weeks, as the diagram of Mr. Gamble would seem to indicate. The Jewish calendar was lunar, the months containing either twenty-nine or thirty days, beginning always upon the day the new moon was observed. Every once in so long, an intercalary month was shoved in to make the seasons fit the dates set for the feasts, but this did not interfere at all with the regularity of the week-day period. . . . At the time of Christ the matter had long been firmly regulated, so that a month was intercalated once in a while to keep the year straight with the seasons; but this did not interfere in the slightest with the regular procession of the week of seven days, and the Jews always regarded their Sabbath as the close of a seven-day period.

Mr. Gamble refers to many commentators in a way to lead one to suppose that they support his theory, which they certainly do not, though there is not perfect unanimity among them. Even the Jews have for ages been divided upon the question, a small sect taking the position advocated by Mr. Gamble. The sabbath from which the count to Pentecost was to be made was, as we learn from the rabbi quoted above, a rest-day, hence a sabbath; but that it was identical with the weekly Sabbath there is nothing to show. Indeed, there is, in Lev. 23:37, 38, an emphatic distinction drawn between these annual feasts and the Sabbath of the Lord. Certain it is that at the time of the crucifixion of Christ, he ate the passover with his disciples, and was crucified and buried before the Sabbath. And the sacred writer tells us that his disciples “rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment,” while their Lord lay in the tomb. It is the great fact and work of creation that marks the weekly period, and the only reason given in God’s word for the weekly Sabbath is the resting upon, blessing and sanctification of, the seventh day as a memorial of creation. The fact that God released the people from Egyptian servitude was the reason why they could resume the keeping of the Sabbath, and the local reason why they should do so.

Without pursuing an extended argument or proof of these patent truths, we will allude to the boastings of this champion of a mistake. He claims to have effectually silenced and cowed our ministers into a meek submission. He states, as we are informed, that he has caused “Father” Enright to back down, and withdraw his thousand-dollar offer. In reference to the latter, the following note received by one of our laborers will be a sufficient refutation of that claim:—

Chicago, Nov. 24, 1896.

DEAR FRIEND: Your postal was forwarded and received here, where I at present reside. I have never seen, never even heard of, Rev. S. Gamble. The assertion that he has “met and refuted me, and that I have backed down,” is utterly false. I have never yet seen any proof from the Bible alone, that we are bound to keep Sunday holy. We keep Sunday in obedience to the law of the holy Catholic Church.

Yours respectfully,

T. ENRIGHT.

If Seventh-day Adventists refuse to debate the matter with him, they doubtless have good reasons for doing so. But those reasons are not that his position is unassailable or that his errors cannot be exposed; for that has been done over and over, all along our entire history.

G. C. T.