AdventAI

A TIMELY DECISION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 52., December 29, 1896

The shameful practise now in vogue among married people of quality (?) who have become dissatisfied with their matrimonial bargain, or happen to see a better chance, of going to a new Western State to obtain a divorce, has lately received a timely check. A New York woman, taking a fancy to another man than her husband, went to Fargo, N. Dak., her new lover accompanying her. By remaining there ninety days, she gained a residence, applied for and obtained a divorce. She immediately married the other man. Now husband number one, who had not appeared in the divorce proceeding, sued in New York for an absolute divorce, to which he was justly entitled, and gained it.

In granting this decree, the New York judge said that by the laws of that State the parties were husband and wife. “Neither of them could voluntarily free himself or herself from those obligations. It could not be done by mutual consent. It could not, under the laws of this State, be done by evasive action designed to circumvent the public policy of the State of New York in respect to what is regarded the sacred obligation of marriage.” The judge then said that for the purpose of obtaining a divorce, “and for that purpose alone, she leaves the State of New York, and goes to the State of North Dakota, where a divorce may be obtained upon a residence of ninety days, and where no inquiry seems to be made upon the subject as to whether that residence was acquired for the purpose of obtaining a divorce, or for the purpose of obtaining a permanent residence. By the laws of North Dakota, therefore, she is the lawful wife in that State of Mr. Bell. By the laws of the State of New York, she is the lawful wife of Mr. McGown. Now that inconsistent relation is something that is very difficult to obviate, but I know of no way, except by adhering first to the ancient rule of the State of New York, that the marital tie cannot be dissolved by such actions on the part of either person to that contract, no matter what the consequences are; therefore I say that under the laws of this State, under the decisions of this State in the highest courts, this lady is yet the lawful wife of the plaintiff in this action. Therefore, if she has lived in the marital relation with another man, she has violated that obligation, which gives just cause to her husband for a divorce.”

It follows, of course, that if she was the lawful wife of the first man at the time of her second marriage, that marriage is void. This decision will affect the legal standing of a great number of similar marriages, some of them among the notables of society. It is to be hoped that it will be sustained by all our courts.