A RULE NOT FOLLOWED

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 29, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 52.

Read the full edition

A RULE NOT FOLLOWED.

A PASSAGE has been put forth on the Sabbath question to which we take occasion briefly to refer, not because it contains any argument, but only as a specimen of the lengths to which men will go when they have committed themselves to the advocacy of error, and seem determined to support it at all hazards. Such cases should serve as a warning to every honestly disposed mind; for no one is ever forced to such extremes in defense of the truth. If the blind lead the blind, they are both destined to fall into the ditch.
A leaflet bearing the signature of “Rev. J. J. Munro, Lunenburg, Vt.,” has been sent us for examination and comment. It contains the usual misstatements of facts, false logic, and unfounded conclusions, which usually appear in attempts to support the Sunday, of which it is not worth while to speak, as they have been so often exposed. But here is one passage, as referred to above, which for cool audacity and unblushing misrepresentation, surpasses anything which it has yet been our fortune to meet. The writer says we do not need any command of Christ for keeping Sunday in place of the Sabbath, because the example of Christ is so much better; and then on the point of example, he comments as follows:—
“If we follow Christ, we shall make no mistake. ‘He that followeth me shall not walk in darkness.’ John 8:12. ‘I have given you an example,’ said Jesus, ‘that ye should do as I have done.’ In observing the first day of the week as the Christian Sabbath, the church simply follows the example of Christ.”
Let the reader pause a moment, and give a little careful thought to this declaration; for it is difficult to take in the full extent of its moral turpitude at the first glance. For one to follow the example of another in actions is to do the same things performed by the first. If the church, in keeping Sunday as the Christian Sabbath, is following the example of Christ, then Christ must have kept Sunday as the Christian Sabbath. The foolishness of such a claim is sufficiently astounding; for nothing was abolished till we come to the cross. But the attempt to make Christ’s own words sustain such a proposition is more astounding still.
The reader will notice that to one quotation in the foregoing extract, the writer gives the reference; to the other he does not. Was he fearful that if he should do so, the reader would look it up, and thus detect his unbridled dishonesty? But the reader should know upon what occasion, and in reference to what work Christ uttered the words, “I have given you an example.” They are found in John 13, and were spoken in reference to the act of washing the disciples’ feet, which he had just performed, and not in reference to Sunday-keeping at all.
Now mark the course of this critic: He will not practise the ordinance of feet-washing at all, but he has adopted and is determined to sustain the practise of First-day keeping, which Christ did not do, and in reference to which he said not one word, and left no example. Now he takes the words of Christ, spoken in reference to a practise which he will not follow, and applies them to a practise which Christ did not follow and never enjoined upon any one else to follow, and would have his readers believe that Christ kept the first day of the week as the Christian Sabbath, and then told his followers that in reference to this practise he had set them an example, that they should do as he had done; and all this for the purpose of clinching the exhortation that “if we follow Christ, we shall make no mistake”! Thus he holds up Christ in a false light, and deliberately makes him testify to that which is not true!
It is a fearful thing to wrest and pervert the words of Scripture. It has been done ever since the Bible was sent forth to arrest the attention of men; and it will no doubt continue to the end. It was practised by some in the days of Peter; but he said that those that did it did so to their own destruction. U. S.