SUNDRY NO-SABBATH SOPHISTRIES

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 15, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 50.

Read the full edition

SUNDRY NO-SABBATH SOPHISTRIES.

The document we are examining under this head is entitled “Seventh-day Adventism Refuted by Fifty-two Facts.” It is a ponderous three-and-one-half page document, and bears the names of five “reverends” as authors. Brethren have requested that its assertions be answered in the REVIEW. Though no well-established Sabbath-keeper could be influenced by it, an examination of its positions may benefit the many readers of the REVIEW who are for the first time investigating the subject of the Sabbath. Hence we notice it. Four points have been already examined. A fifth is given as follows:—
V. “There was no Sabbath before the one given at Marah, where God made Israel a statute and an ordinance, which was the Sabbath, and was the first kept after the falling of the manna.” There is always a desperate attempt by this class of people to connect the Sabbath with the giving of the manna, and so confine it to Israel; but this is the weakest and most inconsistent of them all, as a glance at the circumstances will show.
Positive Scripture testimony has already been referred to, proving that the Sabbath was instituted at creation, and was there commanded, and was of course observed by every worshiper of God from that time on. But the objector’s cause reveals its weakness still further, if possible, by its attempt to place the origin of the Sabbath at the giving of the manna. It is therefore worth while to understand this point.
The foregoing no-Sabbath proposition asserts that the Sabbath was given at Marah. The record concerning Marah is found in Ex. 15:23–26. But not a word is said about the Sabbath. But does it not say that “there he [God] made for them a statute and an ordinance?”—Yes. And was that the Sabbath?—By no manner of means; for the very next verse tells what it was; it was an engagement on the part of the Lord, by which he bound himself to put none of the diseases of Egypt upon them, if they would harken to the voice of his words, and give ear to his commandments. And God showed his power to carry out his engagement by healing the bitter water.
That is all there was at Marah. Then the people journeyed to Elim. But there is nothing said about the Sabbath, nor any statute or ordinance there. Then they journeyed on, and came to the wilderness of Sin. Here they had the experience of the manna, and here the attempt is usually made to introduce the Sabbath, and make it the seventh day from the falling of the manna. But there is not the first syllable in the record to show this. The “sixth day,” on which they were to have a double quantity, was not the sixth day from the time the manna began to fall, but the sixth day of the week. How long it was from the time they came into the wilderness of Sin, before the manna began to fall we do not know. They entered it on the fifteenth day of the second month. Ex. 16:1. Then there was time for dissatisfaction to arise, and for murmuring to spread through the host, and for a gathering to Moses and Aaron for a protest, before the Lord promised the manna at all. On what day of the week this was, we are not told, nor how long before the Sabbath. A new week was not here introduced. The week, with all its days, from the first to the seventh, was already established. Six of these days, beginning with the first, were called by numbers; the seventh was called “the Sabbath.” After the manna began to fall, they were to have on the sixth of this period, the sixth day of the week, a double quantity to gather; but in what part of the week the manna began to fall we are not told. Now look at the reasoning of our “reverends.” They have the Sabbath instituted at Marah, and a Sabbath law there given, after the manna began to fall. But the manna did not begin to fall till the wilderness of Sin was reached, two stages later in their journey; and the statute at Marah did not relate to the Sabbath at all, but to their exemption from the diseases of Egypt! But they are in perishing need of a statute for their Sabbath; and as none is mentioned except at Marah, they are obliged to stultify themselves, and put the Sabbath back there, hoping, no doubt, that no one will discover their folly.
Another interesting point for the no-Sabbath people here, is that this whole transaction in the wilderness of Sin was at least thirty-three days before the commandments were spoken from Sinai, which shows that the Sabbath did not originate there, as it was kept before Israel reached that place. This fact prevents our no-Sabbath friends from using Neh. 9:13, 14, as they would be glad to do.
VI. “Christ mentions none [that is, no Sabbath previous to Marah], neither do his inspired apostles.” Christ’s teaching in regard to the law in general and the Sabbath in particular, is very definite. He points back to the time when the Sabbath was “made,” which was, as we have seen, in the beginning. His “custom” was to observe it, and he took particular pains to strip from it all Jewish traditions, and show what was lawful to be done on it. The holy women observed it after the cross, and the apostles kept it and made it prominent all through their ministry, calling the seventh day the Sabbath, and the only Sabbath; for Paul, speaking of reading in the synagogue on the seventh day (Acts 15:21), says it was every Sabbath day.
VII. “God never blessed or sanctified the Sabbath. He gave it to Israel, but commanded them to sanctify it themselves.” Deut. 5:12. How is it possible for men to make such assertions in the face of Gen. 2:3 and Ex. 20:11?
VIII. “When God commanded Israel to keep the Sabbath day, no one was included except the stranger who sojourned with them.” And that surely is enough; for who were these strangers? They might be anybody under heaven. And why were they to keep the Sabbath in the home of the Israelites?—Not because of their location, but because of the binding nature of the law for them. The very fact that strangers, whoever they were, were required to observe the Sabbath, shows that it was of universal obligation, different from the observances that were peculiar to Israel, like circumcision and the Passover. If the Sabbath had been a Jewish ordinance, the stranger would not have been obliged to keep it any more than the Passover, from which he was specially excluded. Ex. 12:43. Thus the very expression which our friends bring up in support of their position, completely overturns their claim, and brings out the fact that the fourth commandment contains within itself the positive declaration that it is a universal law, binding on all men. U. S.