AdventAI

HOW TO AVOID PAPAL ERRORS.

By M. E. Kellogg

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 49., December 8, 1896

BY ELDER M. E. KELLOGG.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

It is a sad fact that common Protestant theology is so full of papal errors that the Protestantp. 776 theologians are compelled to make admissions which are to the advantage of Rome in many controversies. For instance, Protestants hold to the idea of the immortality of the soul. According to this theory, no man really dies. The soul still lives, and death has no power over it.

Let us now view the Catholic doctrine of the supremacy of Peter in relation to the question of the immortality of the soul. Catholics claim for Peter that he still lives and acts through his successors, the bishops of Rome. The Protestant who believes that Peter still lives, admits one half of Rome’s contention upon this point, which he is under no necessity to admit. That Protestants labor under this difficulty upon this very point may be seen from the fact that a Protestant champion writing against the idea of the supremacy of Peter, has this to say:—

How can the bishop of Rome derive power from the dead Peter in the nineteenth century over any immortal soul in this distant land?—Rev. M. Gallagher, in “Was Peter Ever at Rome?” page 22 of preface.

It may be seen by the above that this very Protestant writer believes that people do have immortal souls; and hence he virtually confesses that Peter, whom he calls dead, is not dead, after all! If he had held that Peter is really dead, he would have made an invulnerable argument against Rome, but by his self-confessed belief in immortal souls, it becomes of no force whatever. By his own argument his dead Peter is just as alive as any one! He stultifies his own argument in a vital point.

Let us view this question of Peter’s supremacy through the bishops of Rome after his death, in the light of the Scriptures. Without stopping to inquire here what was the power, or grace, which was bestowed upon Peter, we simply ask, Where was it to be exercised? “Whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.” Now where was Peter’s work of binding and loosing, whatever that may have been, to be done?—On earth. Then when Peter died and left the earth and the scenes of earth, what became of that power to bind and loose?—It was as dead as Peter was. Peter is dead, and neither he nor his immortal (?) soul lives to superintend the work of Christ on earth. Thus consistency avoids many papal traps which inconsistency very inconsiderately plunges headlong into. This proves that a failure to accept the whole truth often puts one in as awkward a position as though he had remained in the darkest error.