BIBLE OR CATECHISM—WHICH?

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 12, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 15.

Read the full edition

BIBLE OR CATECHISM—WHICH?

J. S. MOORE.
(Springdale, Ark.)
There lately appeared, in the London Telegraph, an account of the anniversary of the presentation of the Shorter Catechism to the English House of Commons, Nov. 25, 1647, which anniversary was held at the Marylebone Presbyterian church in London. Sir George Barclay Bruce presided. Addresses were made by Rev. S. R. McPhail, of Liverpool, Rev. Robert Taylor, Mr. Wm. Caruthers, the Rev. Peter Carmichael, and others.
The catechism was highly eulogized by the president as being “the book next to the Bible.” He said, “Therefore the occasion well deserves commemoration. It [the catechism] furnished the stuff that caused the robust character of the Scottish people,” etc.
Having been brought up a Presbyterian, I well recollect how, on Sundays, my sisters and I were appointed a task of several questions to commit. To this day I can recite many of them verbatim. There was much in them which, at that time, I could not comprehend, though there is much that is Bible truth. But even then, though a child, I found one thing that caused me some anxiety for a time, as I was taught to reverence the Bible as the book of all books, sacred and holy, God’s word to us, the truth for all time.
The part of the catechism to which I refer is found in No. 57, and reads as follows:—
Question.—“Which day of the seven hath God appointed to be the weekly Sabbath?”
Answer.—“From the beginning of the world to the resurrection of Christ, God appointed the seventh day of the week to be the weekly Sabbath, and ever since, the first day of the week, to continue to the end of the world, which is the Christian Sabbath.”
Question 51 gives the fourth commandment as it is in Exodus 20. All the other commandments are also given correctly, in their places in the catechism. I used to wonder why one could be changed, and not the others. I asked my mother about the matter, and she said it was done by the church. As I was taught that the church was composed of God’s people, I thought they had good reason for making the change,—that they would do nothing wrong, and could not be in error. So, like many others, I did not let the matter trouble me.
Some years ago, however, I read “Marvel of Nations.” This led me to investigate the matter carefully, and I found, by reading from “History of the Sabbath,” “Fathers of the Catholic Church,” “Two Republics,” etc., etc., that there was an apostasy soon after the days of the apostles. “The mystery of iniquity,” of which Paul spoke as already beginning to work in his time, made the change, or thought to do so. And in many places in the New Testament the apostles warn us to beware of “false doctrines,” so-called philosophy, etc.
I learned also, by reading the Bible, that the Sabbath was not changed and could not be changed; and that the Sabbath which was from the beginning of the creation to the resurrection of Christ, is also the Sabbath from the resurrection of Christ till now, and is so to continue to the end of the world, and from then onward, world without end. Isa. 66:22, 23. Then I knew that as certainly as I would follow the Lord rather than the apostasy, I must test the catechism by the Bible, and, accordingly, must keep not the first day of the week, but the seventh day; for the commandment reads: “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work.”