AdventAI

NOT AT ALL.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 15., April 12, 1898

If the premises of the opposers of the seventh-day Sabbath could be allowed, it would be a very easy task for them to establish their conclusions; but their premises are invariably unsound, generally consisting of some proposition wholly assumed, or in direct contradiction to the Scriptures; and this condition vitiates all their efforts to show that the Sabbath of the Bible is not now binding upon the people of God.

This course on their part is easily accounted for because, the testimony of the Bible on the subject of the Sabbath being clear and explicit, no argument can be formed against it which does not contradict that testimony, and thus rest on a premise that is false and misleading.

These remarks are made with reference to a little tract entitled, “The Seventh-day Sabbath Abolished, with the Ten-commandment Law.” It is by one Robert Lee Harris; and a brother has sent us a copy, with the request that it be noticed in the Review, inasmuch as it seems to be having some influence, in his neighborhood, in turning away the people from the testimony of the Scriptures on this subject. It is, says our correspondent, boastfully affirmed that it is unanswerable, and that no Sabbath-keeper will ever undertake to reply to it. For such vain boasting we care nothing; but we believe in, and take our stand upon, the Scriptures, and to try to help some minds which may be troubled and confused by the wrong views put forth by those who have themselves gone astray from the word of God, is the only occasion for speaking again on a subject which has been so often treated in these columns.

And what reason does the reader imagine is given by Mr. Harris, in favor of his proposition that the seventh-day Sabbath and the ten commandments have been abolished? Every Sabbath-keeper has heard the assertion so many times that it will occasion no surprise. He says: “I believe it [the ten-commandment law] is abolished, because it is the first covenant (from Sinai), and it is said to be done away.” Here, at the very threshold of his argument, is a plain contradiction of the Scriptures, with the false premise which he would have his readers accept as truth; but it is as far from truth as it can be; for the ten commandments are not, and never were, the first, or old, covenant, which was to be done away. It is easy to see why opponents of the Sabbath claim that the ten-commandment law, of which the Sabbath commandment is an inseparable part, was the old covenant; for the testimony is explicit that that covenant has been done away; and if that is the law which contains the Sabbath, the Sabbath has, of course, gone too; and in this summary way they hope to persuade the people that the Sabbath has ceased to be binding upon men. But when confronted with the impregnable fact that the ten commandments were not the first, or old, covenant, their whole scheme falls into irredeemable collapse, and cannot be reared up again. And this is precisely the case with Mr. Harris; and his tract becomes simply an ignis fatuus, to lead into the bogs of error those who are not careful to heed the solemn warning of Christ, “Take heed that no man deceive you.”

A moment’s reflection should be sufficient to satisfy any one that the ten commandments were not the first, or old, covenant. They have no features that come within the ordinary definition of the term “covenant.” A covenant, in its primary signification, means an agreement between two or more parties, into which they mutually enter; and the agreement involves certain advantages, or favors, to be secured to one or more of the subscribers to the compact, with conditions necessary to the carrying out of the whole. It must be voluntary on the part of those who enter into the arrangement; and the failure of any member to comply with the conditions, or to fulfil the stipulated promises, releases all the others from their obligations, if they choose to consider the compact broken. But any one can see that the ten commandments are not subject to any such vicissitudes. No man is at liberty to refuse to keep them; that is, such refusal would not release him from obligation to keep them. They express the will of the Creator with reference to his creatures. It is his right to command, it is their duty to obey. They have no right to choose in the matter. They have no right to entertain the thought, or to say to themselves, for a moment, Now we can enter into this relation or not, just as we choose, as would be the case in an ordinary covenant; and their refusal to keep, or failure to keep, from any cause, the commandments, does not affect those commandments in the least respect, nor modify men’s obligation to do and keep them. Therefore the ten commandments cannot possibly be the first, or old, covenant, nor a covenant at all, in the ordinary acceptation of that term. This does not prevent their being a covenant in a particular and special sense, as will hereafter appear.

Those who are familiar with the record of the formation of the first covenant, beginning with Exodus 19, cannot have failed to notice how often God states the conditions of the proposed covenant, and his repeated submission of the question to the people whether they would accept them, and enter into the arrangement or not. Not thus were the ten commandments introduced to them, for them to decide whether they would accept them or not.p. 238

And as it is thus shown that the ten commandments were not the first, or old, covenant, the whole warp and woof is taken out of Mr. Harris’s argument, and there is nothing left of it.

The greater portion of the remainder of his contention proceeds on the same false premise, and consists of a reiteration of the same misstatement in regard to the covenant, and a denial of the distinction between the ceremonial and moral laws; and the only argument necessary to meet his position is to bear in mind the fact that his premises are invariably false.

Thus he goes on in his second paragraph: “Now if the ten-commandment law is the first covenant, it is done away.” O, yes,—“If”? Done away?—Of course—If; but there is no room for the “if;” for the ten commandments were not the first covenant. His next effort is a denial of the distinction between the moral and ceremonial laws; between the statutes and judgments which the Lord commanded Moses to write in a book and that law which Jehovah himself spoke from the summit of Sinai, and with his own hand engraved on the tables of stone. That the ten commandments, apart and by themselves, are recognized as a law, and called by the Lord himself a law, see Ex. 24:12; and that the words written by Moses, apart and by themselves, constituted a law, see Deut. 31:24, 26. The ten commandments were not in that book, and were never sprinkled with blood, as the book of the covenant was. See Ex. 24:6-8, compared with verse 12, and Heb. 9:19, 20.

In the light of these scriptures the foolishness of another claim put forth by Mr. Harris will appear. He quotes Heb. 7:12 to prove his position: “For the priesthood being changed, there is made of necessity a change also of the law.” The lack of coherency in his argument here shows itself; for he set out to show that everything—Sabbath, law, and all—has been abolished; but this text speaks only of a change. But the intelligent reader will see at once that the apostle is speaking about the Jewish priests, not about the ten commandments. And the law mentioned is the law that regulated the ceremonial services of the Jewish economy, prescribing what tribe should furnish the priests for that service, and not that law by which God regulates the moral conduct of all his intelligent creatures. This text in Hebrews has nothing to do with the ten commandments nor with the Sabbath.

A brief allusion to a few other points will be sufficient for every Bible student. Mr. Harris says the ten-commandment law “was only to serve till Christ, or the new covenant, should come.” Christ himself says that the law (of righteousness. Matt. 5:17-20) should last as long as heaven and earth endure. Of course 2 Cor. 3:7 is referred to, and the claim set up that the ten commandments are here said to have been done away. But a law is different from the ministration of that law. It was not the ministration that was written on stones; and it was only the glory, not the law, that was to be done away (verse 7); and even this glory was “done away” only “by reason of the glory that excelleth,” not because the glory itself was not good.

Rom. 10:4 is also quoted: “Christ is the end of the law;” that is, says Mr. Harris, “he fulfilled it, and put an end to it,”—a claim very likely to be put forth by superficial readers. But what says the apostle?—“End . . . for righteousness.” To whom?—“To every one that believeth.” So, then, it is still binding on every unbeliever, at least.

“Till all be fulfilled” (Matt. 5:18) is made to refer to all the law. Here is the comment: “When it was fulfilled, it was to be destroyed.” But the “all” refers to “all things” written in the prophets, and covers eternity. The law endures till then.

Pages 8-14 are filled with misapplications of scripture, because the ceremonial law is confounded with the moral, which Paul says (Rom. 3:31), we do not make void, but establish by faith in Christ.

On page 10 of Mr. Harris’s tract, this singular question is asked: “Now I want to ask this question; viz., If the old law is binding upon us (the whole world), why did not Christ command us to teach it, when he was giving us the commission?”—All Christ’s teaching constitutes our commission; for we are to teach “whatsoever” he has commanded us; and on the point of the law he has been very explicit. “Think not,” he says, “that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets. . . . Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all [all things] be fulfilled.” Then Christ draws his conclusion (verse 19): “Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” This language is clear and explicit. It embraces all men, and it covers all time. It is sufficient for every child of God. And when men tell us we are to hear Christ, and not Moses, this is a part of what we are to hear. And he has said nothing to modify or contradict it; for his testimony is Yea and Amen. He has never told us of any new Sabbath to take the place of the one which he made for man, and sanctified in Eden.

U. S.