AdventAI

THE REORGANIZATION OF THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY.

By Edward A. Sutherland; Percy Tilson Magan

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 14., April 5, 1898

THE Battle Creek College is the property of the Seventh-day Adventist Educational Society. As a matter of convenience in this article, the society will be referred to simply as the College. The act under which the College is incorporated is not the most satisfactory for the purposes for which our institutions of learning are designed. The reason is clear. The act organizes the institution on practically the same basis as an ordinary manufacturing, money-making concern. The man who has the most money to invest in the institution has, in accordance with its present charter, the most to say as to how its educational policy shall be directed. Hence it follows that money, instead of consecrated educational ability, mayp. 12 control as to the subjects which shall be taught, and the methods by which they shall be imparted to our youth. Further, opportunity is given for a few to defeat the wishes of the whole denomination. But worse still, two or three men, and these not necessarily stockholders, have it in their power to prevent, for a time at least, the carrying out in the school of the principles of education given by the Lord himself.

Legally, those who have invested money in the College, and taken certificates of stock for the same, are its owners. Morally, there is another class of owners; namely, those people who have given large sums to the institution, and who have never asked nor received a single share of stock. In the ranks of this class may be reckoned one lady who contributed $10,000 in a single gift.

A few persons, so disposed, by gathering up proxies from unsuspecting stockholders, can thus thwart the object and wishes of these large donors, and discourage gifts.

The most pernicious feature of this commercial corporation is that votes can be multiplied on independent candidates to the exclusion of others who may be desired by the great majority of the people. This is accomplished by what is known as the cumulative method of voting. To illustrate: We will suppose that there is a board of trustees of ten members to be elected. A certain stockholder possesses ten shares of stock. These ten shares entitle him to ten votes. The law permits him to write upon his ballot ten names, and opposite each name place his ten votes; this is the ordinary method of voting. Now, suppose he does not wish to vote for all of the ten who may have been nominated, or suppose he wishes to vote for only one man, the statute gives him the right to cumulate his votes on one man or any number of men less than the ten, if he so desires. If there is one special man whom he wants to put on that board of trustees, he can multiply his number of votes by the number of trustees to be elected, and cast the sum of his votes for one name. In this case he has ten shares, and the board of trustees to be elected is to consist of ten men; therefore, the sum of his votes would be ten times ten, which equals one hundred; he could then cast one hundred votes on one man. By the use of this system, it is even possible for a minority to elect a majority of the trustees, if the minority shrewdly gathers proxies and cumulates votes, and the majority refuses to depart from the denominational method of voting; namely, the casting of an equal number of votes for the full number of trustees to be elected.

The possibilities in this direction were made very apparent one year ago at the annual meeting of the College stockholders; and the fact became clear to our representative men that according to the provisions of the present charter of the Battle Creek College, there existed the possibility that a few individuals might elect, as a majority of the board of trustees, men who would actually be hostile to the institution itself. When we say that the trustees possess not only the power to manage and direct, but also the right to dispose of and sell the entire property, the magnitude of the danger threatening our College calls upon every loyal Seventh-day Adventist to arise, and demand that proceedings be immediately instituted to reorganize the College on a more substantial and enduring basis.

It was because of the afore-mentioned dangers, that the trustees who took office one year ago immediately entered upon the preliminary steps looking toward reorganization. Inquiry of stockholders, through the columns of the Review and otherwise, brought but one response; namely, that the College must be placed upon a better and different basis. Committees were appointed to learn the best manner of procedure; but the board, after advising with some of our leading brethren, decided to wait until the time of the spring council of the present year, and thus secure the benefit of the advice and judgment of representative men as to the best method of bringing about reorganization.

According to the provisions of the Articles of Association of the College corporation, there is vested in the Board of Trustees full and exclusive power to “sell, mortgage, let, or otherwise use and dispose of” the property belonging to the society. In point of law, the trustees, and not the stockholders, are technically the corporation; and beyond electing the trustees, the stockholders are practically only an advisory body, whose views on all matters of business and educational policy can be received by the trustees, though not necessarily followed, because, if it were otherwise, the trustees would be mere nonentities, and would not do what the statute says they shall; i. e., manage, control, and direct all the matters of the College.

The unstable foundation upon which the College rests has been a source of embarrassment and discouragement to the faculty, because there has been no certainty but that the work built up by hard labor during one year would be overturned during the next on account of the action of shrewd and unfavorable stockholders, or even by persons who, while not themselves stockholders, have collected a number of proxies.

Soon after the close of the stockholders’ meeting this spring, some of the members of the faculty petitioned the General Conference Committee and the Board of Trustees to take steps looking toward immediate reorganization.

When the petition was presented, there was a general agreement that reorganization was necessary, but considerable debate over the best method of effecting the same. On the afternoon of Sunday, March 27, at a meeting held in the office of the president of the General Conference Association, it was agreed, without a single dissenting voice, that reorganization should be effected at once. There were present at this meeting the General Conference Committee and the outgoing and incoming College boards, with the exception of one member of the latter, including the following-named persons: G. A. Irwin, President General Conference Committee; I. H. Evans, President General Conference Association; Allen Moon, President Foreign Mission and Religious Liberty boards; J. H. Kellogg, J. H. Morrison, A. T. Jones, R. A. Underwood, A. J. Breed, N. W. Allee, R. M. Kilgore, S. H. Lane, G. C. Tenney, G. W. Payne, C. M. Christiansen, and E. A. Sutherland, the last five being members of the present—i. e., the outgoing—Board of Trustees. Of the incoming board, besides some already mentioned, who hold other offices, there were present, Elders U. Smith, Wm. Covert, W. B. White, J. H. Durland, L. T. Nicola, and W. C. Gage. Besides these, P. T. Magan and others interested in the work were in attendance.

In accordance with the mind of this meeting, a trust mortgage has been placed upon all the assets of the College, real and personal, to I. H. Evans, W. C. Sisley, and G. H. Murphy as trustees for the creditors, which mortgage will be used, under the principles of law and equity, to do justice to all and to facilitate the work of reorganization.

At this same meeting there was appointed a committee of ten, afterward enlarged to twelve, to take steps to bring into existence a new College corporation, which shall take the place of the old one; and which, in its Articles of Association, will guard against the dangers which threaten the school under existing circumstances. The following-named persons constitute the committee: E. A. Sutherland, Chairman; P. T. Magan, Secretary; G. A. Irwin, S. H. Lane, I. H. Evans, L. T. Nicola, J. H. Durland, J. H. Morrison, J. H. Kellogg, David Paulson, C. M. Christiansen, and E. D. Kirby. This committee have not, as yet, had time to formulate their plans for the future. As soon as such plans shall be sufficiently matured, they will be fully stated in the columns of this paper, and submitted for criticism to every reachable stockholder of the present corporation. The committee are proceeding upon the principle that every stockholder in the present corporation may be, and shall become if he so desires, a member of the new organization, with power to deliberate and vote in its proceedings, and to enjoy any and all privileges which it may confer.

Meanwhile, during the period of transition from the old corporation to the new, which period must legally extend over a space of time somewhat longer than a year, the educational work of the College will proceed under the management and direction of the incoming Board of Trustees recently elected by the stockholders at their annual meeting. The plans and policy which have been inaugurated during the current school year by the present Board of Trustees and the faculty will be carried out, as the incoming board is fully in sympathy with them. Every effort will be made to provide such training for our youth as will appeal to the good sense and religious faith of our brethren and sisters throughout the world.

Signed, in behalf of the Reorganization Committee:

Edward A. Sutherland, Chairman,

Percy Tilson Magan, Secretary.