AdventAI

TWO PARTIES—TWO METHODS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 47., November 24, 1896

The Catholic Church poses before the world as a church of perfect unity of sentiment. Catholics delight to point out the differences in sentiment existing among Protestants, and contrast this condition with their own perfect union. Many things, however, which are continually coming to the surface, evince that the Catholic Church is not without its internal heartburnings and party quarrels. True, they may not refer to doctrines, but to methods, but sometimes questions of methods may be very important questions. It is a well-known fact that for some time there have been two parties in the Catholic Church in the United States. There has been a liberal branch of the church, whose best exponent is Archbishop Ireland. This prelate has thought it possible to be a Catholic and an American, too. Satolli was sent over here to pour oil on the troubled waters. Now that he has gone, and is snugly ensconced at Rome, he has expressed himself so decidedly against the danger here of the Catholic Church’s becoming Americanized, that Bishop Keane has been compelled to retire from the Washington University. It is also known that both Gibbons and Ireland are not in favor at the Vatican. A Catholic priest of Washington, D. C., lately made the following statement, which sets forth the contention in quite a clear light. He said:—

It is true there are two schools of thought at the university, but on fundamental principles both schools agree. It is only in details that there is a difference. There is no heresy about it at all. These schools disagree on the best plan of presenting the Catholic Church to the age. One believes in winning the age by love and charity; the other believes in taking the age by the collar and dragging it in. That is all. There is no heresy anywhere.

It is apparent that Satolli believes in the “dragging in” policy. He is a Catholic of the medieval type. Others oppose this policy. Just at this time those who are in favor of “taking the age by the collar and dragging it in” appear to have gained the ascendency in the church counsels.