WHOM HE WILL HE HARDENETH

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 15, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 11.

Read the full edition

“WHOM HE WILL HE HARDENETH.”

This statement, with its context as found in Rom. 9:11-22, seems to be a source of real perplexity to many of the students of the Scriptures. In the context we read: “For he saith to Moses, I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion.” Verse 15. In verse 18 the conclusion is drawn: “Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth.” The conviction that these Scriptures furnish ground for the view that the moral condition of any one, together with his future destiny, is already fixed by the arbitrary and absolute decree of God, is calculated to weaken the moral stamina of any soul, and paralyze all aggressive efforts in the warfare against sin. A few thoughts on this subject may therefore not be without interest, at least to some of our readers.
Those who are perplexed over this and similar portions of Scripture, generally make the mistake of supposing that they have reference to the question of eternal salvation or everlasting destruction, as a result of the Judgment, in reference to moral character. But if, instead of this conclusion, we carefully discriminate, and confine the statements of the apostle to only those questions which he had in hand, all difficulty will, we think, disappear.
In the former part of the chapter, Paul alludes to a subject upon which his mind seemed often to dwell; namely, the coming of the Gentiles into covenant relation with God, as the spiritual seed of Abraham, thus coming into a position where they could be called his (God’s) people, who before were not his people; also to the fact that the Jews were to be provoked to jealousy by a people (the Gentiles) who were not a people (of God), and would be angered, or excited to enmity, by the favors that would be shown to a foolish nation (the Gentiles); and that God would be found of them (the Gentiles) that sought not after him, and manifest himself to them that asked not for him. See Rom. 9:25; 10:19, 20, etc.
Then he illustrates the “election,” or the preference manifested by God to certain ones in reference to particular blessings, by the cases of Isaac, Jacob, Esau, and Pharaoh. Were any of these elected, predestinated, or chosen, to everlasting life or eternal destruction, independently of any choice or action on their part?—By no means. In the case of Jacob and Esau, it was simply that the elder should serve the younger. But does it not say that God loved Jacob, and hated Esau? and are not all those whom God loves predestinated to everlasting life, and all those whom God hates doomed to everlasting destruction?—Everything that God hates on account of moral obliquity and inherent corruption will, of course, be destroyed forever. But it does not appear that the “hate” spoken of here is of that nature. Rather, it is of the kind brought to view in such passages as Luke 14:26: “If any man come to me, and hate not his father, and mother, and wife, and children, and brethren, and sisters, yea, and his own life also, he cannot be my disciple.” This use of the word “hate” is explained by Matt. 10:37: “He that loveth father or mother more than me is not worthy of me: and he that loveth son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me.” These passages surely do not speak of the exercise of any malevolent feelings, such as the word “hate” now generally means, toward father, mother, brothers, and sisters; but only that when the word is used in reference to one object, as compared with another, one is to be loved less than the other. In the light of this definition, Luke 14:26 would read as follows: If any man come to me, and love not his father, mother, etc., less than he loves me, he cannot be my disciple. Thus worded, the language is plain, and the law most righteous and consistent; for certainly all who profess to follow Christ, should love him more than they love anything else, and love everything else less than they love him. If they do not, they do not love him at all. Accordingly, we find in the lexicons one of the definitions of the word “hate” reading as follows: “In N. T., to regard with less affection, love less, esteem less.”
What is said, therefore, in Rom. 9:13, is this: Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I loved less than I have loved Jacob. This difference of regard may most naturally be supposed to have rested on God’s foreknowledge of the respective characters of the children; and foreseeing that Jacob would manifest the better character, and thus be better fitted to hold the leading position, was it not perfectly right and consistent for God to regard him with more favor, and to appoint, or elect, him to the ruling position, notwithstanding he was the younger of the two?
In this there was no unrighteousness with God. He did Esau no wrong. There were more blessings left to him than he deserved; but he did Jacob a great favor, as it was clearly in his province to do if he so chose. Likewise, in extending the gospel to all the world, God did the Jews no wrong; but he did the Gentiles a great favor.
In this regard the Lord further declares: “I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion.” He does not say, I will save to eternal life whom I will, and I will damn whom I please, without any action on their part. The mercy and compassion have reference to such distinction in the bestowment of favors as the Lord sees fit to make in this life. But even if we allow it to apply to the future eternal state, then another question may properly claim an answer; and that is, Upon whom has God said that he will have mercy, and whom will he reject? Has he anywhere declared his will in this respect?—Most assuredly. And he declares that he will have mercy upon all them that love him and keep his commandments; and that he will reject only those who hear his sayings, and do them not.
But the rule has also a reverse side: “Whom he will he hardeneth.” How does he harden any?—He does not do it by any direct and positive action on his part: he does it by placing them in positions where they can show out their natural dispositions by spurning the lofty motives brought to bear upon them, refusing to obey, and rejecting the mercies which are freely offered. According to verse 22, God bears long with the workers of iniquity. He does not at once cast them off, but endures patiently their waywardness and rebellion, all the while endeavoring, by every means not inconsistent with man’s free will, to bring them into harmony with the truth and into compliance with his purposes. And he abandons them only when they, in face of all the opportunities, and offers, and entreaties he urges upon them, persist in going beyond the reach of his mercy. The same principle applies in 2 Thess. 2:10, 11. God does not send upon any people (or suffer to come upon them) strong delusion, till after he has set before them the truth, backed up by urgent entreaty for them to obey it, and they have irrevocably refused to receive it or the love of it.
It was just so with Pharaoh. For years while he was coming up to manhood and to the throne of Egypt, with every opportunity to discipline his heart to truth and justice, and become established in righteous principles, God knew the kind of man he was, and what he would attempt to do to thwart God’s purposes; but he did not therefore interfere by his providence, as he could easily have done, to prevent Pharaoh’s coming to the throne; rather, he allowed all natural influences to work unhindered to promote his accession, for a very wise purpose; namely, to take away from the enemies of the truth all ground to claim that the Lord could carry out his purposes only because all the circumstances were favorable, and to show to all the world how easily he could counteract all that Pharaoh could do to hinder the accomplishment of his plans. Therefore the scripture representing the purpose of God concerning Pharaoh, says, “For this same purpose have I raised thee up.” God does not say, For this same purpose have I given thee existence, that I might damn thee, but, “I have raised thee up,” or (as the margin of Ex. 9:16 reads), “made thee stand;” that is, caused thee to take the throne of Egypt, “that I might show my power in thee.” If Pharaoh had yielded to God, God would have shown his power in him by making him a blessing to others and an instrument to carry out his glorious purposes, as it was in the case of Nebuchadnezzar. Pharaoh had a splendid opportunity set before him. But if he would not see and accept the chance God offered him, then God’s purpose was to manifest his power in that case, by triumphing over all his opposition.
God gave him opportunity after opportunity to repent, by requesting him to let Israel go, and sending judgments when he refused. But every time he refused, his heart became harder, not from any direct and arbitrary act of God to that effect, but by his own action in refusing to yield when he had the opportunity. In this way only did God harden Pharaoh’s heart; and the guilt of resisting God was all his own.
The principle underlying all these representations of the word of God is brought to view in the illustration of the potter, as set forth in Jer. 18:2-6. God, in whose hands we are the clay, seeks to make vessels of honor out of all the material he has to use, unless the clay mars itself in his hands. For the illustration falls short of the reality in one particular,—the literal clay is passive, inert material in the hands of the potter; but human hearts, represented by the clay, are endowed with the power of choice and self-volition; hence they can refuse to be molded under his plastic touch, and mar themselves in his hands. On the other hand, from being intractable material, they can yield themselves to his fashioning power, and thus be changed into a condition in which they can be molded into vessels of honor. But God will do the best he can with all the material in his hands, as far as it will permit him to fashion it.
In the world of God’s providence, he has good reason for all his preferments and selections, though we may not be able here to perceive it. He never acts arbitrarily, or from mere impulse and caprice. And when we come to the sphere of moral obligation, in which our actions determine the issues of eternity, this one rule will decide all cases: Those who believe will be saved; and only those who disbelieve will be cast out and perish as the chaff.
U. S.