The present is an age of association and organization. Isa. 8:9–13. Is it the time when unseen agencies are fulfilling Matt. 13:30? Men are instituting organizations on every hand. Most of the societies are secret in their nature; and they are becoming so numerous that it seems difficult to find names for them without descending to that which is absolutely childish. Thus a grave and venerable United States senator from Michigan, according to recent reports in the papers, was initiated, no doubt with appropriately lofty and imposing ceremonies, into the order of “Elks.” And not long ago it was stated that certain boys in New York City, carrying out the spirit of the age, in their measure, organized themselves into a secret society called “The Venerable and Ancient Order of Kids.”
But apart from everything that is grotesque and silly about this business, the fact remains that such organizations are multiplying at a rapid rate, and many specious reasons will be urged for joining them; and the question inevitably arises, whether or not it is consistent for a Christian to unite with any of these organizations. This question has occasionally been noticed already in the REVIEW; but on account of new queries constantly coming up, our readers will allow us again to state a few general principles bearing upon the point. No Christian can consistently belong to any secret organization, for the following reasons:—
1. Christianity claims to be the one element introduced into our world which alone can do for man, morally, mentally, and physically, what he needs to have done for him. Any one who embraces Christianity endorses this claim. It is therefore inconsistent for him to unite with any other order for the purpose of securing some additional good, which he would thus admit that Christianity cannot supply.
2. Secretism bears upon its very face a feature liable to arouse suspicion. Why should the work of any organization be carried on in secret? Can it be for any other reason than that principles are inculcated, or acts performed, which the members would not like to have the public know, for the reason that if they did know them, they would not approve of them? This feature is contrary to the example of the Master. When the high priest would know about the doctrines taught by Jesus and his followers, and asked him about them, Jesus answered: “I spake openly to the world; I ever taught in the synagogue, and in the temple, whither the Jews always resort; and in secret have I said nothing. Why askest thou me? ask them which heard me, what I have said unto them.” John 18:19–21. Jesus here recognized the right of the high priest to inquire into these matters and to know concerning them. But everything he had done had been done openly and in the light of day. He had no secret lodge to which he and his disciples resorted, and in which his doctrine was made known to them. Hence he replied: I have said nothing in secret. I have taught in the synagogue and in the temple openly before all men. Ask any one who has heard me, and he will tell you what I have said and done. Would the members of any secret lodge thus respond, or be allowed to respond, to any inquiries concerning their work? Would it be true of them if they should claim it?—By no means. Then their course is not in accordance with the example of Christ. How, therefore, can the Christian who professes to take, and should take, Christ as his counselor, example, and guide, in all things, consistently unite with such societies?
3. Another objection to secret societies is that every one who joins them must pledge himself to believe, or to do, something of which he knows nothing. Every lodge must, of course, have its officers; and the members are to obey the directions or commands of these officers. Thus each member, as he enters the lodge, must pledge himself to requirements of which he has no knowledge. Whatever prancing of hoof, or flourish of horns, is required of an “Elk,” he must at once perform. When a person buys a piece of property, he wants to know all about it and the title to it, before he purchases. If he buys a horse, he wants to know his record and his characteristics. If he is to marry a wife, he wants to become acquainted with her before the union. This is the only true and safe principle upon which to act. So when Christ calls a man to be his disciple, he tells him what will be required of him, and what he, on his part, will do for him. But he who enters a secret lodge knows not what obligations may be imposed upon him.
4. There are only two relationships recognized in the Bible as the ground on which we should do good to our fellow men, or on which we may expect to receive good from them. These are, first, the common brotherhood of the human family, as all are creatures of God; and, secondly, the more endearing relation of membership in the household of faith. So the apostle says, “Do good unto all men [that is one class], especially unto them who are of the household of faith [that is the other class].” Gal. 6:10. But members of a secret society propose to do good to one another, not because they are members of the common brotherhood of man or members of the family of Christ, but only because they have joined themselves together in the compact of a secret organization, thus setting up another arrangement as better than that of the Bible.
5. As to our own work under the third angel’s message, when the spirit of it is fully received into the heart, it will crowd out and thrust aside everything of a less powerful nature. A person fully imbued with the spirit of this time and this message, feeling that the Lord is about to come, that the world is to be warned, and that to him is committed a specific portion of that duty, will not feel that he has any spare time to spend in attending meetings of less importance, or any surplus means to use in any other direction than in the work of this cause. This message will be to him supreme, or it will soon come to be to him of no importance whatever. We do not therefore feel that in our work it is necessary aggressively to antagonize secret societies, as such, but only to set forth the great truths for this time, and in the interest of these to win the allegiance of thep. 158 hearts of men to Christ; for if the spirit of the message is in the heart, the question of secret societies will soon adjust itself. If this message and work is supreme in the mind and affections, everything antagonistic to it will be set aside. But if other things are considered of more importance than this, this will soon be given up. The two cannot go together. The rule that a man cannot serve two masters holds good here. One or the other he will in time discard, clinging to that which is the dearer to him.
If one is truly enlightened, the few principles herein set forth will, it seems clear to our own mind, be sufficient to lead him to hold himself aloof from all competitive organizations, and cleave wholly to the Lord and his work.
U. S.