AdventAI

QUASHED

By D. W. Reavis

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 43., October 27, 1896

The case against Brother B. A. Philpott, of Murfreesboro, Tenn., was thrown out of court on the following plea, made for the defendant by Attorneys Sheaff and Whitaker at the opening of the trial on October 21:—

The defendant for plea says that the indictment pending against him in this county returned by the grand jury at the June term, 1896, of this court, charging that he, said Philpott, on the 15th day of March, 1896, and divers other days before the finding of this indictment in said county and State of Tennessee, did engage in farm work; viz., plowing and hauling manure, which renders it exceedingly unpleasant to reside in the community of the said Philpott, to the manifest corruption of public morals, and so as to become a public nuisance to a large body of citizens living in the community, and against the peace and dignity of the State, is not a valid indictee, for the reason that the name of Byron Freeman, marked thereon as prosecutor, was not signed by said Byron Freeman, nor was the signature thereof, with his name as such prosecutor, authorized by him; wherefore, said defendant avows that there is no prosecutor upon said indictment, and this he is ready to affirm; and he therefore prays that said alleged indictment be quashed.

The presenting of this plea was a surprise to the court and the prosecuting attorney, and caused some embarrassment on the part of the prosecuting attorney, but he soon recovered sufficiently to take issue with the plea. Mr. Freeman was sworn, and put on the stand, and he stated that he did not sign the indictment, nor did he authorize any one to sign it for him; that he was summoned to appear before the grand jury last June, and in answer to questions propounded by the jury, testified to seeing the defendant at work on his farm on Sundays, and signed his name to his testimony, but did not enter complaints, nor sign as prosecutor; and that he was not willing to be the prosecutor in the case. The prosecuting attorney then apologized by saying that a mistake had been made by the grand jury in signing the indictment in the name of a witness instead of that of the prosecutor proper, and that he would withdraw his issue to the plea. The court could then have appointed the prosecuting attorney, prosecutor ex officio, if he had thought that it was a just indictment and should be prosecuted, but the judge ruled that the indictment was irregular, and could not hold, and discharged the defendant.

While there are no charges made, it is the general opinion that in this case the grand jury used inquisitorial power beyond their lawful limit, and in the absence of a prosecutor, or to shield the person making the complaint, they signed the name of a witness as prosecutor to the indictment to cover up their illegal procedure, doubtless thinking that the defendant would not discover this unlawful act; but unfortunately for them, they signed the name of an honest, conscientious man, who would not be used as a tool in such unchristian and unjust proceedings.

□ The people in this community are generally very friendly to our people, and denounce the arrest of Brother Philpott. If the grand jury indict any more of our people here, it will be done in the regular order and according to law.

While the trial was pending, a church was organized in Murfreesboro, and Brother Philpott was ordained as its elder. Five were baptized in Stone’s River on the Sunday before the trial, and the church was holding meetings every night, with a good outside interest. While some were trying to hinder the work by the force of law, it appeared only to tend to its advancement. In every case of this kind we see more and more of the real presence of God among his people. Our safety and our help are alone in him.

D. W. REAVIS.