AdventAI

IS APOSTASY POSSIBLE?

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 41., October 13, 1896

AFTER a person has been truly converted, and become a sincere follower of the Saviour, is it possible for him ever so to lose that experience, apostatize from God, and fall into sin, as to be lost at last? There are many expressions in the Bible which seem to affirm that such is the case; but there are many people who deny that this can ever be. It is important that a correct view be taken of this subject; for if one flatters himself that he cannot lose salvation, when such a result is possible, he could hardly avoid being lulled into a state of carnal security, which would increase his danger a hundredfold.

When one who has once been a shining light in Christian work, does finally plunge back into sin, and die impenitent, as many do, it is very easy to dispose of the case by saying that such persons were never really converted, and never were true followers of Christ, and so their cases do not refute the dogma of “once in grace, always in grace.” But the only satisfactory solution of the question is to ascertain the teaching of the Bible on the subject. What the marks of true conversion and discipleship are, or whether it is possible for one ever to tell whether he or any one else is truly converted or not, it is not the province of this article to discuss. The question in hand is simply to learn whether or not the Bible teaches that one who has been truly converted may apostatize and be lost.

Those who believe in what is called “the perseverance of saints,”—that is, that a person once a saint, is bound to “persevere” to the end, and be saved,—appeal in behalf of their position to such texts as Phil. 1:6: “Being confident of this very thing, that he which hath begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ.” In reference to the deduction drawn from this text, the question arises, On what condition does God begin in one the good work referred to?—On the condition of the full surrender of the heart and will to him; for he can do nothing for one till the will is yielded to him. But as free moral agents, we can change our will and withdraw it from him. Now will God go right on with the good work in us, after we have withdrawn from him the gift on condition of which he began it?—Impossible! Our wills must still be held in subjection and submission to him.

The invariable rule on which God deals with his creatures, individuals as well as nations,—a rule which is every way consistent and just, and inseparable from his own changeless nature,—is stated in Jer. 18:7–10. It is that when he threatens a nation with destruction, if it turn from its iniquity, he will change his attitude toward it, and send prosperity. And, on the other hand, when he speaks good concerning a nation, to build and prosper it, if it turn away from its righteousness to iniquity, he will change his purpose and overthrow it. The same rule will hold, and must hold, with an individual as well as a nation; that is, when an individual turns away from righteousness to iniquity, God cannot continue his work of grace with such a one, to his salvation. Such expressions positively show that those who are at one time recognized as righteous and acceptable in the sight of Heaven, and destined to salvation, may so change their course as to receive wrath and condemnation instead.

Another text appealed to is 1 Cor. 3:12–15. This passage speaks of the man who builds with hay, wood, and stubble, and then says that his work will be burned, but “he himself shall be saved; yet so as by fire.” Let it be borne in mind that the question under discussion pertains to one’s own individual experience; but this text speaks only of his outside labor. All that this scripture asserts is that a man may honestly labor in so poor and cheap a way that his work will not abide the test, and of course he can receive no reward for that, but he himself may be saved.

1 John 3:9 is still another text urged in behalf of the view that, once converted, no one can fall from grace: “Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin; for his seed remaineth in him: and he cannot sin, because he is born of God.” The reason here assigned why he who is born of God does not sin, is because His seed (the principle of spiritual life) remaineth in him; and so long as this abides in the heart, so long the person has a moral safeguard against sin. But the very language implies that it may not remain, by making the absence of sin conditional upon the seed’s remaining in him. Peter says that this birth is accomplished by the word of the Lord: “Being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible, by the word of God, which liveth and abideth forever.” 1 Peter 1:23. But Paul warns us that there is danger that the word may leak out of our hearts as from a leaking vessel. Heb. 2:1 (margin).

When in the condition described by John, we are of course counted as children in the family of heaven. But Paul in Gal. 4:1–11 has something to say to those who have become children, or sons, of God, and have the “Spirit of his Son” in their hearts, “crying, Abba, Father.” Such must be truly converted persons. But he warns them against going back into bondage to weak and beggarly elements, accuses them of so doing, and says, “I am afraid of you, lest I have bestowed upon you labor in vain.” Certainly, having brought them to where they were children, not servants, sons of God, endued with the Holy Spirit, his labor for them could not have been in vain if it was impossible for them to lose that relationship.

Space can here be taken for reference to only a few of the more positive texts on this subject; but they are so plain that they cannot be mistaken. Paul was certainly a true servant of God; but he expressed a fear that after he had preached to others, he should himself “be a castaway.” 1 Cor. 9:27. In Heb. 6:4–6, he speaks of some who have tasted the good word of God and the powers of the world to come, and been enlightened, and been made partakers of the Holy Ghost. Such persons must have been truly converted. But he adds that it is impossible to renew them again unto repentance, if “they shall fall away.” This certainly shows that it is possible for persons to apostatize, even after they have reached such a state of advancement in the Christian life that, should they fall, they could not recover themselves. Again, many who have once had their names in the book of life will meet the sad fate of having those names blotted out. Rev. 3:5. Many in the Laodicean church will be spued out of the mouth of the faithful and true Witness because of their lukewarmness; but they were once members of his church, or such a separation could not take place. See also such passages as 2 Peter 2:20–22; Rom. 11:17–22; 1 Cor. 10:6–11; Eze. 18:20–23. We also believe in “the perseverance of the saints,” in the sense that all ought to persevere and continue faithful in well-doing, and that all who do this and faint not, will surely reap the overcomer’s reward.

U. S.