IS THE CHURCH LOSING IN HER INFLUENCE OVER THE MASSES?
By A Clergyman
Is it true that education and right living, in the highest moral sense, leaving out the question of religion per se, obviate the necessity of regeneration by the Spirit of God? There is under the writer’s eye at this moment a paper containing the memoir of a soldier recently buried, in which it is said, among other things, that he had connected himself with the church in his boyhood, and remained a member in good standing until the day of his death. And yet there were many who listened to that statement at his funeral service who knew that for many years he had not only neglected the duties of membership in the church of God, but that he had tried hard to wear the brazen front of a skeptic in all matters pertaining to religion. The world believes better things of the church, and has a right to expect them; and so it comes to pass that when they note her inconsistencies, her influence for good over them is greatly weakened in the estimation of reflecting minds outside. Wherein lies the blame for this state of things in the church,—with the clergy or the laity?—Both are at fault in a measure. The great increase of wealth in the church has made costly buildings necessary, with all their furnishings, organs, choirs, and a high-priced ministry. Let it be understood that the clergy are among the truest and best men in the world to-day; but under existing circumstances, it is to be feared that few of them have the courage of their convictions upon many questions relating to the very highest interests of society. They dare not speak out upon the subject of temperance; for, alas! many men connected with the manufacture and sale of intoxicating liquors are found in the churches, and with their money are liberal supporters of the same. They are silent upon the question of stock-gambling; for sometimes men who are sanctimonious in appearance in the Lord’s house and on the Lord’s day, are acknowledged leaders all the rest of the week in the sharp schemes of the gambler. Would they declaim against the races, the fact confronts them that official men in their congregations, with their wives and daughters, are patrons of the exciting ring; and not seldom lesser lights in the church stake their money on the final issue in the same field. And so on down through a variety of evils which are sapping the life of the Christian church to-day. Men of God are silent upon these questions because their position in the church and in the social world depends upon their letting them alone; and one of the results is seen in the drifting apart of the church and the masses, more and more, as the days are going by. Not long ago in one of the Eastern States, a good Methodist brother wrote to the editor of one of the great official papers of the church, complaining of the lack of decision and courage on the part of his presiding elder. The answer of the editor was discreet, kind, and conciliatory; but the following week a ministerial brother of experience as a presiding elder, wrote to the editor also, justifying the brother elder complained of, because the bishops of his church would not sustain him in any other course than the one complained of. The return mail brought an answer from the editor in this exact language: “I acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the —— inst. Its contents are serious, and give me painful thought, especially as they appear to be correct statements of existing facts.” This is another straw showing the drift of things relating to discipline in the church to which these men belonged; and it is only fair to presume that churches without an episcopal form of government are in about the same condition. A pampered ministry in high places shuts the door against an earnest, courageous, evangelical effort to reach the masses of the people; and so in many places they are left to perish without the bread of life. The remark of a poor man, but a good man, a close observer, and loyal to the church and religion, may not be out of place here. Said he: “Bishops, secretaries, and other dignitaries of the churches, who have fine salaries and ride in palaces on sea and land, seldom preaching, only at conferences, synods, and dedications of the finest churches, where they see the army of the Lord on dress parade, may not be doing as much as they imagine toward the coming of the kingdom of Christ; while the masses of the people are toiling and sweating on farms, and in mines, and factories, and hard places in society everywhere.” It requires generalship, to be sure, in the army of the Lord; but certainly not one so far removed from the soldiers, who do the hard fighting, and the praying also in this particular case. Then the services of these times, in so many churches, have no charm for the devout soul,—nothing in them to lift up and cheer the chastened spirit,—nothing inspiring and helpful to the tempted and discouraged. They are cold and formal, and hence the people stay away. What a contrast between the simplicity and helpfulness of public worship forty years ago and much of it to-day! Then the massive hymns of Watts, and Wesley, and Doddridge, and Montgomery, and others equally gifted in sacred composition, sung by the whole congregation, had a sweep and a power about them that drew the people to the sanctuary, and lifted them up nearer to God. Now the choirs and quartets in many places indulge in nothing more than a performance, pleasant, perhaps, to a few cultivated ears, and gratifying to themselves, but utterly lost on souls devout, and intent upon the true worship of God. We are not to forget that the question under consideration is the church’s influence over the masses of people. Less than a half century ago the most of the churches in this country were filled with devout worshipers, in the cities and in the country alike, whenever there was a call to the house of prayer. Now only in exceptional localities, perhaps, it is an open secret that godly ministers and laymen alike mourn continually because of empty churches and almost all lack of any interest whatever by the people in spiritual things. In vain do many in high places shout themselves hoarse over the greatness of the church; her millions of members, and hundreds of millions of money; the great benevolent and philanthropic enterprises under her control. All this is an effort to throw dust in the eyes of the people, while society goes on drifting away from the church, honeycombed with doubt, and prejudice, and a skepticism that threatens moral and religious bankruptcy to the whole ecclesiastical fabric; while the handful of loyal soldiers of the great Captain, in all the churches, are crying mightily unto God for relief. During the last Christmas season the writer attended service in one of the churches belonging to a denomination which boasts of its culture and wealth, and, indeed, has large influence in the land. The exercises lasted just one hour and forty minutes; and the whole time, with the exception of eighteen minutes, was devoted to music and the ritual. The minister occupied the eighteen minutes in an address. Part of the responsive service was so poorly done as to excite the surprise and comment of a number of intelligent persons present; and yet it seemed to be regarded by the congregation present as a well-done affair; but there was absolutely nothing in it to touch or help the toiling masses outside; and so, having come to know these things, they stay away. Another very strong evidence of the drifting apart of the church and the people is the almost frantic efforts of the clergy everywhere to arrest and hold their attention by the announcement of sensational themes for discussion in the pulpit from week to week. This thing has gone so far in many places as to become actually nauseating to intelligent people outside; many express themselves freely, while others catch their spirit; and so the chasm widens day by day. Who is to blame at this point? People generally in this country believe the church building itself to be sacred, in a measure at least; hence its pulpit is not to be prostituted to the discussion of secular subjects or to the delivery of sensational addresses; neither are its walls to echo with the jollity and mirthfulness of the throngs which gather in many of our modern houses of worship to promenade to strains of secular music, or sit down to gossip over social questions at ice-cream or oyster tables. Those outside say, “We can do these things in other ways and places, and not violate our consciences by desecrating the sacred precincts of the sanctuary with secular affairs; and so the weakening of the church’s religious influence over the people becomes greater by the constant repetition of these things.”