The question of the use of individual cups in celebrating the Lord’s Supper, is one that is being agitated in many places and by various Christian bodies. It is one of those aggressive questions that will not be put down, but pushes itself to the front in spite of the scruples or prejudices of its opponents. To one unaccustomed to the thought of each one’s sipping the wine of the communion from a separate cup, it is received generally with more or less repugnance. There is something in the idea that seems inconsistent with the word and spirit of communion. The practise proposed would not accord with the example of our Lord and his disciples. Our Saviour did not take twelve cups and bless or give thanks; he took the cup. From this cup each drank, according to the injunction of the Master. These details have been dwelt upon with peculiar fondness by the church of Christ ever since, and the heart naturally clings to them.
But along came science, taste, and common custom, and these cry out that the practise of scores of people drinking from the same cup is not to be tolerated. It would be regarded as very shabby hospitality were all the guests at an ordinary table required to drink from one cup. At drinking-fountains each successive drinker does not fail thoroughly to rinse the common cup before using it. But the communion ignores these requirements of etiquette, and tramples all the mutterings of distaste underfoot.
But it is not a matter of etiquette or taste simply; the objections to the ordinary practise rest upon a foundation of serious facts. The danger of the contamination and infection of fatal and loathsome diseases is certainly much greater than most of us have been wont to consider. The almost universal custom of wearing mustaches by men, in which the bacilli of consumption and other infectious diseases find lodgment, increases the danger. The prevalence of sin has spread abroad diseases of a virulent, deadly, and loathsome nature. Good people sometimes contract these diseases innocently. These diseases are almost nameless here, but good people have them, and to drink from a cup with them is not only disgusting but very dangerous.
It is not necessary further to dwell on this subject; but it is probably before us, and we may be called upon to consider it. What we have said is not intended to cast a decisive influence on either side. If the order and circumstances of the first Supper are to be closely followed,—if they have a vital significance,—then they should be followed to that extent.