IS THE CHURCH LOSING IN HER INFLUENCE OVER THE MASSES?

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 29, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 39.

Read the full edition

IS THE CHURCH LOSING IN HER INFLUENCE OVER THE MASSES?

BY A CLERGYMAN.
This is the question we propose to discuss in this article; and let no one conclude from the title that there will be a great array of statistics, usually very dry to most readers. On the other hand, it will be found that plain statements of startling facts will be made, that ought to be of the profoundest interest to every thoughtful church-member, minister or layman, in this country.
There is a restlessness in the church, in this age, that often comes to the surface in serious questions by thoughtful men and women, concerning her lack of moral power and aggressiveness, which betokens a dissatisfied condition on account of her lack of success.
Millions of members are enlisted; hundreds of millions of dollars are invested in church property; millions more are employed in the support of the gospel at home and in missionary enterprises abroad; culture and talent of the first quality are found in pulpit and pew throughout the land; and yet good men and women everywhere to-day feel that something is lacking in the efforts of the church to civilize the nations and convert the world.
What is it? By our investigation can we find out, in part at least, the cause? According to the declaration of its great Founder, the church is to be the “light of the world” and the “salt of the earth.” In order to accomplish this, there must be in her, and emanating from her, a principle and an influence differing from that which governs any other organization in the world. This is true of the church to a certain extent everywhere to-day, and needs no argument to prove it. A simple statement of the fact will be accepted by all reasonable people.
In times of trouble and sorrow, everybody turns to the church for sympathy and help; and when death comes, however beautiful the ritual of any other moral order, the ministry of the church is recognized first, and no one complains. Through the teaching of the church alone men are to be saved, is an axiom so fully established that no one thinks of questioning its authority.
So far, then, there is no disagreement among ministers or laymen. But all this does not quiet the questionings of thoughtful minds concerning the lack of influence of the church in society. That she has drifted in a good degree from the simplicity of the gospel and from the spirit and teaching of the fathers, is the profound conviction of many of the best people to-day in all the churches. The fact of wealth and influence and culture and numbers does not altogether shield her from this suspicion.
The organization of the church for aggressive work in the cause of Christ, it will be admitted, is more complete and powerful to-day, outwardly at least, than ever before in her history. Look at her missionary organizations, collecting and disbursing millions of dollars annually; look at her societies of “Christian Endeavor,” her “Epworth Leagues,” her “Sunday-schools,” her “Brotherhoods” and “Guilds,” and so on, almost without number, in which are centered the enthusiasm and strength of myriads on myriads of the very flower of the youth and children of the land. Think of her “ragged schools” and “homes for the friendless” and “hospitals” and “asylums,” in which are found enlisted the means and sympathies and endeavors of tens of thousands of the best men and women of the land. Think of her vast publishing interests: of her “Bible societies,” scattering millions of pages of sacred and religious literature among the people, not only in the English tongue, but in foreign tongues and in distant lands every year. Look upon her collection of sacred song, containing much of the finest sentiment to be found in verse anywhere in the world; her pulpits occupied by men of culture and learning, the acknowledged peers of the scholars and orators of any other profession. Think of the beauty and sublimity of her ritual; the solemnity pervading all assemblages whenever her sacraments are administered.
Take one broad outlook, unprejudiced, over the field of her enterprise, and observe her mighty influence upon society and upon the civilization of the world in general; consider all this seriously, and you are forced to the conclusion that to offer a criticism upon the movements of the church and her work to-day, requires a man to be brave, or else reckless. He who dares the task draws the fire of a thousand zealous devotees of the church and of religion. Nevertheless we assume to say that all these things do not conclusively establish the fact that the church is not weakening in many ways and in many places in her influence upon society; and that a tide has not already set in, which, if it does not soon begin to ebb, augurs great ill to the church of God.
Everybody who takes any interest at all in religious matters knows that for a quarter of a century, in ministerial conventions and in lay conferences alike, the question has been discussed until it has become threadbare and worn-out, “What shall be done to reach the masses?” It remains yet unanswered, while the masses are drifting, and the influence of the church over them, it is claimed by many observing minds, is weakening day by day. One of the most significant and suggestive facts at this point for the church to consider, was embodied in the statement sent out by the secular press not long ago; namely, that at a great gathering of working men in a public hall in one of the great cities of our country, when the speaker referred to the church, there were hisses in the assembly; but when the name of Christ was mentioned, there were cheers. Now is there any room whatever for the indulgence or the cultivation of such a spirit by the masses in our midst? Let us see. And our inquiry shall be fair, honest, and tempered by a sincere desire to bring this great and important question to the thoughtful attention of any who may be seeking light upon this subject, in the very best possible spirit.
First of all, then, and chiefly: Blinded by wealth, culture, and social position and influence, the church, to an alarming extent in many places, has lost sight of her great commission, “Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel.” No one can mistake the meaning of this term in its settings, as contradistinguished from the many gospels of our day—the gospel of science, higher criticism, evolution, culture, and so on. Christ meant the gospel that saves men from their sins, and everybody knows it. But in spite of this knowledge, the church temporizes and hedges, and is most of the time too busy about things of subordinate consideration to give proper emphasis to the “one thing needful.” Her benevolent organizations and her philanthropic work absorb her time and strength until she loses sight of, or forgets, the interests of men’s souls.
Young Men’s Christian Associations, which will readily be acknowledged as an adjunct of the church, are too busy about ball games, bicycle races, and athletics generally, to make any direct effort to lead their members and patrons into a religious life; and so it comes to pass that intelligent, thoughtful people outside conclude that they are lacking in the vital principles of religion which alone can save men.
The inconsistencies of church-members very largely add to the loss of her influence upon society. He who founded the church says in his word to all who will be his followers by identifying themselves therewith, “Come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing,” and, “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.” But where is there any self-denial for Christ and his cause to-day?
There are scarcely any amusements of the world in which church-members are not active participants. The dance, the theater, the card-table, the race-track, are all the resort of the professed followers of the Man who was “meek and lowly in heart.” Almost all discipline in the church, wherever such a thing ever was known, has been lost; and any one connecting himself with any branch of the church remains a member therein until his death, unless he openly scandalizes the society, or voluntarily withdraws; and too often (who will assume to deny?) at the funeral service of some lifelong inconsistent member, or over the remains of a notoriously wicked man or woman, the most fulsome words of praise are spoken, or hymns sung which would be appropriate only at the funeral of a saint of God. And those outside the church look on and listen, and then turn away and exclaim, “What a sham in the name of religion!” and so the breach widens between the church and the world. Certainly we would make no serious mistake in asserting that if the church was right and in her normal and proper state in the days of Wesley, and Whitefield, and Edwards, and Finney, and their coadjutors, when men cried for mercy, were converted, and ever afterward led consistent Christian lives, then there is something very seriously out of joint to-day. Who ever hears any expression of sorrow for sin in this age of culture and refinement? Who ever sees any penitential tears? Can it be possible that we have outlived the necessity of these things, which the fathers regarded as being essential to a spiritual birth and to the soul’s eternal interest?
(To be continued.)