Persecution of the Albigenses.
BY PROFESSOR P. T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
I have often thought that the wrongs of the past should be referred to in the same spirit of tenderness as the evils of the present. The words of the Master, “Love your enemies, bless them that curse you,”1 should be applied in behalf of the enemies of the church in days gone by as well as to those of our own time. And it is not with any inclination or desire to rehearse the cruel deeds of Roman Catholics, that I enter upon the narrative of their persecution of the Albigenses.
The Albigenses were a part of the French nation, and the influence of the torments inflicted upon them did not die with the embers of the stakes at which they suffered. Those horrible tortures were destined to live in the hearts of men and women for long years afterward. They were destined to be repeated to the little children at their grandsires’ knees, and finally to awaken a belief that the God of the Catholics must be an awful being, not fit to be worshiped. The atheistical tendencies of the French Revolution have been commented upon much by historians. It is frequently urged that this was an extraordinary phenomenon of that terrible time, and one which was not correlated with the other questions at issue.
Such reasoning is, however, the result of a superficial view of the facts in the case. The French people of the eighteenth century hated God because such bloody deeds had been done in his name. It could not be otherwise, and the “Worship of Reason” was only a logical revolt from a system which seemed to them to be the most unreasonable form of worship imaginable. The sequel cannot be understood without the antecedent, and that is why the story of the persecution of the Albigenses must be related in this connection; but it is entered upon in the spirit of that well known adage, “With charity toward all, and malice toward none.”
The proselyting zeal of the Albigenses was prodigious. No labor was too severe, no risks too great to deter them from spreading the faith which they deemed essential to salvation. Their truthfulness and constancy were admirable. One of the members of the tribunal of the Holy Inquisition warns his fellow workers not to commence his interrogatories by asking, “Are you a heretic?” for the answer will be a simple “Yes,” and then nothing more can be extracted; but if the Albigensian is exhorted in the name of God to tell all about his life, he will faithfully relate every detail of it without falsehood. When it is borne in mind that this candor led inevitably to a fearful death at the lurid stake, it is remarkable to note that the inquisitor seems utterly callous to the emphatic testimony which he renders to the superhuman conscientiousness of his victims.
The earliest persecution of the Albigenses on record, took place at Orleans about the year 1017. Fifteen persons were led out to watch the kindling of the fires which were to be used for their destruction. As they looked upon the tongues of flame licking up the smaller fagots, and realized that soon their quivering limbs would be fuel for the relentless blaze, they were asked to recant, and pardon was offered. But only two yielded their faith, while thirteen remained stanch. Another group went to the pyre singing, “Blessed are ye when men shall revile you.” At the capture of the Castle of Minerva, the Catholics piously offered their prisoners a choice of recantation or the stake. There were one hundred and eighty of them in all, and to a man they declared for the stake. But this constancy gave birth to no tenderer feelings in the heart of the monk who has chronicled the event than expressed in his written words: “No doubt all these martyrs of the devil passed from temporal to eternal flames.”
It was in the year 1178, that Pope Alexander III published a call for the third council of the Lateran. It contained an ominous allusion to the tares which were choking the wheat and must needs be pulled up by the roots. The council “commended the employment of force by the secular power to compel men to their own salvation.”2 An indulgence for sin to cover a period of two years was promised to every man who should take up arms to extirpate the heretics. Each would be received under the protection of the church during this life, and those who fell in battle were assured of safe conducts to the world beyond. On such terms as these it was not difficult to raise an army of the warriors of these days.
Forth went this band on its mission of devastation and death. Nevertheless the heresy grew and flourished till the pontificate of Innocent III. A chronicler assures us that among many thousands of people, there was scarcely a Catholic to be found. But how different were the means employed by the Albigenses for the spread of their faith, to those used by the church. So great was the number of converts to the ranks of Albigensianism that unless some drastic means could be devised to check the “vile superstition,” it seemed only a great question of timep. 600 when the Roman Catholic faith would disappear throughout all the Mediterranean provinces of France. Although in the majority, the heretics never indulged in persecuting the Catholics. It is true that the nobles were rapidly depriving the Roman clergy of their revenues and possessions. This could not be objected to very strenuously, as the priests were neglecting their duties, and the monks were disgracefully lazy. But the Albigenses, however much they may have believed themselves to be the coming church, never thought of extending their faith by the sword. If they found a Catholic zealous enough to contend with them, they would reason, argue, and dispute. Everywhere they expounded the word of God to the people. But “they were content with peaceable conversions and zealous missionary work, and dwelt in perfect amity with their orthodox neighbors. This was more than the church could stand, since it had ever held that the toleration of others is the persecution of itself.”
In the year 1207 Pope Innocent III proclaimed a crusade against the people of southern France, and by the troops of the church under Simon de Montfort, those sectaries who had quoted to the indolent priests, “If a man will not work neither let him eat,” were summarily taught that there “is such a thing as wresting the Scriptures to one’s own destruction.”
It was at the siege of Beziers that the greatest atrocities were committed. When the city was taken, no quarter was given. “From infancy in arms to tottering age, not one was spared,—seven thousand it is said were slaughtered in the church of Mary Magdalene, to which they had fled for asylum.” The total number of slain in this one place is variously estimated at from sixty to one hundred thousand. A soldier more merciful than his leaders, asked the papal legate, Abbot Arnold, how he should distinguish and save the Catholic from the heretic. “Kill them all,” was the ferocious reply, “God will know his own.” Revolting was the carnival of murder and rapine of that awful day. Finally the town was set on fire, and the blood-red sun of that July eve looked as if the very skies were reflecting the crimson scene. What a holocaust was this to a Deity of mercy and love, whom the people of southern France “might well be pardoned for regarding as the Principle of Evil.”
At the massacre of Lavour, four hundred people were immolated on one pile; and it was remarked that “they made a wonderful blaze, and went to burn everlastingly in hell.” It is beyond the power of tongue or pen to depict the horrors that were perpetrated upon this innocent and inoffensive people. The very soil was saturated with the blood of men, and the atmosphere foul with the stench of roasting flesh. “From the reek of murdered women, mutilated children, and ruined cities, the Inquisition, that infernal institution, arose. Its projectors intended it not only to put an end to public teaching, but even to pervade thought. In the midst of these awful events, Innocent was called before another tribunal to render his account; he died A. D. 1216.”
How blind must have been the minds of these crusaders to the principles of the religion of high Heaven. In all their deeds they saw only the hand of God, and meritorious acts which would purchase a passport to eternal bliss. It is reported of one of them—Foulques—that once when preaching against the heretics, he compared them to wolves and the orthodox to sheep. An Albigensian whose eyes had been bored out and his nose and lips cut off by Simon de Montfort, arose and said, “Did you ever see sheep bite a wolf thus?” To which Foulques rejoined that de Montfort was a good dog who had thus bitten the wolf.
But enough; a fearful day of reckoning was to come for the church, in which old scores were to be settled and wiped out by the red hand of the Revolution.