LUTHERANS AND SUNDAY-KEEPING

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 4, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 31.

Read the full edition

LUTHERANS AND SUNDAY-KEEPING.

In the same paper from which extracts are given in another column showing the position of Lutherans on the question of church and state, we find an article setting forth the position of that church on Sunday-keeping, both as to the origin and obligation of that institution. The article is entitled, “The Augsburg Confession and the Doctrine of Sunday,” and lays down propositions which would forever debar the members of that communion from judging or oppressing their fellow men for any use they might see fit to make of that day.
It sets forth, in the first place, that the Sabbath commandment would be fulfilled by making every day a Sunday, only that the necessities of this life make another command necessary, that we shall work six days. In this life, therefore, the command can be only partially fulfilled, but will be fully carried out in the world to come; in proof of which reference is made to Isa. 66:23!
In the next place it is admitted that Sunday-keeping is purely and only an ordinance of the church, and has by the church been put in place of the seventh day as an example of “Christian liberty.” On this point the following extract is explicit:—
We would now inquire of the Augsburg Confession, by what authority the church ordained Sunday. The church “possessed rather more inclination and willingness for this alteration, in order that the people might have an example of Christian liberty, that they might know that neither the observance of the Sabbath nor of any other day, is indispensable.” Our Sunday is an example of Christian liberty. Had there been no Christian liberty, there could have been no New-Testament Sunday. The Christian church ordained Sunday, because she was left free to do it; she was neither compelled to do so nor restrained from doing so. She had been delivered from the old ceremonies; new ceremonies had not been appointed her. In this freedom from old ordinances she rejoiced, and rejoicingly and thankfully she concluded to make the day of her public worship an enduring memorial of her priceless liberty under the gospel of the Lord. It was her own voluntary act when she ordained Sunday.
It is Christian liberty, with a vengeance, thus to tamper with a law of God. But not content with this, they set it forth as a still further, and equally necessary, exhibition of Christian liberty, that one is permitted to keep that law, as changed, or not, just as he chooses; only if one thinks he must keep it, then he must not. The liberty to break one of the commands of God strikes one as a singular kind of liberty, a kind in which the most reprobate might rejoice. But here is what they say on this point:—
However, did not the church, by freely ordaining Sunday, mean to bind her members to the observance of just this day? God forbid! Had she done so, she would not have used but abolished Christian liberty, to the extent, at least, of the Sunday regulation. In that case, the church would have done the very thing that God forbore doing,—she would have fixed a new ceremony, and would have bound the free children of God to a human ordinance, thus putting the Christians of the New Testament into a worse plight than ever the Jews were in under the Old; for they had their ordinances directly from God. No; the power which ordained Sunday is still required for its maintenance. The people, says the Confession, were to “know that neither the observance of the Sabbath nor of any other day, is indispensable.” We keep Sunday to-day by the same right by which the church ordained the same; namely, by virtue of our Christian liberty. It is an example, indeed, of the Christian liberty of the church, but it is no less an example of our own personal, individual liberty. The Augsburg Confession teaches us that a church which says to its children, “You must keep this day,” must be answered, “Nevermore! If we yield this point, then we might as well turn Jews at once; for the principle of Christian liberty having been surrendered, what is there but the passing whim of men that is to keep us from a complete return to Moses?” Moreover, a Lutheran, on hearing of a must in connection with our Sunday, will say: “We have had enough of pope-rule before Luther; will you now make the church our pope?”
It is unfortunate that the fear of ordinances and ceremonies should have led people to take such liberties with the law of God, because it enjoins a day to be observed in his honor (Isa. 58:13); and it is very strange that in their abhorrence of popery, they should have adopted a popish institution; and in their attempt to exhibit Christian liberty, should have taken a course to show that they were still bound in the chains of tradition. But whatever one may think of their position, it is very certain that the large Lutheran denomination can never join in the hue and cry for Sunday laws, nor unite in oppressing those who deem it right, on conscientious grounds, to devote the day to any proper secular employment.