AdventAI

INCONSISTENT PROTESTANTISM.

By T. Valentiner

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 31., August 4, 1896

BY T. VALENTINER.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

“Father” Jessing, under whose charge is the “Josephinum,” of Columbus, O., a college for the education of Catholic priests, which enjoys in a special way the favor of the papal See, is also publisher of the Ohio Waisenfreund, a paper issued largely in the interest of said college. In its issue of March 11, he reported that one of his pupils had died, and said in his remarks, among other things: “We hope that the virtuous youth who has departed from us at such an early age, being the first deceased of the propagandists of the Josephinum, will, in heaven, be an advocate of our college, to which he was devoted with his whole soul.”

A Lutheran exchange, Der Lutherische Herold, of New York, said, after quoting this statement: “This is Romish.” Well, yes; the doctrine and custom of the praying of the deceased for the living may be a specifically Roman one; but the doctrine of natural immortality, according to which the souls of the deceased pass immediately after death into heaven or hell (if not into purgatory), is, we are sorry to say, also held by the great majority of so-called Protestants, although in direct opposition to definite expressions of the Holy Scriptures.

According to the latter, man knows nothing during the time intervening between death and the resurrection, and has no part, no interest, in this world,—for the reason, of course, that he knows nothing of it. Eccl. 9:5, 6. But when it is admitted, as most Protestants do admit, that the souls of the departed are in heaven, enjoying the bliss of that beautiful home, it should likewise be admitted that they probably have an interest in this world, the same as the angels have, and especially in the ones who were dear to them here,—their friends, relatives, and acquaintances. And in this case what would be more natural than to pray for them at the throne of God?

The reader will see that Protestants do not act logically. First, they profess to follow the Bible only; and then, notwithstanding, they hold doctrines which are directly against the Scriptures. Then they call the logical consequence of their own premises Romish. They act in this question as they do in regard to the Sunday question. In both cases they leave the Bible ground for the tradition of the Catholic Church. The accusation of the latter, that they have been “squatters” on Catholic ground for the last three centuries, holds good in both instances. There seems to be but this difference,—while they are not willing to go to the logical end in the question of natural immortality, a large number of them are not only willing but anxious, yea, even urging, coaxing, and compelling, and using whatever means they deem profitable, to bring about Sunday legislation and persecution, which is the logical end of the attitude of the papacy in regard to that question. At present they are doing what the late Pastor Scovell, a number of years ago, pointed out as “one of the necessities of the situation;” that is, they are making repeated advances to, and meeting repeated rebuffs on the part of, the Catholic Church, to gain its co-operation. That they will get it when the latter sees fit, is, of course, beyond doubt.

In all these questions we have to choose between the word of God and the traditions of men. According to the Bible, God does not let fleshly minded men live eternally (Rom. 8:6, 13), but only those who, through Jesus Christ, the way, the truth, and the life, have been brought into harmony with God, and fitted for the kingdom of love and glory, to be truly happy through all eternity, and to receive immortality. The life in harmony with God should begin here; and the true children of God will set aside all tradition, when it is brought to their attention, and obey God to the best of their knowledge.