In the Question Chair

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 25, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 34.

Read the full edition

In the Question Chair.

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

682.— SOLOMAN, JERICHO, AND RAHAB

1. Did Solomon die while living in idolatry? 2. Did the Israelites break the Sabbath in marching around Jericho on the seventh day? 3. Was Rahab such a character as would now be understood by the term “harlot”? or was she a public woman only in the sense of being the keeper of an inn, or house of public entertainment? P. E. McC.
Answer.—1. Very probably, according to 1 Kings 11, Solomon never recovered from his idolatry. At any rate he died with murder in his heart. Verse 40. 2. The Sabbath commandment gives us six days in which to do our own work. On the Sabbath we may not do our own work, but may do God’s work. Whatever God commands us to do, it is not our work, but his work. If the Lord had occasion, he might command us to saw wood all day, some Sabbath, and we could do so, in that instance, and not break the Sabbath; for we would not be doing our work, but God’s work. God did command the Israelites to march around Jericho for seven days in succession, one of which must of course have been the Sabbath. But in going around on that day, they did not break the Sabbath; for they were not doing their own work, but God’s work, which he had commanded them to perform. Which day of those seven was the Sabbath we do not know; but we much prefer to suppose that it was the last one, and that it was the Sabbath on which they went round seven times, and on which the walls of Jericho fell flat to the ground. But, as already remarked, that would be no violation of the Sabbath, because they were not doing their own work, but only carrying out a command of the Lord. 3. It is not necessary to understand that Rahab was a disreputable character. The word translated “harlot,” had come to be used, Dr. Clarke says, for innkeeper, as this business was anciently most largely carried on by women, many of whom, from their exposed situation, did not maintain the highest standard of morality; but the term would not necessarily imply a fallen woman. The Samaritan Chronicle (the Book of Joshua in Arabic, a very ancient manuscript) speaks of this woman as “Rahab, the innkeeper.” A note on this expression states the following additional facts: “The word here translated innkeeper (fundwiqyeh) is the same word employed by the Targumist (pundokitha) in Josh. 2:1, to describe Rahab. Josephus speaks of her only as keeping an inn, and the Jewish commentators (Kimchi, Jarchi) adopt this view. According to St. Matthew 1:4, she subsequently married Salmon, a prince of Judah, and thus became the ancestress of David.” To her business of innkeeping it seems that she added the other reputable calling of raising flax, an occupation not likely to be followed by those who had given themselves up to make a living by the practise of vice. The supposition that she was an abandoned woman would not be very creditable to the two spies, who publicly sought her house, and whom we may suppose to have been men of God sent forth on a divine mission.

683.— DO ANIMALS REASON?

If animals reason, as some claim, are they not able to discern between right and wrong? and then will they not be rewarded or punished according to their deeds? G. J. I.
Ans.—Many animals seem to be endowed with sufficient brain power to perform to some extent the mental process which is called reasoning. They often also manifest a sense of guilt, so far at least as it pertains to fear of punishment. But they have never given any evidence of being in possession of a moral nature, or having a sense of moral accountability. It is man’s superior organization that gives him these attributes, and makes him an accountable being, subject to future rewards and punishments.

684.— ASLEEP IN JESUS.

Some here who believe in the conscious state of the dead, quote 1 Thess. 4:14 in proof of their doctrine: “Them also which sleep in Jesus, will God bring with him.” Please give us your version. W. E. A.
Ans.—The text speaks about saints who are asleep, not those who are awake. If the saints are now in heaven, they are not asleep; and none will be brought from heaven asleep when Jesus comes. Read Heb. 13:20: “Now the God of peace, that brought again from the dead our Lord Jesus,” etc. Then paraphrase, in harmony with this, 1 Thess. 4:14, as follows: “For if we believe that Jesus died, and that God brought him up again from the dead, even so them also which sleep in Jesus, the saints who are dead, will God bring up from the grave with him, or as he brought Christ up.” Then Paul goes on to state that when Christ comes, the living will not “prevent,” or go before, them which are asleep; for “the dead in Christ shall rise first,” that is, before the living are translated. Then the dead who have been raised, and all the righteous living, will be caught up together to meet the Lord in the air.

685.— NUMBERING ISRAEL—AGAIN.

Elder J. P. Henderson, referring to the answer to question 677, in REVIEW of July 28, states a fact which throws some light on the records in 2 Sam. 24:9 and 1 Chron. 21:5, concerning the numbering of Israel and Judah. The reader will remember that 2 Sam. 24:9 gives the number of Israel as three hundred thousand less, and the number of Judah as thirty thousand more, than the record in 1 Chron. 21:5. The fact to which Brother Henderson refers in explanation of this, is the statement in the commentary of Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown, that Israel had a standing army of three hundred thousand men, and Judah a coast-guard of thirty thousand men, which, as they had already been numbered, did not need to be enumerated again. Yet one of the accounts, for certain reasons there given, omits the army of Israel, and puts in the coast-guard of Judah, while the other omits this body of the men of Judah, and includes the regular army of Israel. This would exactly account for the difference in the figures given in the two accounts. U. S.