FROM SANITARIUM PARLOR TALKS BY
J. H. KELLOGG, M. D.
(Reported by David Paulson, M. D.)
Question.— Is it better not to use medicine when one is sick?
Answer.— There are many different kinds of medicine. Some of them cure one disease by introducing another. There are some remedies—perhaps you might call them medicines—which are helpful because they aid nature in effecting a cure. I draw a very decided line between such remedies and other classes of drugs.
Some time ago a man who makes it his business to sell drugs came to the Sanitarium. While making up our bill, he said: “I kind of even up my stock here, because the drugs that other people buy, you don’t buy, and the drugs that you buy, other people don’t buy.” That is not strictly correct; still, we do not use the class of drugs for which there is the greatest call by those who depend upon drugs. I will not say but that the doctor who has not massage, trained nurses, etc., at his command, is often compelled to do differently in the way of using drugs than he would do with these aids. One physician said to me, “It is folly for a person to suppose he can violate all the laws of health, and then antidote his wrong-doing by swallowing some bitter medicine.” Said I, “Doctor, do you propose to carry that idea out in practise?” “O, no,” said he; “that’s quite another thing. If a man comes to me, and I find his tongue coated and his bowels out of order, and he says, ‘I want something to touch up my liver,’ I give him something. If I should tell him that he would better fast a little, drink some hot water, and stop smoking, he would dismiss me, and patronize my neighbor across the way; so I must give him his ‘little pills’ and something for his liver and stomach, and suggest to him that if he wouldn’t smoke quite so much, and would be more careful about his diet, it would be better for him.”
The fact is, people demand something to take. If a man has a pain or distressed feeling in his head, he wants something to make him feel better right away; he does not want to wait for the results of rational treatment. The difference between these two methods of relief—medicine and treatment—is this: if a person simply attempts to stop the pain, even if he succeeds, he is not cured; the cause of the pain is there as before. Pain exists just as much after a dose of chloroform as it did before; the person is simply oblivious to it,—he does not feel it,—and why?—Because his nerves are paralyzed. Now the difference between relieving the pain in this way and in the rational way, is that in the one case the pain is present, only benumbed, and in the other case the pain is actually removed by the restoration of the diseased part to its normal condition. In the former case we treat the pain, and the only result is to relieve the pain, and that temporarily; in the latter case we treat the patient, the pain is removed, and the patient cured.
As a matter of fact, it is nature that cures, whether a man takes medicines or does not take them. But the difference between the two methods is that the man who tries to get well by taking frequent doses of medicine has a harder time than do those who do not take medicine. If he takes a certain drug to benumb his nerves so he will not feel pain, he may get rid of his pain for the time being; whereas, if the congestion, the cause of the pain, is removed by nature’s efforts, the pain stops of itself because the disease is cured. Here, for instance, is a man who smokes to steady his nerves; when he gets up in the morning, he cannot attend to his business, cannot even run up a column of figures, till he has smoked. I have seen a man who couldn’t sign his own name until he had smoked a cigar, and another who couldn’t write until he had had a glass of whisky. So the man smokes his cigar, and the woman takes her tea or coffee, as a benumbing dose, because they feel nervous and hungry, and then they feel better; the nerves are quieted. This is because the nerves of digestion are poisoned. They were simply clamoring for something to eat, and the man has paralyzed them instead of feeding them. I have heard a great many men declare that if they took a chew of tobacco when hungry, they didn’t feel hungry any more. Now why is this?—Because the tobacco has quieted the nerves, but in doing so it has paralyzed the nerves of digestion. The same is true of every drug; and it is not only one part of the body, but the whole, that is affected by the drug. When a man takes a dose of opium and paralyzes the nerves of pain, he at the same time benumbs the nerves of digestion and circulation, so that he has less chance of getting well than he had before.
There is a difference, then, between curing a disease and curing the patient. Baron Liebig says we relieve one trouble by producing another. If a man has congestion and pain in his stomach, we may give him fomentations; the blood is drawn to the surface, the congestion is relieved, and the man is freed from pain. But that is different from giving a man a dose of opium and covering the pain up, because, in that case, the morbid condition is there just the same. One of the worst things in the world at the present time is the medicine habit, to which people are so generally addicted. If a man is sick, he thinks that if he can only find a doctor who is “smart enough,” he will give him something that will cure him. That is a mistake. People think that if they can find a mineral spring whose waters smell bad enough, or a medicine that tastes bad enough, it will cure them; whereas, the cure does not consist in the action of the waters of a mineral spring or in the taking of any drug, but in what nature will do for them.
Q.— What causes boils? Is it injurious to stop them by an application of iodin or turpentine, when they first appear?
A.— No; kill the boil if you possibly can. A boil is simply an eruption of germs. It is a common idea that people have boils because the blood is impure; and that is true, but when the boil breaks, it is not the impure matter from the blood that comes out; it is the best part of the blood, a part of the white blood corpuscles that have laid down their lives in defending you against the attacks of germs. Boils are the result of inoculation by germs. If these get underp. 470 the skin, and set up their work of suppuration, the pus will accumulate, and being pent up, will form a hard bunch. After a while this bunch will get soft, and when it is opened, the pus will escape. That pus contains the best elements of the blood, the white blood corpuscles, which have gathered there to destroy the germs, and have, as I said, finally laid down their lives in defense of the body.
One way to stop a boil is to apply hot poultices in quick succession. The heat thus applied will so stimulate the activity of the tissues as to destroy the germs, and thus cure the boil; or if it does not destroy the boil, it will bring more corpuscles to that particular part of the body, and so the pus will accumulate rapidly, causing it to “ripen,” as it is sometimes called, quickly, and the core that pops out will be a little mass of flesh around which the germs have formed until the boil is killed by being cut off from the rest of the tissues. An application of iodin will kill a boil, and this it does because it is a disinfectant; it kills the germs. Turpentine is another disinfectant and kills germs. The best way to kill the germs in a boil is to inject into it two or three drops of carbolic acid. But this would have to be done by a physician, because an inexperienced person might put the carbolic acid into a vein, and that would do harm.
Q.— In your opinion will a person who is not very strong contract rheumatism by living in a house where the cellar is damp?
A.— Yes, if a house has a damp cellar, it is an unhealthy house. Such houses are likely to have mold on the walls. A lady once asked me to look at the mold on the walls of her house; and she was fairly frightened when I told her that her house had the leprosy. She said that the mold on the walls was sometimes green, sometimes yellow, and sometimes blue, and that as often as she wiped it off, it would come back again. In proof of my statement that the house had the leprosy, I referred the lady to the books of Moses, who describes that very condition of the walls of a house as the leprosy; and I told her that he directed that such houses should have the plaster torn off and carried away, and that if the house did not then get well, it was to be finally torn down. But I informed her that in the light of modern science it was only necessary to fumigate her house thoroughly, and ventilate and cleanse her cellar, and keep it in that condition. I have been in cellars in which one could actually find his way about in the dark by the sense of smell, if he was at all familiar with the place; for instance, he could tell that over here was the potato heap; and here, hung up to the sleepers, was a codfish; and in another corner was the soap-grease barrel, full of soft soap, etc. It scarcely need be said that such a cellar is full of poisonous gases, which continually arise into the house, creating an atmosphere of death.
Q.— How many hours a day is it best to devote to study?
A.— All the time, except that devoted to necessary exercise. One need not study the same thing all the time, but I do not think that study is harmful. The idea that people break down from study is mere moonshine. If you find a young lady who has been “broken down by hard study” while attending school, you will find that probably her waist was tied up so that she could not possibly take a full breath; that she has been living upon unwholesome food, or that containing insufficient nourishment, of which she has been trying to make brains, muscles, and nerves; reading the latest novel in the evenings; and once or twice a week going out to some social entertainment, where she ate ice-cream at midnight. It is such things as these that have broken down her health, and not her school work. I do not believe our students are injured by their studies; I think it is the bad hygiene at home that works the harm. One should have a change, however, studying one thing part of the time and something else part of the time. In studying literature, for instance, one will at length find his brain getting tired, but he may rest it by studying mathematics, which will draw the blood into another part of the brain, and thus afford relief.
Q.— Will sulphur cleanse the blood?
A.— No; but it will cleanse the alimentary canal. Five grains after breakfast is an excellent antiseptic, and it will also prevent the growth of germs in the stomach. The real benefit of sulphur consists in its power of cutting off the supplies of poison in the alimentary canal, so that it is prevented from entering the blood. Nature cleanses the blood through the action of the kidneys and the liver.