In the Question Chair

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 21, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 29.

Read the full edition

In the Question Chair.

[DESIGNED for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

671.— BAPTIZED UNTO MOSES IN THE CLOUD.

Will you please explain (1) 1 Cor. 10:2, “And were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea”? Does not this favor the idea of sprinkling as baptism? (2) Josh. 10:12, 13; 2 Kings 20:9–11, in regard to the long day, and the shadow’s going back on the dial of Ahaz. Does this disarrange the reckoning of time in any way? SUBSCRIBER.
Answer.—(1) No argument can be drawn from 1 Cor. 10:2 in behalf of sprinkling. It has no reference to the baptismal ceremony as a church ordinance. If it had, it would prove immersion instead of sprinkling. See the work, “Thoughts on Baptism,” published at this Office. (2) The statement in Joshua and Kings in reference to the long day, and the shadow’s going back on the dial of Ahaz, introduces no confusion in the reckoning of time. In each case there was simply produced a longer day than usual. But the days all followed in order just the same.

672.— ADAM’S CONDITION BEFORE THE FALL.

Was Adam created mortal or immortal? T. E. R.
Ans.—This is an oft-recurring question, but there can be to it only one answer. Adam was not created either mortal or immortal; for those were the very conditions in reference to which he was put on trial. He was on probation, to decide by his own course of conduct whether he would live or die. Life and death were both set before him, and it was for him to choose between the two. So long as he continued innocent, and retained his access to the tree of life, he would live. If he proved disobedient, he was to die. On the line of obedience he would in time become immortal; but he took the path of disobedience, and by his sin became mortal.

673.— SIN AND THE TREE OF LIFE.

Did Adam eat of the tree of life before he sinned? Had he eaten after that, would that have made him an immortal sinner? M. C.
Ans.—Before he fell, Adam had free access to the tree of life, and it would have been very strange if he had not eaten of it during the time while he maintained his innocence. But once eating of it would not insure eternal life. Continual access to it, and repeatedly eating of its fruits, would be necessary. But it would not be consistent to allow a sinner to partake of that which was designed for innocent and holy beings; hence Adam, as soon as he had sinned, was driven out of the garden, and debarred from any further access to the tree.

674.— REPAIRING CHURCHES.

Considering the shortness of time, is it right to use our means to repair our churches? M. W.
Ans.—If such a question could properly be raised at all, it would apply more strongly to the building of new churches, than to the repairing of old ones. But the Master says, “Occupy till I come,” and unless we know that time is so short that the facilities we need could never be used, they should be provided. If a new house of worship is needed, build it. If one needs repairing, repair it, that decent and comfortable places may be provided where persons may listen to the truth.

675.— THE FAST OF JOEL 2.

Does Joel 2:15, 16 teach that children who have not reached years of accountability, should be required to fast? D. J. C.
Ans.—In order for a fast, or a religious exercise of any kind, to be of any virtue, it must be entered upon understandingly, with a sense of its necessity, and with a clear perception of the object in view. This infants cannot do; hence there can be no good object gained by compelling a fast on their part, into the knowledge or spirit of which they of course cannot enter. The same rule would apply here as in baptism. All are commanded to be baptized. But before one can properly take this ordinance, he must be of sufficient age to repent and believe, as these steps are necessary for proper baptism. Mark 16:16; Luke 24:47. But infants cannot do this; hence they are not proper subjects for baptism.

676.— RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.

Please explain how one can at the same time advocate religious liberty and close communion, especially in view of 1 Cor. 11:29, and the example of our Saviour himself in eating with a well-known traitor. O. G. N.
Ans.—Every man has the natural right to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience, or not to worship at all, if he is so disposed; and no one has any right to interfere with another in this respect, if he does not trespass upon the rights of any one else. This is what is understood by the expression “religious liberty.” But that is not saying that we must fellowship as right every form of religion or non-religion that any one may adopt. We must be governed by our understanding of the teaching of the word of God, as to those whom we are to receive into communion and fellowship, as those who, in our judgment, are following the teachings of the Bible. This is our liberty, and others have the same liberty in regard to ourselves. Often, no doubt, persons come to the Lord’s table, who, in heart, are not worthy, and to whom 1 Cor. 11:29 would apply; but as we can judge only from outward appearances, and cannot read the heart as the Lord does, we cannot judge them. As to Judas, before he yielded to the power of the deceiver, and committed his great sin, he had no doubt given evidence of being affected by the gospel of Christ. At least he had not given evidence that he was hostile to Christ, or would turn traitor to him; for when Christ announced that one would betray him, it seemed that no one was aware that it would be Judas. Such was his standing up to the last interview that Christ had with him; and although Christ knew what Judas was about to do, Judas had not then committed the crime, and Christ passes judgment on no one beforehand. Hence, he could do no other way than to let events pass on in their natural order, till Judas had fully developed himself. U. S.