PREPONDERATING PRESUMPTION

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 30, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 26.

Read the full edition

"PREPONDERATING PRESUMPTION."

Safe men in an argument prefer the solid ground of facts to stand upon, instead of inferences or assertions. But Sunday observers content themselves with what they confess to be mere “presumption.” So long as they cling to Sunday-keeping, they are forced to that kind of defense; for Sunday has nothing better to offer. They do not, however, deserve any special commiseration; for they have full liberty to come over, if they will, to the ground of solid facts, which is the side of the Sabbath of the Bible.
A very singular article appears on this subject in the New York Observer of June 11. It is headed “Sunday or Sabbath?” and starts out as follows: “The American people have come to the point where they must choose between Sunday and the Sabbath.” In this the writer states more than he intends. What he says is true in regard to the institutions themselves, but unfortunately he means only between the terms to be applied to the day of rest. He fights shy of Seventh-day Adventists in this manner: “We do not mean by this statement to imply any indorsement of the narrow and essentially Judaizing views of those good brethren who argue for seventh-day observance. Such historical considerations as seem to support their contention can be met, argument for argument, with a preponderating presumption and pressure in favor of the observance of that day in the week as our Sabbath on which the Lord shed a perpetual resurrection glory.”
This is a good confession that there are at least historical considerations which seem to favor our side of the question; and that all the other side has with which to meet them is “preponderating presumption.” It matters not what kind it is, or how much there is of it; if it is presumption, the more there is, the worse for them. It is here called “preponderating,” which is a very accurate word in this place; for there is a most unlimited amount of it on that side of the subject. But we prefer the historical considerations where the solid facts are to be found.
The next point is an admission that it really makes no difference what day we keep, after all; and Rom. 14:5 is quoted to prove it. That seems to be for the purpose of preparing the way to discount the work of the Seventh-day observers after this fashion: “The seventh-day people, while at liberty to observe any day they like, so long as they regard it ‘unto the Lord,’ concern themselves with a very doubtful and essentially a side issue when they waste time . . . over a campaign in favor of Saturday rather than of Sunday.”
Is it a side issue to try to find out just what God means by a commandment, and then try to keep it just as God has required of us? The only commandment for a weekly Sabbath there is in the Bible, is the one which points out and specifies the seventh day as the day to be kept,—the commandment which shows why the seventh day was chosen, and why no other day could possibly answer the purpose. Is it, then, a side issue to contend for that very day, and for that very reason? Our friend might just as well say that in the case of Nadab and Abihu, fire only was the essential thing, the kind of fire being only a side issue. The Lord did not think so. Leviticus 10.
After saying that “it is eminently proper” that the day of the resurrection of Christ should be chosen as the Christian Sabbath, the writer says: “And it is really enough to reply to the specious arguments of the seventh-day Judaizers, Ours is not Jews’ day, but Lord’s day.” Is it possible that any one can be so thoughtless as to write thus concerning the Sabbath of the Lord? Where in the Bible is the Lord’s Sabbath ever called the “Jews’ day”? But how often has God asserted his own claim to the day. It is everywhere “the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” “my holy day,” etc.; and what an insult is it to God to take the day which he has so repeatedly called his own day, and give it to the Jews, and then sneeringly call it “Jews’ day”! But this is only half of his crime; for he then takes another day, which the Lord has never claimed as his, and thrusts that into the place which he has made vacant by his most daring act of taking out the Sabbath of the Lord, and assigning it to the Jews, and calls that the Lord’s day.
Next it is affirmed that the essential idea of Sabbath-keeping is only one day of rest out of seven; on which the writer says, “The Lord knew what was best for man when he settled on this proportion of rest to labor.” Yes, and the Lord also knew best when he said that the day of rest should be the seventh day, and no other, because that in it, that definite day, he had rested from the work of creation.
Now our friend comes to the chief difficulty which confronts him. He says: “Sunday, we know, is a term which has pagan associations, and that does not necessarily carry with it anything in the way of religious observance. How to convert a heathen Sunday into a Christianized and Christianizing Sabbath is the question.”
That indeed is the question, not for those who have returned to the true Sabbath, but for the Sunday-keeping world. Sunday is essentially a heathen institution, and it cannot be Christianized, because the Bible has never given any instructions in that regard; and it can never become a Christianizing agency, because it has not that nature; and woe to the church or state which shall endeavor, without any divine sanction, to enforce it by human decrees and civil penalties.
Again we quote: “If the American people neglect God on God’s day, they will become practically as heathen as Sunday (Sunnan Dæg) was before Christ laid his sanctifying touch upon it.” God’s day is the seventh day, and the American people, with a small exception, are ignoring it. What, then, about their relation to God? But what the churches are clamoring to have enforced upon the people, that they may not neglect it, is an institution wholly heathen in its origin, and papal in its nursing; and this is urged as necessary to save the people from becoming heathen. But it is only like giving a man whisky to keep him from getting drunk. But where, we ask, did Christ ever lay his “sanctifying touch” upon Sunday? He never mentioned it, nor rested upon it, nor set it apart, nor blessed it, nor called it holy, nor gave any commandment for its observance, nor any example for such a practise, either himself or through his apostles. It is no wonder that this writer further says, “We deal therefore with a very intricate Sabbath problem.” Those who are thus trying to sustain the Sunday practise are indeed perplexed over it, and well they may be. The trouble is, they are trying to enforce an institution as of God, which he has never ordained, and to sustain it by his word, which says nothing about it.
To the keeper of the Bible Sabbath there is nothing intricate or puzzling about the matter. God has given one Sabbath commandment, and no other; and he has set apart one day for the Sabbath, and no other. He has stated facts concerning this day as the reason why it has been chosen as the Sabbath, which are not true of any other. He has given as the object of the Sabbath that which can be secured by that one day, and by no other; and he has placed the Sabbath commandment in the bosom of a law which is, in its very nature, immutable and eternal.
The simple work God’s servants have to do is to keep his commandments themselves, and make known to the world God’s claims upon all men; and he has promised his Holy Spirit to aid in the work, and will himself attend to the results which must follow disobedience. What we would urge every professed follower of Christ to do, had we a voice to reach every ear, would be to return to the institution which God has ordained, preach and practise according to his word, and do what can be done to lead men to be reconciled to God, and urge this by the sanction of his revealed will and the promised aid of the Holy Spirit, and then leave the results with him.
O that all could realize what unnecessary trouble they make themselves by clinging to wrong views, instead of cheerfully and quietly yielding to God’s word, and making their practise conform thereto. All that is necessary to do this is to leave self out of the question, and bow to the word of God as that which is always right, and the authority of which is supreme.
U. S.