FROM the very first of the present insurrection on the island of Cuba, the people of the United States have very generally sympathized with those in rebellion, and have hoped for their ultimate success. There are several reasons for this. The ancestors of the people of this country were themselves so-called rebels. They felt aggrieved at the treatment which they received from their mother country, and to gain those rights which they believed “nature and nature’s God” designed that they should possess, they raised the standard of rebellion, and after a long and arduous struggle, they gained their independence. This being the case, when the people of this country see another people in this western hemisphere, which they believe is consecrated to liberty, struggling as did their fathers against an Old-World power, they very naturally feel that another battle for freedom is on, and so their sympathies are drawn out for the insurgents. It is also a well-known fact that Spain, once the proud possessor of Mexico, Central America, and a very large part of South America, has lost all these countries by revolutions and rebellions similar to the one now raging in Cuba. The natural inference drawn by the people of the United States is that had these colonists been well treated, they would have remained until this day as integral parts of the Spanish domain. Senator Vest referred to these losses of Spain by saying, in a speech in the Senate, that she “is an old wolf which has lost all her litter but one, and is now trying to gnaw that one to death!”
The Spanish government is aware of this feeling in the United States, and is rousing to the necessity of doing something to change the current of American feeling, so that it will be more favorable to the Spanish government. To this end it has authorized the sending out of a large pamphlet, the title of which is the same as that of this article, to all the newspapers which are in this country. If one should read this pamphlet and believe all it says, making no allowance for national vanity, or the probability that there is another side to the question, one would believe that Spain is one of the most enlightened and progressive nations on the earth; and that she has always treated her colonists with a great deal of tenderness; and that not one of the countries which once acknowledged her sway, and which now are independent, had any real grievances whatever.
Two of the statements put forth in this governmental document are worthy of note: First, that the grantees of land (that is, those to whom Spain gave tracts of land) took great pains to “teach them [the natives] the Christian faith, preaching it to them for their salvation, and to treat, aid, and defend the other Spanish subjects and vassals, so that by such means the natives might be drawn toward the suzerainty of Spain. . . . For the indoctrination and protection of natives, and of the slaves, Negroes, and mulattoes, priests were appointed and parishes established,” etc. We may see in this statement of pretended good the very germ of evil which has followed the flag of Spain everywhere. Priests were appointed by the government, and the education—if idle tales of the saints, and knowledge sufficient to recite a few stereotyped prayers and count their beads, may be dignified by such a name—was committed to their care. The first thing done for the natives was to fasten the incubus of a State Church upon them along with the civil authority of Spain. Under this double burden they staggered along until one by one they threw off the civil authority of Spain, and since that time there has been a continual struggle between the people of these countries and this Spanish inheritance of the State Church. Under the influence of the Catholic State Church of Spain, which became in turn the State Church of the colonies in their independent condition, there was no religious liberty, so that the religious tyranny which still oppresses the people of the former Spanish colonies is a Spanish inheritance of evil. It is idle talk for Spain to say that the people of her colonies have all the liberties which are granted to the people in Spain. That does not come up to our American standard. In Spain there is no freedom of religious worship. The name of Spain stands for tyranny, while the name of America has come to mean freedom in both civil and religious things. It is an obvious fact that there can be no true liberty or rational progress under a system of religious oppression. The slow progress of Spain’s former colonies, then, is directly traceable to her system of government, in the union of the church with the state, which these colonies inherited from Spain; and their progress can never be anything but nominal until this priestly rule is broken.
The second point to note in the Spanish document is the statement that “the outbreaks of Cuban insurrections have coincided in time with the intention of the metropolis [Spain] to transport to Cuba the most radical legislative innovations, which innovations have been deemed in Spain marks of progress. The Cuban revolt of Yara [the previous revolt] was almost simultaneous with the Spanish democratic revolution of 1868.”
Here the grave charge is made by the Spanish government that Cuba has rebelled just as Spain was about to grant great reforms. The fact is that the coincidence was because the same spirit was moving Spain that was moving Cuba. In Spain it was a partial going over to democratic principles; in Cuba it was absolute rebellion in behalf of these principles. By the force of the democratic party in Spain, the Spanish government was compelled to promise reforms and to start to carry them out; but the same current was so strong in Cuba that the people sought more than reform,—they sought for a separate government, where these reform principles might be better carried out. Hence the other, and the present rebellion. If we shall allow that Spain’s statement of her colonial policy is entirely true, and that her colonists never had any just cause for rebellion and separation, we must conclude that the American rebellion and revolution set an evil and unnecessary example to the Spanish colonists. No American will admit this, and very few Englishmen, at the present time, would care to make such a statement.
M. E. KELLOGG.