AdventAI

THE BEER QUESTION IN BAVARIA.

By J. L. Corning

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 22., June 2, 1896

Here in Bavaria, where I write, all beer is subject to strict governmental inspection; and, if adulterations are found in it, the police authorities empty it into the public sewers, the brewer bearing all losses and paying all costs. As a consequence, Bavarian beer is famed all over the world for its purity; and, chemically considered, its reputation is justly deserved. They call beer in Bavaria “liquid bread,”—a name which some would think to be not very complimentary to the “staff of life.” Be this as it may, it is certain that beer constitutes a large fraction of the nutriment of the people, especially of the peasantry. With this latter element of society I have had much intercourse for several years, and know their habits and dietetic resources pretty well. As a rule, the peasants of Bavaria are practically vegetarians. Not that they have any dietetic theories as to the uses of animal and vegetable food respectively; for they have commonly no theories under the sun. Sunday is the only day in the week on which the peasants of Bavaria allow themselves the luxury of meat, simply because the conditions of poverty prohibit the indulgence. Beer being cheaper than meat, the working classes resort to it as a staple article of nourishment.

It is a fact of common observation that alcohol, even in small doses, possesses the power of breaking down human self-control to a most extraordinary degree. The use of alcohol is the exception, and the abuse of it is the rule, in human experience. Nine tenths of mankind,—I am almost ready to say ninety-nine hundredths,—if they admit the smallest quantity of this poison into their systems, will find themselves crippled in will-power, so that inordinate indulgence becomes almost inevitable. In this regard beer comes within the limits of suspects, and justly so. Beer contains a minimum of alcohol; but that minimum is enough to kindle, in the great majority of organisms, a thirst which is sure to lead to immoderate indulgence. How many beer drinkers, do you suppose, keep themselves, here or anywhere else, within the strict limits of dietetic law?—Not one in twenty; perhaps not one in fifty. The overwhelming majority of beer-drinkers in Bavaria, where beer is the purest and most innocuous, are intemperate in the use of it. Do I mean that every one of this mighty constituency of Gambrinus gets drunk?—No, not that; but the great majority go beyond the bounds of utility, and, in the enjoyment of their beloved and so-called “innocent” beverage, get physical and mental damage of various kinds and degrees. Bavarian pathology shows a frightful procession of fatal maladies which are distinctly traceable to excessive beer-drinking. A physician told me not long ago that he had assisted in a large number of autopsies, and had observed an astonishing proportion of fatty hearts. This in a great Munich hospital, remember, in an environment where the tall brewery chimneys outnumber the church spires ten to one, and where they boast, and truthfully boast, of brewing the purest beer in the world!

I sat in the court brewery not long since, drinking a mug of what is called the best beer on the earth. The mug holds a quart, and the drinking of its contents should occupy an hour. So there was ample time to be sociable. I said to my neighbor, “Friend, this quart is all I can well get away with.” “You surprise me,” he replied. “I drank sixteen yesterday myself, and I am a moderate drinker.” Twenty, and even thirty, quarts a day is not an uncommon limit in this portion of the globe. Is it to be wondered at that adipose, with its host of hidden perils, is a common disease? A more melancholy spectacle than one encounters in a swimming bath hereabouts, is rarely to be seen. In an occasional vision of the menagerie there on exhibition, I have asked myself if Germany is in danger of Russian or French invasion more than she is of the mighty army of adipose.

There is a form of physical indisposition not uncommon in the lists of Bavarian mortality, which goes under the name of Schlag. Perhaps I should use a word slightly more emphatic than “indisposition,” for this special phase of it generally kills. It is nothing more than the springing a leak of one or more blood-vessels in the brain, known among us at home, I believe, as apoplexy. This is a common form of disease among immoderate beer drinkers, and most beer-drinkers are immoderate. Once in a while,—in fact, very often,—I read in the German papers that, “in the inscrutable decree of God, Mr. So-and-so has suddenly died of Schlag.” Now, if they would only confess themselvesp. 343 pagans, and write “Gambrinus,” the divinity of beer, instead of the other name, I would write “Amen” under these obituary notices. Why do these rationalistic Teutons thus deceive themselves?

I have often, at home,—that is, in my American home, for I have a Bavarian home as well,—I have often heard the wish expressed that the drinks of Germany might, on the western continent, get the upper hand to the degree of crowding out the dreadful curse of drunkenness—a wish certainly to be commended in the motive of it, but somewhat at fault as to the historical fact. Of drunkenness of the American type,—that is, the congregation of devils bred by whisky and other distilled liquors, there certainly is not a great deal in Germany. But this is not to say that the “beer-drunk” does not prevail to an alarming extent, or that it is not a form of physical and mental insanity sad and shameful to contemplate. The beer-drunk is the great curse of the laboring class in Bavaria, and, I conjecture, likewise in Germany generally. It has been my wont for several years to be awakened out of sleep in the small hours of Sunday and Monday mornings by the insane howlings and wild songs of midnight revelers returning from beer-cellars and gardens, where multitudes of them leave all, or nearly all, the earnings of the week, which should have gone to the support of their wives and children. This is a very sad condition of things to contemplate in a civilized and Christian community, especially when one hears not the faintest suggestion from any quarter of an attempt at reform. It is a mistake to suppose that beer will not rob a man or a woman of the use of reason; for I have seen it do it many times.—J. L. Corning, in Christian Register.