From the Literary Digest we learn of a volume by Mr. Thomas Dixon, Jr., pastor of the People’s Church in New York, under the above title. The author takes New York for a sample, and claims that the test is a fair one. From this he proceeds to demonstrate that the churches of to-day come utterly short of fulfilling their mission. The “Introductory Note” is quite characteristic:—
This little book says and proves that Protestantism is a failure in New York. Three answers have already been hurled at my head by the theological grannies in this neighborhood. “You are an infidel!” “You are a sensationalist!” “You are a failure yourself!” Quite true, dear grannies, from your point of view. But the answers are irrelevant.
I might be an infidel with full-grown horn, hoof, and tail, and still Protestantism be a failure in New York; or I might be so supremely orthodox as to believe that Pope Leo XIII is the scarlet woman of the Apocalypse, and that every man who differs with me in this view is a liar, a thief, a hypocrite, a brute, or a Jesuit—and still Protestantism might be a failure in New York.
Then, suppose I am a sensationalist. What of it? Truth is stronger than fiction, and nature more miraculous than miracle. The most sensational discoveries of this city have all been simple facts. A statement may be sensational, and its author a prophet or a clown, a philosopher or a fool, and yet it may be a fact.
Again, it may be true that I am a failure—all the greater pity, since I am a Protestant minister! This is not an answer. It is a confirmation. It is a confession. This is simply piling on the agony!
As to figures, the author gives the following statements:—
The following table shows the apparent gain in church-membership during the last decade in leading Protestant churches:—
| 1885 | 1887 | 1891 | 1892 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baptist | 13,669 | 13,687 | 13,952 | 14,644 | Net | increase | 975 |
| Methodist | 12,588 | 12,981 | 13,280 | 14,140 | “ | “ | 1,552 |
| Presbyterian | 20,308 | 23,016 | 23,299 | 24,737 | “ | “ | 4,429 |
| Lutheran | 14,000 | 14,000 | ........ | 13,375 | “ | decrease | 625 |
The Baptists increased 975 during the seven years from 1885 to 1892. The normal birth-rate of their membership, 13,669, should have given an increase by birth of more than 3500 during this period, their accessions from other Baptist churches more than balancing their death-rate. The Baptists, therefore, managed to hold about one fourth of the children born into their homes. Is this “holding our own”?
The Methodists increased 1552 during these seven years. The birth-rate should give the Methodists in this time about 3521. So our Methodist friends, with their matchless zeal, managed to hold nearly one half the children born in their homes. Is this “holding our own”?
The Presbyterians increased 4429 during these seven years. Their normal birth-rate should have given them an increase of 5684. So our Presbyterian friends, with their enormous wealth and prestige, peculiar to New York City, massed in their eighty-one churches, managed to hold about two thirds of the children born in their homes. Is this “holding our own”?
But these figures do not tell all the pitiful story. Every one knows, who knows anything about the history of New York churches, that the rolls are not kept to-day as they were twenty or thirty years ago. Then church enrolment meant a pretty accurate summary of the members on the field; now some of our churches keep even the dead on their rolls, on the ground that their establishment extends over this world and the next! One of these mushroom records collapsed the other day by a fire, and out of a roll of over 4000, there could not be found 200 members! This is undoubtedly an extreme case, but it is to the point. There are actually fewer Baptists in New York to-day than there were twenty years ago; there are fewer Methodists than there were twenty years ago.